Tôji Temple, Five-story Pagoda, Kyoto
BatĂ´ Hiroshige Museum of Art, Tochigi
JAPANESE CREATIVITY — CONTEMPLATIONS ON JAPANESE ARCHITECTURE
YUICHIRO EDAGAWA
15 Foreword 16 Introduction
20 CHARACTERISTICS OF JAPANESE ARCHITECTURAL CREATIVITY 22 31 40 47 56 64
Intimacy with Nature Importance of Materials Simplicity and Denial of Ornamentation Craftsmanship and Skill of Master Woodworkers Bipolarity and Diversity Spirit of Coexistence
72 CHARACTERISTICS OF JAPANESE ARCHITECTURAL COMPOSITION 74 82 90 98 106 114
Asymmetry Culture of Addition Devotion to Small Space Organic Form Sense of “Oku = Inner Zone” Do Not Show the Whole
120 FORMATIVE DEVELOPMENT FROM PARTS 122 136
Parts Precede the Whole/ “Now = Here” Principle Compositional Principles
148 WHAT DOES “PARTS PRECEDE THE WHOLE” ACCOMPLISH? 150 167
Case Studies My Design Work on Nibancho Garden
178 SUMMARY 186 Author 188 List of References Cited 189 List of Illustrations Cited 191 Imprint
Foreword
Yuichiro Edagawa’s book is an epoch-making work that describes what “Japaneseness” is. What lies at the root of Japanese creativity and its architectural artifacts? By analyzing a wide variety of exemplary buildings from the sixth century to the present, Edagawa determines twelve distinctive characteristics of Japanese architectural creativity and composition, including intimacy with nature, importance of materials, bipolarity and diversity, asymmetry, devotion to small space, and organic form. Most of all, this book explains that distinctive features of Japanese architecture derive from the design method “parts precede a whole,” which is an unprecedented architectural way of studying. It is significantly important to publish this work in English and to appeal to a worldwide audience. There have been very few studies on Japanese architecture written in English and because of the recent rise of interest in Japanese architecture, it has been a great challenge to promote the understanding of Japanese architectural wonders. In this sense, the English publication will be a great contribution for foreign scholars who are interested in Japanese architecture and will also respond to the expectations of many foreign people interested in exchange with Japanese culture. Kengo Kuma 15
Introduction
In 2008 in Germany, I published a photo and interpretation book titled Japanese Identities: Architecture between Aesthetics and Nature introducing Japanese architecture to a worldwide audience in the English and German languages (Edagawa 2008). The first page opened with the following photograph and words: The publication was my humble attempt to show people overseas the beauty and magnificence of Japanese architecture. I wanted to introduce scenes created by Japanese people that are characteristic of Japan, show the original creativity of the Japanese, and that have cultural and/or historical impact, and which I considered beautiful. The book was well accepted as a guide book for Japanese architecture and was widely distributed around the world. But within myself, there existed the thought that the level of the book didn’t dig deep enough to introduce Japanese architecture and culture. As an architect, I have been given many opportunities to design various buildings, and at the same time, I have tried to experience as much architecture as possible. Observing a number of old and new buildings in detail, I cannot help but sense a certain nature such as basic stance of creativity of the Japanese continuously streaming through them. This is the inner sensibility of the Japanese, which might be an inherited gene and DNA among us. There is an apparent commonality in what the Japanese regard as beautiful, comfortable and what holds us in awe. This is what I want to dig into. 16
1 Five-story Pagoda, Kofukuji Temple, Nara. This is the place where it all started. Some years ago, I had the chance to visit the ancient city of Nara, and I visited this very spot. This is one of the most representative settings for a scenic encounter with Nara. Looking up at the pagoda, I was astonished by its beauty: the originality and harmonious beauty of its form, the tactful use of natural materials, and the rationality of its structure. I was so proud to notice the essences of the ancient Japanese people’s creativity. I will never forget the strong feeling that welled up within me—to introduce what Japanese people once created to a worldwide audience.
17
But how can I describe and explain this in detail? By focusing on Japanese architectural artifacts that strongly exemplify a Japanese identity and by describing distinctive characteristics that are at the source of an architectural “Japaneseness.” In this book, I will deepen the understanding of the relativity of these characteristics and what are behind Japanese-like perceptions. I will also try to refer to the kind of architecture to which these characteristics might lead. By studying the distinctive features of Japanese architecture, I want to: • organize existing ideas and studies on Japanese architectural characteristics • come up with new relations and interpretations between and behind these features, through new comprehensive and bird’s-eye views, in addition to the individual perspectives of existing ideas and studies • create a more essential understanding of Japanese identities through new interpretations and viewpoints • verify what kind of architecture Japanese identities might create • find a way to interpret and explain Japanese identities as a whole What we especially have to take into consideration is that, when we talk about the distinctive features of Japanese architecture, it is likely that basic attitudes of creation, such as intimacy with nature and emphasis on natural materials, and morphological
I
ntimacy with Nature
One of the most distinctive features of Japanese architecture is no doubt its close relationship with the surrounding natural environment. Architecture, in harmony with its natural surroundings, is treated as if it were integrated with them. Japanese architecture is not intended to surpass nature, but it can be said to coexist with nature. This is to say, in general, nature in Japan is gentle and people appreciate most of the gifts of nature, and therefore our ancestors followed the way of symbiosis with nature. This is in great contrast to architecture in the Western world, which tends to be isolated from nature and appears to want to assert itself over nature. In his work Characteristics of Japanese Architecture, Hirotaro Ota describes Japanese architecture as follows: Japanese architecture is not intended to confront nature; rather, even though it is man-made, it is considered to be just a tiny scene of nature like a tree. ‌ Japanese architecture shows a humble stance with its friendly attitude toward nature rather than with its strong presence as an individual. What Japanese architects aimed for was not a highlighted imposing structure, but a humble structure harmonizing with nature. (Ota 1954) What do Japanese people look at and feel when they stand in front of an architectural structure? Ota’s description follows: Here is a famous waka poem by the twelfth-century monk Saigyo Hoshi. This poem was read when he visited the Grand Shrine of Ise: nanigoto no owashimasu kawa shiranedomo,
22
2 Nageiredo Hall, showing its harmonious relationship with nature (built around AD 1100, location: Misasa-cho, Tottori). This is a most typical example of Hirotaro Ota’s description, namely, “an architectural structure showing a humble stance with its friendly attitude toward nature rather than its strong presence as an individual.”
katajikenasa ni namida koboreru (loosely: I do not know what god there is, but feeling utterly blessed, I am deeply moved to tears). (Ota 1954) What impressed Saigyo so deeply? Was he moved by the beauty of the architecture itself, which Bruno Taut described as “the greatest piece of creative architecture in the world”? Probably not. More likely, Saigyo was impressed by the thick cedar grove, the simple shrine building made of plain wood, and, moreover, by the harmony between the architecture and its environment. Thus, it is needless to say that Japanese architecture bears great relevance to the surrounding environment and has a strong symbiotic attitude to nature. And it is natural that, in the process of creating each piece of architecture, this symbiotic attitude to nature leads to more attention being paid to each part of the structure to allow it to adapt to the surrounding nature. In this chapter of the book, I study various pieces of architecture that are symbiotic with nature in order to attempt to study the basic influences that are brought about by the symbiotic attitude of the Japanese to nature. Nageiredo Hall, Sanbutsuji Temple, Tottori Prefecture
23
2
This is one of the most representative examples of this attitude, which clearly shows the harmonious relationship between nature and Japanese architecture. The hall stands in a natural cave half way up the steep cliff of a sacred mountain. Nageire means “to throw in.” It is not certain how this hall was built, but legend has
Townscape of Two Medieval Towns
1 The Japanese being particular about materials themselves. 12, 13 Sanno-machi developed as a merchant town at the center of Takayama castle town, which was called the “Little Kyoto of Hida.” As evidenced by the fact that it was designated as a “Preservation District for Groups of Traditional Buildings” by the Japanese government, the district conserves its buildings and townscape from the late Edo period. By contrast, the old town of Rothenburg in Germany, also known as a medieval jewel, preserved the exact historical townscape in its postwar reconstruction. Because Rothenburg is close to the rich timber-producing areas of the Schwarzwald (the Black Forest), it has a lot of wooden structures that are similar to Japanese culture, but the design appears to be totally different. In Western Europe, wood is mostly covered by colorfully painted plaster, while in Japan the wood itself is highlighted by the characteristic design of woodwork, and the overall simplicity plays the key role. By comparing these two examples, it can be seen that there is a great difference in the way they handle and insist on materials.
12 Sanno-machi, Takayama Gifu Pref. Here it is clear how the Japanese insist on wood; characteristic lattice works continue on both sides of the street. Painted in a blackish color that is a mixture of red iron oxide and persimmon soot, the buildings preserve the goodness of wood as it is. 13 Rothenburg, Germany. Most of the buildings in the town are wooden structures; nonetheless, they are completely covered by colorfully painted plaster. As a result, they lack the characteristics of natural wooden buildings.
32
14 Katsura Imperial Palace, Kyoto (constructed over several decades after 1615). Wood, bamboo, Japanese paper, plaster, etc. insist on their existence as they are. Differences in their natural qualities bring about the deep flavor of the exterior finish. 15 Santa Maria del Fiore, Firenze, Italy (completed: 1436, architect: Filippo Brunelleschi). This building is surprisingly colorful and beautiful. This is why it is referred to as the “Cathedral of the Flower.” The exterior wall is covered with finely cut pieces of colored marble that are treated just as colored pieces, with no claims as stone material.
33
Handling of Exterior Finishing Materials
2 Each material insists upon its presence. 14, 15 The buildings at Katsura Imperial Palace in Kyoto are in the sukiya style, which utilizes the very best of diverse natural materials and enjoys their refined taste. As seen in the photo, wood, bamboo, Japanese paper, plaster, etc., insist on their existence as they are and thus express a simple and delicate beauty. By contrast, in Florence, the Renaissance Cathedrale di Santa Maria del Fiore (Cathedral of Saint Mary of the Flower) owes its glamorous beauty to the colorful marble decoration of the exte rior finishing. Here, marble, cut into tiny pieces, loses its original stone-like characteristics. The marble cuts are merely built into the wall decoration and engraved as colored pieces. This is a typical comparative example in which major differences are found in the handling of materials in Japan and in the West. Handling of Interior Finishing Materials
3 Materials bear clear identification of insistence as a part of architecture. 16, 17 The interior design of the magnificent Alhambra in Granada, Spain, which is a highlight of Islamic culture, is simply overwhelming. The numerous tiles, stone pieces, and plaster works
S
implicity and Denial of Ornamentation
Japanese architecture features natural materials used as they are (mainly wood), and its form is likely to be simple and lucid. Structural frameworks are not hidden but are meant to express formative beauty. Ornamental elements are limited so that the materials used are appreciated as they are. The technique and know-how of the master carpenters are, of course, essential. Thus, the architecture completely reflects simplicity and purity in nature. Why are the Japanese fond of such simple architecture? Once, on the occasion of publishing a book of mine in Germany, I was interviewed by a magazine publisher and responded to this question: “Naturally, the Japanese interpretation of the void is not merely emptiness but, more than that, a borderless space for meditation and creativity. Therefore, it is possible to create a pure, simple, sophisticated structure to represent any significant architecture.� It can probably be said that such an abundance of rich imagination and creativity has allowed the Japanese to abandon unnecessary decorations. Simplicity is inevitable with the materials used for construction, so it is possible to exhibit freer imagination and creativity with a minimum of installations. A tea ceremony room, in which the host is able to express his intention in a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity by arranging a flower or by hanging a scroll in the alcove, is a typical example. With a single branch of cherry tree blossoms, guest and host can share the illusion that they are sitting under cherry trees in full bloom. Because of these spiritual and cultural characteristics, the
40
24 Main hall of Inner Shrine (rebuilt every twenty years, which is also the only occasion when the building is exposed to public). This is the prototype for all buildings in Japan. Although it is a symbol of authority, the nondecorativeness of its nature is remarkable. 25 Inner Shrine being rebuilt on the contiguous lot. Surrounded by natural forest, this shrine makes one feel this is a place where god descends.
41
Japanese have respected and enjoyed simple taste without excessive ornamentation. Below, I will look at examples of architecture that embody this simplicity throughout the ages. Ise Jingu Inner Shrine, Mie Prefecture
24, 25
In the midst of the divine forest, which covers one million square meters in the city of Ise, the Inner Shrine stands as it did 2,000 years ago. The shrine buildings are completely rebuilt on the contiguous lot every twenty years to ensure ritual purity, and the old buildings are dismantled. Thus, the original form and technique are preserved with all of their details. Of course, this practice is enormously costly, so Ise-jingu is the only shrine today that is regularly rebuilt, though this was common practice for many shrines in the past. The style of the main sanctuary building is distinctive to Ise- jingu, and this is the purest and most simplified style of S hinto architecture, which is unique to Japan. This style is said to be the form of a house with a raised floor, which was used to store rice about 2,000 years ago. The impression of the building is ex tremely simple and linear, using unfinished Japanese cypress, a thatched roof, and pillars erected without foundations in the ground. The sanctuary is enclosed by four rows of board fences and may not be approached by general worshippers. On his visit to this site, the famed German architect Bruno Taut compared Ise-jingu with the Pantheon in Greece saying, “This is
The reconstruction of the Western Pagoda involved various ideas. Each lean-to of the Eastern Pagoda, which is now plastered white, was X-rayed, and it was discovered from the joints that there were latticed windows, which are now restored on the Western Pagoda. The height of the Western Pagoda was raised by thirty-three centimeters in anticipation of subsidence caused by its own weight. And to reduce the total weight, the amount of sand under the roof tiles was cut. But moreover, it is quite interesting to listen to what Nishioka, the master carpenter who led the total reconstruction, has to say because it shows the wisdom and skill of a master craftsman. As for the rafters, it’s the same. The rafters for the Eastern Tower are 5 suns × 5 suns [a sun is a Japanese unit of length, approximately 3.03 cm] or 4.5 suns × 4.5 suns, all mixed. But when assembled as a whole, they are in good harmony. The total feeling is so serene. By contrast, for the Eastern Pagoda, the rafters are cut by machine to exactly 5 suns × 5 suns and, as a result, the pagoda looks hard as if cast in a mold. When really sharp spear-head hand planes are used, even when the whittled surface is exposed to rain, the rain will just wash off. But when electric planers are used, the surface will be soaked when exposed to rain, and as a result black mold will grow. Then the life of the tree as a material is shortened. In this sense, all the wood used for this pagoda is finished by hand using spear-head planes so that it will last for a thousand years. (Nishioka 1981)
31 Reconstructed Western Pagoda (reconstruction completed: 1981, location: Nara, master carpenter: Tsunekazu Nishioka). According to Nishioka, because the main components including rafters were cut by machine, they are of the same dimensions and look hard as if cast in a mold. Many things need to be carefully considered when handling trees as natural materials.
48
32  Eastern Pagoda, which has survived since the seventh century. The design and reconstruction of the Western Pagoda was only possible because of the existence of the Eastern Pagoda. In terms of aesthetical sensibility and construction techniques, these were the most advanced structures more than 1,300 years ago.
49
It has been said that the lean-to that makes the pagoda seem to be six stories is a matter of pure design. But the fact is, according to Nishioka: Once the roof of the lean-to is set, the swaying of the Âtower stops at once. It was understood that the tower was stable because of this lean-to. It is impossible to design such an interesting structure. Owing to the existence of the Eastern Pagoda, we were able to design and reconstruct the Western Pagoda. 32 The insights of the master craftsman are astute. Nishioka points out: As for the Pagoda of Horyuji Temple, the framework members are thick and not calculated precisely. Whereas for the towers of Yakushiji Temple, the members are thin and the lean-to plays the role of an anti-seismic damper. The difference between the construction periods of the two buildings is only several decades and it is not possible to make such progress in such a short time. The techniques that were used to construct Horyuji Temple probably came in over time from the Korean Peninsula, whereas for Yakushiji Temple it is natural to consider that advanced techniques came in directly from the Tang dynasty of mainland China. Trees grow naturally, and exposed to sunlight and wind, each tree is different; one is twisted to the right, another to the left. It is important to combine them according to their characteristics so that the torsion strength comes to zero and the tower will not twist. (Nishioka 1981)
designed in a different architectural style. The first floor is built in a residential style, while the second floor is designed as a Buddha hall (housing an image of the Bodhisattva Kannon), and the third floor is in Zen style (holding Buddha’s ashes). In general, Japanese architecture is understood to be simple and understated, with a refined sense of design and use of natural materials. But here at the Golden Pavilion, the second and third floors are completely covered in gold leaf and, as a result, the building offers a startling and gorgeous image. At the same time, the composition of the pavilion precinct in particular provides a sense of balance between the sumptuous and the simple. This reminds me of how gold leaf folding screen is used in an understated room to indicate a special place. At the foot of the Kitayama Mountains in a sea of green, the Golden Pavilion suddenly appears and its beauty is immediately apparent, making the depiction by Yukio Mishima in his novel Temple of the Golden Pavilion redundant. A young Buddhist priest burned down the original in 1950, being enchanted by, and yet attempting to dominate, the pavilion’s beauty. The pavilion was rebuilt in 1955 as a perfect replica of the original.
40 Golden Pavilion (originally built in 1398) and its reflection on the lake. This is the most beautiful scene of which Japan is proud. The beauty of its reflection shining on the surface of the lake, the gorgeousness of the gold-leaf-pasted structure, and its harmony with the surrounding trees—it is not difficult to explain why this scene is so beautiful. But why did it suddenly appear? This could only be explained by its sense of bipolarity.
Golden Tea-Ceremony Room, MOA Museum, Shizuoka Prefecture 41
This is also a tea-ceremony room that was originally created by Rikyu. The restoration was carried out by leading scholars of architectural history. Built about the same time as the creation of
60
41 Golden teaceremony room (original work by Rikyu, restored by scholars). Why did Rikyu create this tea-ceremony room at the same time as Taian, which is highly esteemed as the ultimate in restrained and understated elegance? While the use of gold is moderate and unpolished, such an example could only be explained by bipolarity.
Taian, and the ultimate example of restrained and understated elegance, this tea-ceremony room was constructed by order of Hideyoshi. These two examples created by the same person at almost the same time clearly show the bipolar feature of the Japanese. Before I actually saw the Golden Tea-Ceremony Room for the first time, I took it to be a dazzling fake, but I was surprised that I experienced no such impression on seeing it. Rather, I was able to feel the result of exhaustive studies in pursuit of the summit that were common to Taian. Scarlet tatami mats and paper screens were really effective, and though the tea sets looked like gold, all the other architectural fixtures did not seem to be real gold; rather, I could feel the excellence of the close study of the materials. A court noble who attended the tea ceremony to which Hideyoshi invited the Emperor kept a diary, in which he wrote that “the walls seemed earthen not golden,” which was the same impression as mine. It could be said that an uncommon nobleness hung in the air. The Japanese sense of beauty is hidden in the moderate way according to which the gold was not brilliantly polished. Nikko Toshogu Shrine, Tochigi Prefecture
61
42, 43
There is a saying that “one does not know what beauty really is until one has seen Nikko Shrine.” The buildings of Nikko Toshogu, which are so brilliantly colored and richly decorated with deep relief carvings, are so beautiful yet quite different from other Japanese architecture.
not only pottery but all other tools and tea-ceremony rooms. Although it may give a stiff impression to look at shin-gyo-so as a determined promise, in fact, the Japanese way of accepting foreign culture is seen in this classification. From those things that were Japanized by breaking from their original forms and whose changes, through decisive simplification, disguised themselves as different things from original figures, it is interesting to know not only the development from Chinese tools to Japanese tools but also how to understand Japanese culture, namely, shin-gyo-so from the viewpoint of “to imitate, to put in disorder, to disguise.” When we look at things in this way, it is understood that shin-g yoso is a concept that can help us uniformly comprehend different styles and forms. In his work Thoughts in Japanese Design, Teiji Ito says: The people often say that our culture was familiar with neither negation nor conquest. Once architecture, gardens, industrial arts, and even entertainment were born, their styles continued to exist without being destroyed. … If the new style was born as the result of negation and conquest of the old style, it is natural that the old style should be forgotten in the new era. … The history and the characteristics of our culture, in the design field, were expressed in the form of shingyo-so. (Ito 1966) It is possible to organize various different styles by shin-gyo-so and to justify the presence of each style, and it can be said that
51 Dojinsai study room, Togudo, Jishoji Temple (Silver Pavilion), Kyoto. Shin: Formal form based on the samurai lifestyle, so neat and rigid.
70
52 Middle garden guest house, Shugakuin Imperial Villa, Kyoto. Gyo: A playful mind is strongly reflected in the staggered shelves, wall design, and sliding screen paintings. 53 Jo-an Tearoom, Aichi Pref. So: Keen-edged space with minimum components.
71
shin-gyo-so has promoted the coexistence and collateral of various styles and forms. But it is more correct to say it has prompted the sense that it is natural to have three styles/three states for anything. The fact is that such a value system has become widely rooted in Japanese culture, and that the formation of collateral coexisting culture without negation are both sides of the same coin. Shin-gyo-so is a very useful concept that makes it possible to jus tify the existence of various styles in general by just using the term when there are various architectural styles and forms in Japan. For example, among existing shoin architecture, which developed in the lifestyle of samurai, Dojinsai, a study room of Togudo Hall, Jishoji Temple, which is said to be the origin of that architectural style, is ranked shin; shoin architecture in the sukiya style that avoided the stiff atmosphere of samurai life is classified as gyo; and the ultimate thatched hut used as a tea-ceremony room can be ranked so. Thus, any coexisting style can be explained by this shin-gyo-so. 51, 52, 53 From ancient times, when the objects of religious belief that were linked directly to daily life were diverse and there was no absolute code for determining how one must behave, “sensitivity without denial” or the “mentality that anything goes” was cultivated. This mentality of the Japanese accepted foreign culture without resistance and created the way for justifying the collateral coexistence of diverse possibilities. It can be said that this developed the grounds for the parts to assert themselves freely.
Main Hall
Worship Hall Copper Torii
Kyoto Imperial Palace, Kyoto
Kyoto Imperial Palace is one of the most typical and representative architectural constructions in Japan. The current Kyoto Imperial Palace used to be one of the temporary palaces that had been built outside the original Heian Palace. It had been the Imperial Palace from 1331 to 1869, when the capital was moved to Tokyo. During this period, there were repeated instances of fire and reconstruction; extensions were also built, adding new functions.
58 Slightly misaligned configuration. The Copper Torii and Worship Hall, and a glimpse of the ornamental rafter ends of the Main Hall in the rear slightly misaligned. Obviously, this is intended to give a feeling of depth. 59 The Main Hall. Under symmetric culture, it is important to show off the existence of the main structure, but under a Japanese configuration, the whole of the Main Hall is hidden. 60 Birds-eye sketch It is understood that the Copper Torii, Worship Hall, and Main Hall are intentionally misaligned. The function of each component is important, and the mutual relationship of the absolute position of the components is not of great importance.
78
61 Kogosho, Ogakumonjo, Otsunegoten (from left). The placement of each building is likely determined spontaneously. There seems to be no intention to regulate the placement and form of each building from the overall image of the palace. Rather, the relationship between the buildings and exterior spaces is of great importance. As a result, asymmetry is inevitable. 62 Shishinden (Hall of State Ceremonies). The neglecting of symmetry by planting.
79
From Shishinden (Hall of State Ceremonies) to Otsunegoten and beyond to the Chosetsu Teahouse via Kogosho and Ogakumonjo, extensions continued northward. The buildings were added by crossing their ridges at right angles and by adding connecting corridors. What was considered important were the relationships between added buildings, the grand Oikeniwa Garden, and o ther exterior spaces. The layout of the extensions was determined spontaneously, which differs significantly from the strong assertion of symmetry that is found in the West, at the Chateau de Versailles or the Schönbrunn Palace of Vienna. 61 This is the front face of Shishinden, which is the most formal face of the Kyoto Imperial Palace. The building was built symmetrically to conform to an ancient rite but, as if to eliminate this symmetry, a pair of trees were planted—a tachibana tree on the right and a cherry tree on the left. Although these trees were planted in accordance with the ancient rite and the origin of this planting has also been communicated through time, morphologically it is clear that there was an intention to eliminate the tension of symmetry. It is said that the cherry tree was at first a plum tree, but in any case, an evergreen tree and a deciduous tree were paired to display asymmetry. 62 Since the introduction of jori-sei (the ancient Japanese system of land subdivision), there have been attempts in our country to fix the symmetrical order numerous times, but it is likely that on each occasion there was some influence to exclude symmetry. Here, one of the origins of this power is acknowledged.
C
ulture of Addition
Addition (Katsura Imperial Villa, Kyoto)
65, 66
The culture of “formative development from parts to the whole” is in a sense the “culture of addition” (Ito 1996). From investigations undertaken during dismantling and repair work at the Katsura Imperial Villa in Kyoto, it was found that a series of buildings ranging from Old Shoin and Middle Shoin to the New Palace had been added. 67 By orthogonally connecting these buildings, it was possible to create a rich relationship with the garden and realize a segmentation of the function of the space to create a more private New Palace. As for Japanese culture, the evolution of creativity does not necessarily mean that the old is denied and replaced with the new. It is possible to enable coexistence with the old by adding the new. The total composition of the buildings of Katsura Imperial Villa is a perfect example of the result of the addition of parts, which are Old Shoin, Middle Shoin, and the New Palace. Orthogonal Design/Flying Geese Pattern (Nijo Castle, Kyoto)
Ninomaru Palace in Nijo Castle was built almost at the same time as Katsura Imperial Villa but differed because all of its buildings were constructed simultaneously, each with its own function. The palace is the result of the addition of functions. 68 In Japanese architecture, huge roofs are avoided by keeping the gradient. Large buildings in terms of depth are not built and extensions are made by orthogonally connecting separate buildings
82
65 Old Shoin. 66 New Palace, Musical Instrument Room, Middle Shoin (from left). 67 Plan of main buildings of Katsura Imperial Villa (constructed over several decades after 1615).
New Palace
Middle Shoin
83
Old Shoin
Rock Garden, Ryoanji Temple, Kyoto
80, 81
This is the world-famous Rock Garden of Ryoanji Temple. This simple yet remarkable garden measures only twenty-five meters by ten meters but is meant to represent the whole universe. The rectangular Zen garden is completely different from other gorgeous gardens constructed in the Middle Ages. Neither trees nor water are used; the garden consists of only fifteen rocks and white gravel. But behind the configuration breathe the deep thoughts of Zen Buddhism. Visitors sit on the veranda facing the garden to gaze at it. It is for the visitors to decide what and how they think of this abstract garden. The longer one looks at it, the more varied one’s imaginations will probably become. The white gravel is often compared to the sea and the rocks to islands. But I see them as a sea of clouds and protruding peaks. It is often explained that there are fifteen rocks in the garden. But regardless of where one sits, it is impossible to see all fifteen at one glance, which signifies the imperfect nature of humankind. The low earthen wall surrounding the garden is also of great importance. It is made of clay boiled in oil, from which the color seeps out and leads to a peculiar design over the course of time. Also, an intentional perspectival effect was created by decreasing the height of the wall toward the distant corner. The garden is said to have been created by multitalented Soami, who died in 1525, but no one is quite sure. There are many opinions as to the creator and the creative intention of the garden.
80  Everyone stares at the garden (said to have been built in the late fifteenth century). Sitting on the veranda, everyone gazes at the garden. Recently, there are more visitors from foreign countries due to the worldwide Zen boom. A Japanese rock garden, where water is expressed without its being used, hides symbolic meanings in this small space. 81  The surrounding earthen wall. The presence of this tasteful earthen wall, which regulates the small space, contributes greatly to the formality and the sense of existence of the garden.
94
82 Koishikawa Korakuen Garden in Tokyo (Edo period clan garden, construction started in 1629). Shukukei of famous scenery in Kyoto: the Katsuragawa River and Togetsukyo Bridge in Arashiyama. 83 Amanohashidate in Katsura Imperial Villa.
95
Shukukei (an artificial scene constructed in a garden, which mimicked a famous natural scene) in the Gardens 82
Koishikawa Korakuen Garden is a strolling type of garden begun in 1629 by Yorifusa Tokugawa, first feudal lord of the Mito Tokugawa family, and finished by his son, Mitsukuni Tokugawa, as a garden attached to the residence, and the names of places of beauty from across the country are used here and there. The photograph is of famous scenery in Kyoto: the Katsuragawa River and Togetsukyo Bridge in Arashiyama; and it is possible to imagine that this setting was created according to the cherished memory of this Kyoto scene and with a strong yearning for it. In this case, a hint or a motive from natural scenery creates a configuration incorporating the essential qualities of a scene into the garden, which is called shukukei. Here, numerous shukukei elements are scattered through the garden, the aggregation of which constitutes the whole. Here we can also clearly see the characteristic quality of the Japanese way of configuration that is devoted to the parts, and in which parts precede the whole. The next example is a shukukei in the Katsura Imperial Villa, Kyoto. On the way to one of the teahouses, Shokintei (known as Pine-Lute Pavillion), one has a view of Amanohashidate (a natural sandbar known as one of the three most beautiful spots in Japan). It is said that this setting is associated with the scenic beauty of Tango, the birthplace of the princess of Prince Tomohito, who created this villa. The garden of the Katsura Imperial
breeze, one can notice the flow of air by the movement of ribbons and threads hanging in the space, which are the work of Naito. One will clearly notice the birdsong and the sound of cicadas in the hall, which are sounds that cannot be noticed outside. Looking upward through the hole, one will once again become conscious of the clear blue sky, innocent white clouds, and deep green of the trees. Here, each of the five senses is sharpened and activated. Here and there on the floor of the hall, water drops spring out and flow, join together, and grow. What will one feel, in the experience of such living evidence, through such stimulated sensitivities? Everyone visiting here sits on the floor and meditates. The internal space is somehow quite comfortable. This may be because the outline surrounding the space is organic and natural, and the geometric enclosure remains unnoticed. 98 As one moves about in the hall, the exterior seen through the hole is quite different. Springs on the floor and drops of water vary. When interviewed, the staff who spend their days in this art space answered: This art space definitely consists of an aggregation of parts. The impression of the space differs completely according to place, time, weather, season, etc. Every morning, we start with wiping off the water, gathering fallen leaves, wiping and cleaning the floor, and we find that the drama that develops in each part of the hall is so diverse. We can’t but feel the great energy that has been infused into every part of the space.
97  Interior of the museum hall. The structure is planned so as to prepare for the delicate water drops of Rei Naito that spring out, join together, and grow to become flows of water. The structure requires maximum consideration of the detailed parts of the architecture. This space consists of the elaborate aggregation of those parts.
104
98  Looking up into the sky. Both the unification of the interior and the outside world, and the outside seen from inside through the hole, are full of new discoveries.
105
It is obvious that this space has been created primarily by the aggregation of a careful devotion to every part of the total structure. For those architectural structures of natural organic forms that have been encountered so far in this chapter it is evident that the creation process, in each case, involves parts preceding the whole being seriously considered, and that the creation process is the result of the individual production of single articles. Mass production of such structures is completely out of the question, which, however, makes it possible to sense the depth of architecture that is brought about by intensive labor. The charm of Japanese architecture is based on an original sensitivity that cannot be measured by Western rationality. It could be said that this is where the characteristics of the Japanese identity that aims to create “from the parts to the whole� is clearly revealed.
Main Approach to the Ginkakuji Temple (Silver Pavilion), Kyoto 99
Here is the approaching path to the Ginkakuji Temple from the main gate to the inner gate. This approach plays a major role in the layout of the precinct. Visitors cannot enter the garden directly from the main gate but are forced to walk a distance and make two right-angled turns. A fifty-meter-long approach space surrounded by bamboo fences called the “Ginkakuji hedge” was thus created, and this space is quite effective in demonstrating the concept of oku. Some talk about the defensive implications of the approach, but away from the hustle and bustle of the city, this space in fact has an absolute effect as an approach to the world of Higashiyama culture of the mid-Muromachi period. 100 Nezu Museum, Tokyo
99 Site plan of Ginkakuji Temple (founded in 1490). 100 Approaching path and the “Ginkakuji Hedge”. A unique space where visibility is restricted and a feeling of depth more than actual distance is recognized.
101
The space of approach to the newly rebuilt Nezu Museum in Tokyo, which was designed by Kengo Kuma, is nothing but a production of oku. Away from the bustle of the capital’s Aoyama district, where there are many fashionable boutiques, it is an introductory space to a silent art museum. And at this point we change our mind-set, become calm, and ready ourselves to enter the world of art. Entering from the front street, we see that the structure of space has a particular effect (the composition of this particular part of the whole) created by making two orthogonal turns. This space and its effect can be said to be the product of Japanese DNA that has been cultivated through the long history of Japan. 102
108
101 Site plan of Nezu Museum (built: 2009, architect: Kengo Kuma, location: Tokyo). 102 Approaching path producing the wonder of oku. Make a right turn from the street and you are here, and after walking along this path, make a left turn and you will reach the entrance. Expectations increase by not being able to see oku. This is a distinctive Japanese space structure.
Dazaifu Tenmangu Shrine, Fukuoka Prefecture
Fushimi Inari Taisha Shrine, Kyoto
109
103
The production of oku at Dazaifu Tenmangu Shrine is quite interesting. The main approaching path to the shrine first passes through a line of souvenir shops, then makes a left turn and goes straight through a tower gate to the main building. In between, visitors cross two big arched bridges over Shinjiike Pond. A visitor is purified by crossing the water, but more importantly, as one goes up and down the arched bridges, the sight of the main building accordingly appears and disappears. The layer of space is thus acknowledged and, layer by layer, one proceeds to oku, which is the most sacred space. Within a linear approach space, there lies an admirable production through which oku is to be acknowledged. Similarly, a representative straight approaching path is found at Tsurugaoka Hachimangu Shrine in Kamakura, where there is a great difference in the level of the ground as one proceeds. In this case, the great stairway plays a major role in the configuration that allows one to recognize the feeling of oku. 104
This path leads to the inner precinct of Fushimi Inari Taisha Shrine. This place is called the “Senbon Torii,” meaning a thousand torii gates. It is so unique that one will not find a similar place. Fushimi Inari Taisha is worshipped as a god for prosperous trade, and individuals who were successful in their business donated each of these red torii gates, built in a consecutive series
Unlike people in the West who will compose the whole in a c learly logical manner and show the whole aspect, it is important for the Japanese to accumulate parts and to produce a sense of oku. In this way, the Japanese attain a more holy and solemn feeling.
118 The Long Walk, Windsor Castle, England. 119 Entrance bridge of Ise Jingu, Inner Shrine.
Case of an Approach to a Private Space
The Herrenchiemsee New Palace, which was built on Herreninsel (gentlemen’s island) by the Bavarian King Ludwig II on the Chiemsee, Bavaria’s largest lake, about sixty kilometers southeast of Munich, was meant to be a replica of the Palace of Versailles, which had been built by French King Louis XIV. Both this grand approach, which can be called the complete form of the French garden, and the setting are designed to let visitors feel an emotional upsurge as they approach the palace’s main façade. 120 Conversely, the approach to the Katsura Imperial Villa in Japan has a completely different appearance. If you enter through the front gate and proceed to the simple Miyukimon Gate, you cannot understand the total structure of the villa at all except for this humble gate. Inside the gate, only a hedge is to be seen. As soon as one passes through this gate an orthogonal right turn is made, but still one cannot grasp the whole image. In Western culture, it is obvious that social status is expressed by an absolute sense of distance, grandeur of scale, and magnificence of arrangement. But it can be said that Japanese sensitivity, which intends to express dignity by refinedness, profoundness, and the production of oku is antipode to this intention. 121
116
120 Herrenchiemsee New Palace, Germany (constructed 1878–1886, uncompleted). 121 Miyukimon Gate, Katsura Imperial Villa. The intention not to let one see the whole is obvious. Each part of the whole has its own meaning as one proceeds.
Vista of a Garden and its Development
When one goes out onto the terrace of the Nymphenburg Palace in Munich, Germany, one sees the grand vista of a magnificent garden and waterway that continues in a straight line for several kilometers. Absolute length asserts the possession of a vast territory. 122. 123 By comparison, upon going through Miyukimon Gate at Kami- no-ochaya (Upper Teahouse) of the Shugakuin Imperial Villa, one climbs the steps carefully through clipped shrubbery. But the vista does not work at all. Once one reaches the top, there is a simple pavilion, Rinuntei, and suddenly the entire garden vista is completely revealed. Excellent borrowed scenery with superb views of the pond, its islands, and the surrounding Kyoto hills is provided, as seen in the photograph. This is the wonder of the vista itself and the sudden change. There is a great difference in the creation process, namely, the difference between the attitude of Western culture, which tends to reveal everything, and that of the Japanese, who try to create significance in each part without showing the whole image and to show the resulting change most effectively. Unobstructed View
117
124, 125
When one enters the Mirabell Gardens in the ancient city of Salz burg, Austria, which is said to be one of the most beautiful baroque gardens in Europe, one notices the strong axis in the total arrangement, which can be seen not only within the garden but
In this chapter, I will investigate this philosophy through concrete examples in order to look at what is meant by the notion of “design from parts and configure the whole.” Examples for Investigation Katsura Imperial Villa, Strolling-Type Garden, Kyoto
126
The garden of the Katsura Imperial Villa, which is designed in the kaiyu (strolling) style, is an assembly of partial optimization. In Japanese gardens, landscape is configured by organi cally combining a pond, islands, bridges, stones, and trees; these elements’ individual appearance in their specific location and their details are extremely important. In addition, architec tural structures play a key role in the garden as a specially added element because of their visual performance and location. As the rationale of the garden’s design, miniature views associ ated with natural places of beauty across the country are incorpo rated, including Amanohashidate from Tango, the hometown of the princess of Imperial Prince Tomohito, who is the creator of the whole garden. In addition, the approach is to optimize every part, right up to the steppingstones around buildings. With all these parts combined, the great spectacle that varies as one strolls through the garden can be appreciated. Whether or not there was a total image at the beginning is not the question. From the result, it is obvious that the challenge was to create the best possible total on the spot.
126 Amanohashidate Bridge and Shokintei Teahouse. The main constituent in the strolling garden is “a moving person.“ The garden consists of a pond, islands, bridges, stones, trees, and buildings—each of which is elaborately created. The landscape is configured by setting up these parts, and a person in motion appreciates the garden by combining the respective parts.
124
127 Steppingstones of the approach to Old Shoin. From such parts and each detail, it is clear that the willingness applied to their creation is tremendous. From examination of the materials to the inventive ideas of the form, it is obvious that a great deal of hard work had been put in. 128 Steppingstones from Old Shoin to Shokatei. 129 Steppingstones under the eaves of Onrindo.
125
Let’s look specifically at how committed these examples are and how they invest energy to design their parts and details. 127, 128, 129
Dogo Hot Springs Bathhouse, Ehime Prefecture
130
The bathhouse’s main building is a large-scale architectural complex mainly consisting of three-story wooden structures built basically in the Japanese style from between 1894 and 1924. To mark the 100th anniversary of the original buildings, the complex was designated as an Important Cultural Property of Japan, the first such designation for a public bathhouse. The characteristic and imposing structure is well known nationwide and has become the representative face of Matsuyama. Although the main building is not exactly Japanese-style architecture, it was built by master carpenters based on traditional techniques related to castle architecture. Extension work was carried out as needed (main extensions were added in 1894, 1899, and 1924), thus completing the present complex. The construction work was carried out without a final image, and the overall form of the building is very complicated since it is a combination of various parts with different functions. As a result, its powerful presence and total cohesiveness are worth mentioning.
Kumano Hongu Taisha Shrine
There is another document that shows the composition of Jap anese architecture in ancient times. It is the National Treasure of the Kamakura period (1185–1333): Ippen Shonin Eden (Illustrated biography of the itinerant monk Ippen). Within the document, there is an illustration showing the appearance of the shrine in those days. It is possible to understand that the total layout was not regarded as important and that each building that was part of the shrine was built according to the needs for that building at the place where construction was possible. It is said that the shrine, in those days, was built on the sands of the Kumano River, and in the Edo period (1603–1868) it was rebuilt but was washed away by a flood in the Meiji period (1868–1912). Four buildings that survived the flood, including the main hall, were then moved to the current high ground. Thus, rather than the entire configuration showing the formality of the layout as a shrine, the functions of each part were considered to be the priority. 139
138 Drawing of Joyugain Residence, Ninnaji.
Townscape of Edo (former name of Tokyo)
When we look at an old map of the city of Edo in the Edo period (1603–1868), we can see that the city spread out around a center of Edo Castle, but that the castle was merely positioned in the center and that no centripetal feature can be recognized in the plan. Around the castle, the residences of three branches of the Tokugawa families, and of hereditary daimyo (feudal lords), outside daimyo, and direct retainers of the shogun, were
130
139  Ippen Shonin Eden (Illustrated biography of itinerant monk Ippen).
131
positioned in a spiral configuration. But no positive city planning existed. The population of the city, which had developed throughout the Edo period, exceeded one million at the beginning of the eighteenth century, and Edo became one of the largest cities in the world. The towns within the city, which were called 108 (innumerable) towns, continued to multiply and sprawl in each of the city’s parts. When looking at an old map in detail, one will notice the distinction of areas for samurai, merchants, and shrines and temples. As for areas for shrines and temples, a certain intention, which is said to be the influence of feng shui, is apparent. At the same time, town layouts depend on the geographical features of places, and it is likely that the whole is constituted by the aggregation of each part. That is to say, Edo is a great combination of countless parts—namely, innumerable towns. 140 As is shown in this case, even in the planning of a gigantic city, in Japan parts come first and the whole is constituted as the result. The overall logic of urban planning does not control and regulate the state of each part. In his work Miegakuresuru-toshi (From Edo to Tokyo) Fumihiko Maki says: It is well known that the relationship between the whole image and each of its parts has always been regarded as important in the development of Western cities. The whole always had control over its parts, and when parts were to be emphasized, it was done with the strong intent of positive revolt
What is noteworthy at Hillside Terrace is that Maki elaborated sequential plans such as “vernacular,” “locality,” and multiple “linkages,” and that he pursued a compositional principle and a technique that would connect each individual part, while letting it change, to bring about an identical whole; in these efforts, he was devoted to Japanese sensitivity. With their universal Modernist taste, the architectural elements that this pursuit realized definitely embody Japanese identities such as spatial depth and folds. 7 Spatial folds 153 8 Spatial depth 154 Maki has consistently created a new urban space with the architectural vocabulary of Modernism. Using the technique of “group form,” which this chapter has introduced, and the vocabulary and concepts of multiple architectural group design, Maki succeeded in creating a group of architectural structures in which parts were valued and parts took precedence.
151 Symbiosis with nature. Originally, this district was a residential area full of green. Such a feature has been left as untouched as possible, and it has become an urban oasis space. The green on the right of the photo is a round burial mound from the Burial Mound age. The third phase buildings (completed in 1997) are constructed around the green of this mound. 152 Open courtyards. Open courts, sunken gardens, and multiple public spaces are incorporated. Such spaces induce a variety of activities.
146
153 Spatial folds. Being able to see and not able to see creates “spatial folds” (Maki 2006). These are created by an overlapping of space such as a corner indent and entrance, an independent column and a courtyard, as well as a tree and an art object. 154 Sense of spatial depth is introduced. Multiple “spatial folds” create and visualize “spatial depth.” Here, a circuit passage leads one to an inner zone and the transparency of the interior through the glass is added, and a rich “spatial depth” is composed.
147
C
ase Studies
I will make concrete investigations of cases that, at the present time, have succeeded to be among the most representative instances of the process of “parts precede the whole� having a notable influence. Nara Prefectural Office Building
This building was constructed along the main street of Nara just in front of Nara Park. It is an inspiring work designed by a diligent and skillful architect from the Ministry of Construction, Mitsuo Katayama. Katayama deliberately considered what could be most fitting for the environment of this ancient city with a history of over 1,000 years, and he carefully studied the arrangement of Buddhist temples: the gate, the surrounding corridor, the main hall, the tower, etc. 155, 156 Katayama thus came up with this design, which bears a strong resemblance to the image of the Great South Gate of Todaiji. The characteristics of his design were the deep eaves on top, the rectilinear design based on the post and lintel system, the emphasis on the horizontal lines, the multilayered arrangement to acknowledge spatial depth, and the atmosphere it evoked. These are the characteristics of traditional Japanese formative design. It was inevitable that the more Katayama tried to pursue the essential qualities of the past, the more his design took after the great heritage of Todaiji. What is noteworthy is that, as a matter of course, Katayama did not attempt to follow the image of the Great South Gate. It is
150
155 Nara Prefectural Office (built: 1965, architect: Mitsuo Katayama, location: Nara). Like a corridor, lower buildings surround the courtyard in front of the high-rise, which resembles the layout of Todaiji Temple. It can be said that the three-span entrance way is quite similar to the Great South Gate of Todaiji. 156 Great South Gate of Todaiji (rebuilt: 1199). The design essence of this structure is the emphasis on horizontal lines, deep eaves, independent columns, and the multilayered arrangement of spatial depth. These features were apparently inherited by the Nara Prefectural Office Building.
151
the parts of the building, such as the eaves, columns, and beams, on which he focused. They are, so to speak, the essences of traditional architecture, and it was from these essences (namely parts) that Katayama assembled the architectural structure. As a result, he created architecture that harmonizes with and has a suitable presence in the traditional city of Nara. This is an exact example of the Japanese identity that parts precede the whole. Makabe Denshokan
Makabe in Sakuragawa City, Ibaraki Prefecture, where the mountains extend outward from Mount Tsukuba in the background, developed as a countryside town that was home to a jinya (the administrative headquarters of a small domain in the Edo period), and the townscape of the Edo period, which can still be seen here and there, is designated as an Important Preservation District for Groups of Traditional Buildings. In the center of the town, a multifunction complex—Makabe Denshokan, consisting of a library, a multipurpose hall, and a historical museum—was built. In the midst of the historical townscape, a significant task was determining how to maintain tradition and harmonize with the townscape. Using a design method called “sampling and assembly,” which extracts and reconstructs the historical townscape elements, the architect brilliantly succeeded in realizing this task and was awarded the Architectural Institute of Japan, Architectural Design Division Prize in 2012.
for the diversity so typical of the Japanese style, in addition to being inappropriate for the natural view of the Imperial Palace. They aimed to develop urban planning in which the logic of each individual block would be used effectively. Here, the sensitivity of the Japanese to eliminating symmetry is clearly shown. As the result, the Marunouchi Building was designed by utilizing the intellectual abilities of Mitsubishi Estate’s in-house architects and was completed in 2002. Five years later, the New Marunouchi Building, the basic design of which was carried out by a British architect, was completed in an asymmetrical style entirely different in its exterior finish and form. Now, in front of Tokyo Station, I am glad to see the two buildings standing as examples of quite natural taste. 168 This is a case that strongly recognizes the characteristics of Japanese culture, which do not control parts from the whole picture but develop an independent and original world in each part of the whole. Diversity of Each Block in the Marunouchi District
Nowadays, the given design conditions of office buildings— which are, so to speak, universal standards—are extremely uniform, and it is therefore obvious that homogeneous structures are likely to be built. If the total plan were to exist initially, the likely result would be total homogeneity due to the control and restrictions of the plan. In circumstances as in Marunouchi, however, it seems that a force to eliminate uniformity exists.
168 Marunouchi Building (left, built: 2002, architect: Mitsubishi Jisho Sekkei) and New Marunouchi Building (right, built: 2007, basic design: Michael Hopkins, architect: Mitsubishi Jisho Sekkei). The two buildings have the same functions (office and commercial) and similar volume. Therefore, there were strong opinions that their design should be the same, as twin towers. But the architects had the courage to insist on the independence of each block, which was quite significant. 169 Restored Mitsubishi Building No. 1 (original building: built in 1894, designed by Josiah Conder; high-rise construction and restoration both completed in 2009,
160
architect: Mitsubishi Jisho Sekkei). It has only been forty years since the former building was demolished because of the logic of economic rationality, and the same building was restored here as faithfully as possible. In the meantime, values had changed quite rapidly, making it likely that this change had greatly influenced architecture itself. This restoration reminds us of the history of Marunouchi and helps us appreciate a calm atmosphere in the efficiency-oriented city. 170 The Marunouchi Park Building’s pocket park. This is the type of public space that has long been sought after but not realized for Marunouchi. The space is always crowded and there are refreshments, encounters, and laughter. It is an oasis for a busy city.
161
Each of the new Marunouchi site blocks is larger now because of the integration of smaller sites, and owner-developers had different additional requirements in each site block. Various urban planning techniques such as the specific block system, comprehensive design system, and volume transfer have been taken into account, and the requirements of those technical systems, which are enforced by the local government in order to obtain the relaxation of certain regulations, vary. As a result, the diversity of the city, or the independence of each block, has been achieved, and Marunouchi district is now a great accumulation of urban blocks, each with a theme that differs significantly from the others. Let’s take a look at the characteristic blocks in this district. 1 Marunouchi Park Building
Marunouchi Park Building was completed in 2009. Mitsubishi Building No. 1, which was originally built in 1894 as the first office building in Maruouchi, was restored on the same site. The appearance of this nostalgic European-style building brought some relief and respite in Marunouchi, where everything is new. In addition, there is a courtyard-type public space, or pocket park, on this site, which can’t be found in other blocks, and this is a place for relaxation and refreshment for office workers and shoppers. 169, 170
restarted, and the head priest of an adjacent prestigious temple said he would object by raising straw mat flags. The most significant subject was how to respond to the various situations of the neighbors and how to design a plan that would fit into the surrounding environment. The method we adopted here could certainly be described as “formative development by way of creating the best parts and coming up with the best whole.” Here, I will look at our actual design, which was created by realizing the characteristics of Japanese identities that I feature in this book.
178 Site plan. The scale difference in the size of the project area is obvious. It is quite important to preserve the continuity of the townscape, and we restarted the project with the recognition that the main design theme was how to fit it into the surrounding environment. 179 Coexistence with neighboring graveyard (built: 2004, architect: Mitsubishi Jisho Sekkei, location: Chiyoda-ku, Tokyo). What should the building look like as the background for the graveyard? Starting from this point of view, we came up with this tremendous green wall, like a green hill. This greening was indispensable for the graveyard’s coexistence with the temple.
168
180 Setbacks on the north side. The total form accords with the north side set-back line, and the combination of the setbacks and plants is quite effective. The arrangement of scale differences and the reduction of oppressive feelings in these parts of the building are apparent. 181 Open-air office. At the time, the idea of an open-air office was considered very new and attractive. The open-air activities in good weather were especially refreshing. The pursuit of such additional values in each part of the building contributed greatly to the total evaluation of the building.
169
1 Intimacy with Nature
In order for the new building to blend in with surrounding buildings whose scale and functions are completely different, what we first considered was to let nature be the medium. We brought in as much green as possible and aimed to coexist with the neighbors by means of intimacy with nature. We aimed to rely upon the common characteristic of the Japanese that is “coexisting with nature.” The starting point of the design was how to correspond to the temple and its graveyard in the west. 179 As for the north side, we planned set-back terrace gardens with abundant plants on each floor, thus creating a new urban scene as if a green hill had appeared. 180 Such an attitude in pursuit of a natural environment and comfort benefited not only the neighbors but also those working in the building. The roof garden is not merely an open space on the roof but is meant to be an open-air office, equipped with chairs, benches, tables in between plants, and LAN wiring infrastructure for use as a relaxation space or for conferences and meetings, weather permitting. 181
Main Entrance hall
Entrance gate
9 From the Parts to the Whole
We tried to do our best in designing the building, taking into consideration as far as possible the requirements of its neighbors. Because the circumstances of each neighbor differed, it was necessary to respond in a completely different way at each part of the building in each elevation. We thus tried to do the best at each part of the building, and as a result, the total figure was com pleted “from parts to the whole.” In any case, the priority was that the completed building be attractive and show maximum functionality. Although this was a huge office building with a v olume of over 57,000 square meters and residential floors above, a distinguished company was greatly in favor of the environmentally friendly design policy of the building and its performance, and the entire office area was rented under an extremely long contract. From the developer’s point of view, the project was a great success. We also earned high marks from the neighbors, and, coinciding with the project’s completion, we were awarded the design contract for the reconstruction of the guest hall and living quarters of the adjacent temple by the same head priest who had once said he would oppose the project by raising straw mat flags. What we especially had in mind for this project was the sense of scale on the site. For this purpose, so that each part would have the right scale, the entrance gate, elevator shafts, staircases, and other parts jutted out from the main structure, and the total exterior appearance seemed like a row of small buildings. Although it was a single building, the exterior view was as if a complex of
190 2F plan. Main Entrance Hall i Entrance gate h 191 Bird’s-eye view from the west.
176
many small buildings had been constructed. The plan 190 clearly shows this. As can be seen in the photo, the entrance gate and the elevator tower in the west look as if they are different buildings. The highrise part in the front and the lower part in the back are the same. The protruding part in the east looks like an annex building. Within the total structure, there is a convenient 50 meters × 100 meters of office space in a useful rectangular plate. 191 The entrance gate in the west is a separate building that could be called an entrance annex (see fig. 188). Its appearance is quite suitable for the entrance, and it has the properly segmented scale and appears as an independent existence. Although not straight, the traffic line for the entrance of the building is clear. At the beginning of the chapter “Parts Precede the Whole/‘Now = Here’ Principle,” I wrote: Japanese architecture is designed from parts and then configured as the whole. In other words, no total picture is imaged at the beginning, and parts are created one by one in the most proper way; as a result, the best possible total is produced as the whole. This procedure is quite different from the Western way of creating. In the Nibancho Garden Project we pursued and practiced this distinctly Japanese procedure. 177
S
ummary Diagram Intimacy with Nature [p. 22]
What is at the Root of Japanese Creativity: Japanese Identities
Importance of Materials [p. 31]
Simplicity and Denial of Ornamentation [p. 40]
CHARACTERISTICS OF JAPANESE ARCHITECTURAL CREATIVITY
Japanese Way of
FORMATIVE FROM
Craftsmanship and Skill of Master Woodworkers [p. 47]
Parts Precede the Whole/ “Now = Here” Principle [p. 122]
Bipolarity and Diversity [p. 56]
Spirit of Coexistence [p. 64]
Asymmetry [p. 74]
Culture of Addition [p. 82]
Devotion to Small Space [p. 90]
Looking at Things
CHARACTERISTICS OF JAPANESE ARCHITECTURAL COMPOSITION
DEVELOPMENT PARTS
Compositional Principles [p. 136]
Organic Form [p. 98]
Sense of “Oku = Inner Zone” [p. 106]
Do Not Show the Whole [p. 114]
A
uthor
Yuichiro Edagawa, PhD (Engineering) Globeship Corporation Managing Director Globeship Sodexo Corporate Services K.K. Representative Director and CEO 1948 Born in Kobe, Hyogo Prefecture 1967 Entered the University of Tokyo, College of Arts and Sciences 1970 Studied at the University of California, Berkeley, College of Environmental Design 1974 Graduated from the University of Tokyo, Faculty of Engineering, Department of Architecture Joined Mitsubishi Estate Company Ltd.— Architectural Design Division 2001 Transferred to Mitsubishi Jisho Sekkei Inc. upon its establishment 2008 Resigned from Mitsubishi Jisho Sekkei Inc. and entered FM business 2009 Joined Birudaiko Co. Ltd. as a Director
2015 GLOBESHIP Corporation established, Managing Director 2016 Awarded the degree of doctor of engineering by the University of Tokyo, specializing in architectural design Globeship Sodexo Corporate Services K.K. established, inaugurated as the Representative Director and CEO Qualifications
Authorized First Class Architect, Interior Planner, Certified Facility Manager Affiliated academic societies and others
The Architectural Institute of Japan, The Japan Institute of Architects, Japan Guide Association Representative architectural works
Tokyo Stock Exchange Building, HSBC Tokyo Building, Shochiku Square, Mitsubishi Heavy Industries Shinagawa Headquarters 186
Building, Nibancho Garden, Osaka Stock Exchange Building, Sankei Breeze Tower, and others, many of which have been awarded architectural prizes Major writings
Japanese Identities – Architecture between Aesthetics and Nature. Berlin: JOVIS, 2008. Japanese Identities – Japaneseness through Architecture. Tokyo: Kajima Shuppankai, 2009. Distinctive Features of Japanese Architecture and What is at the Root of Japanese Creativity. Tokyo: Kajima Shuppankai 2017. Recent Activities
Through FM services, making efforts in pursuit of contributions to the global environment that GLOBESHIP aims to achieve and of quality of life, which is the company policy of Sodexo with which we jointly established the JV.
187
In addition to the writings mentioned above, devoting time to introducing Japanese culture to foreign countries through architecture and giving lectures such as “High-Level Guiding Skill of Japanese Culture,” hosted by Japan Tourism Agency; the Japan Guide Association sponsorship “Training for Understanding Japanese Architecture” for professional guides; and “The Characteristics of Japanese Architecture” to foreign architects groups visiting Japan.