ACTA UNIVERSITATIS UPSALIENSIS
Symbolae Botanicae Upsalienses
37:1
Xylographa pallens colonizing a conifer log in Pseudotsuga menziesii forest, Siegel Creek, Sanders Co., Montana,
U.S.A. (April 2014). Photo T. Spribille
SYMBOLAE BOTANICAE UPSALIENSES 37:1
Molecular systematics of the
wood-inhabiting, lichen-forming
genus Xylographa (Baeomycetales,
Ostropomycetidae) with eight new species
Toby Spribille, Philipp Resl, Teuvo Ahti, Sergio Pérez-Ortega,
Tor Tønsberg, Helmut Mayrhofer & H. Thorsten Lumbsch
© The authors, 2014
ISSN 0082-0644
ISBN 978-91-554-8235-0
Printed in Sweden by Danagård LiTHO AB, 2014
Contents
Introduction
. . . . . . . . . ...........................................................................................................................
8
Material and methods .................................................................................................................... 9
DNA acquisition ....................................................................................................................... 9
Phylogenetic analyses ........................................................................................................... 17
Chemistry . . . . . . . ........................................................................................................................ . 18
Morphology . . . . ......................................................................................................................... 18
Studied material ..................................................................................................................... 19
Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .........................................................................................................................
Bayesian analysis ...................................................................................................................
Maximum likelihood .............................................................................................................
Relationships among sampled taxa .....................................................................................
19
20
20
20
Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . ......................................................................................................................... 21
Evolution of ascomata in xylographoid lichens ............................................................... 24
Taxonomic section .......................................................................................................................
Lambiella Hertel ....................................................................................................................
Lambiella insularis (Nyl.) T. Sprib. ..............................................................................
Xylographa (Fr. : Fr.) Fr. .......................................................................................................
Key to the species of Xylographa .................................................................................
Xylographa bjoerkii T. Sprib., sp. nov. ........................................................................
Xylographa carneopallida (Räsänen) T. Sprib. ..........................................................
Xylographa constricta T. Sprib., sp. nov. ....................................................................
Xylographa difformis (Vain.) Vain. ...............................................................................
Xylographa disseminata Willey ....................................................................................
Xylographa erratica T. Sprib., sp. nov. ........................................................................
Xylographa hians Tuck. ..................................................................................................
Xylographa isidiosa (Elix) Bendiksby & Timdal .......................................................
Xylographa lagoi T. Sprib. & Pérez-Ortega, sp. nov. ................................................
Xylographa opegraphella Nyl. ......................................................................................
Xylographa pallens (Nyl.) Harm. ..................................................................................
Xylographa parallela (Ach. : Fr.) Fr. ...........................................................................
25
25
25
25
26
28
30
32
32
35
37
39
42
42
47
51
58
Xylographa rubescens Räsänen .....................................................................................
Xylographa schoieldii T. Sprib., sp. nov. . ...................................................................
Xylographa septentrionalis T. Sprib., sp. nov. ............................................................
Xylographa soralifera Holien & Tønsberg .................................................................
Xylographa stenospora T. Sprib. & Resl, sp. nov. .....................................................
Xylographa trunciseda (Th. Fr.) Minks ex Redinger ................................................
Xylographa vermicularis T. Sprib., sp. nov. ................................................................
Xylographa vitiligo (Ach.) J.R. Laundon . ...................................................................
Excluded taxa
. . . . . . . . .................................................... ...................................................................
Acknowledgments
Literature
61
65
65
69
71
74
76
79
82
.................................................... ...................................................................
82
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ........................................................................................................................
83
Molecular systematics of the wood-inhabiting, lichenforming genus Xylographa (Baeomycetales, Ostropomycetidae) with eight new species
Toby Spribille, Philipp Resl, Teuvo Ahti, Sergio Pérez-Ortega, Tor Tønsberg,
Helmut Mayrhofer & H. Thorsten Lumbsch
Toby Spribille1,2*, Philipp Resl1, Teuvo Ahti3, Sergio Pérez-Ortega4, Tor Tønsberg5, Helmut
Mayrhofer1 & H. Thorsten Lumbsch6 (2014). Molecular systematics of the wood-inhabiting,
lichen-forming genus Xylographa (Baeomycetales, Ostropomycetidae) with eight new species.
– Acta Univ. Ups. Symb. Bot. Ups 37:1. ISBN 978-91-554-8235-0
The ascomycete genus Xylographa includes some of the most abundant species of wood-inhabiting lichenized fungi in boreal and temperate regions. It has never been monographed and
little is known of its species diversity and evolutionary relationships. Based on a morphological
and secondary metabolite-based assessment of material from North and South America, Europe
and Asia, we generated a three-locus phylogeny based on sequences of the internal transcribed
spacer, 28S nuclear rDNA and mitochondrial small subunit rDNA. We analyzed the data within
the context of putatively related genera in the order Baeomycetales. Xylographa is a strongly
supported monophyletic group closely related to Lithographa and Ptychographa, as well as
rock-dwelling and lichenicolous species of Rimularia s.lat. The evolution of linearized ascomata in Xylographa appears to have enabled ascomata to grow laterally, and patterns of lateral
growth are diagnostic. We recognize twenty species in Xylographa and provide a thorough
revision of nomenclature. The following eight species are new: Xylographa bjoerkii T. Sprib.,
X. constricta T. Sprib., X. erratica T. Sprib., X. lagoi T. Sprib. & Pérez-Ortega, X. schoieldii T.
Sprib., X. septentrionalis T. Sprib., X. stenospora T. Sprib. & Resl and X. vermicularis T. Sprib.
The combinations Lambiella insularis (Nyl.) T. Sprib. and Xylographa carneopallida (Räsänen)
T. Sprib. are newly proposed. Xylographa constricta from southern South America represents
the irst known case of secondary de-lichenization in the Baeomycetales. Xylographa parallela
s.str. is conirmed as bipolar on the basis of sequenced collections from both southern Chile and
the northern Hemisphere.
Keywords: Ascomycota, biodiversity, evolution, Fungi, lignicolous, phylogenetics, saproxylic,
taxonomy
1
Institute of Plant Sciences, NAWI Graz, University of Graz, Holteigasse 6, A-8010 Graz, Austria. 2 Division of Biological Sciences, University of Montana, 32 Campus Drive, Missoula, MT
59812 U.S.A. 3Botanical Museum, Finnish Museum of Natural History, P.O. Box 7, FI-00014
University of Helsinki, Finland. 4Departamento de Biología Ambiental, Museo Nacional de
Ciencias Naturales (CSIC), C/ Serrano 115-dpdo, E-28006, Madrid, Spain. 5University Museum
of Bergen, Allégaten 41, P. O. Box 7800, N-5020 Bergen, Norway. 6Science & Education, The
Field Museum, 1400 S. Lake Shore Drive, Chicago, IL 60605, U.S.A.
*Corresponding author: e-mail toby.spribille@mso.umt.edu
8
T. Spribille et al.
Introduction
Fungal-algal symbioses, also known as lichens,
are thought to have arisen between two and four
times in total, almost all involving fungal partners
from the Ascomycota that were ancestrally saprobic (Gargas et al. 1995; Lutzoni et al. 2001; Prieto
& Wedin 2013; Schoch et al. 2009). Reversions
to saprobic lifestyles from lichens are however
much more common than de novo lichenization
in the fungal tree of life (Lutzoni et al. 2001). Lichens experienced a massive evolutionary radiation
within Pezizomycotina in Lecanoromycetes (Miadlikowska et al. 2006), branching into two main
groups: Lecanoromycetidae, including most recent
macrolichens; and Ostropomycetidae, a group of
several thousand described species from all latitudes, nearly all of which form small, crustose thalli
(Lumbsch et al. 2007a). Within Lecanoromycetes
the Ostropomycetidae can be considered a hub of
secondary de-lichenization, with saprobic lifestyles notably in Agyrium (Pertusariales; Lumbsch
et al. 2001, 2007b) and two families of the Ostropales, Odontotremataceae and Stictidaceae, the
latter radiating into scores of species, including
endophytic and saproxylic fungi (Sherwood 1977;
Schoch et al. 2006; Baloch et al. 2010). Furthermore, at least some ostensibly lichenized members
of this group exhibit a non-obligate association with
algae (Wedin et al. 2004) and a degree of substrate
speciicity suggesting substrate involvement in the
primary carbon metabolism (Spribille et al. 2008).
The Ostropomycetidae are very unequally studied, with detailed phylogenetic studies in Ostropales (Baloch et al. 2010; Rivas Plata & Lumbsch
2011; Rivas Plata et al. 2013) as well as on phylogenetics and character state development in Pertusariales (Schmitt & Lumbsch 2004; Schmitt et al.
2006; Lumbsch et al. 2006) The order Baeomycetales is by contrast undersampled, and even the
higher level classiication of this group remains
unsettled. The 18 genera assigned to this order
by Lumbsch & Huhndorf (2011) feature a wide
spectrum of character innovation ranging from
stalked ascomata to appressed and linear, simple to
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
branched, laterally growing ascomata. Baeomycetales also harbour genera with levels of obligate
substrate afinity anomalous in the ostensibly autotrophic lichen symbiosis, suggesting carbon metabolisms that go beyond fungal-algal interactions.
Molecular evolutionary studies in Baeomycetales have focused mainly on the genus Placopsis
(Schmitt et al. 2003a).
This study targets one of the widespread groups
of fungi in the Baeomycetales associated with
lignum, the genus Xylographa. Unlike the large
majority of Lecanoromycetes which have round
ascomata, Xylographa belongs to a small group
of genera which form linear ascomata, sometimes
called lirellae or hyster(i)othecia (Lumbsch 1997).
In the Lecanoromycetes, similar ascomata can
otherwise be found in Lithographa and Ptychographa, two genera postulated to be close to Xylographa (Lumbsch 1997), as well as in Graphidaceae (subclass Ostropomycetidae: Lumbsch 1997,
Lumbsch et al. 2007a,b; Mangold et al. 2008), and
in Elixia and Xylopsora in subclass Umbilicariomycetidae (Bendiksby & Timdal 2013). They are
also known from Opegraphaceae, Arthoniomycetes (Ertz et al. 2009, Ertz & Tehler 2011) and in
distantly related ascolocularous fungi of the Dothideomycetes (Mugambi & Huhndorf 2009). Like
many of these groups, Xylographa species have
poorly developed lichenized thalli. More than most
lichenized fungi at high latitudes, Xylographa exhibits high substrate specialism for wood (Spribille
et al. 2008). The obscurity of the algal afinity and
the strong wood association were enough that the
earliest Xylographa species were classiied among
non-lichenized cup fungi within the then broadly
deined genera Hysterium (Persoon 1796) or Stictis
(Fries 1822). The core genus Xylographa and subsequently described family Xylographaceae (Tuckerman 1888, currently not recognized) were only
gradually circumscribed as a group: no single paper
has been dedicated to the taxonomy of Xylographa.
Altogether, between seven and ten species are now
commonly recognized. Vainio (1883, 1909) and
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
later Räsänen (in Vainio 1921, Räsänen 1939) were
among the irst to recognize additional species diversity in Xylographa in Finland and what is now
Russian Karelia, but none of these species are recognized today. Nearly seventy years passed before
the genus was again taken up for critical review by
Bruce Ryan in the preparation of the Sonoran lichen
lora, a treatment published posthumously (Ryan
2004a). The poor state of knowledge in Xylographa is further relected in the fact that up until very
9
recently only a single isolate from the genus was
represented in GenBank.
Our treatment has three speciic aims: 1) to
identify clades and develop a phylogenetic circumscription of the genus and its species using molecular and morphological characters; 2) to recircumscribe known taxa with recognizable characters
and establish a new classiication; and 3) to identify potential adaptive traits over the Xylographa
phylogeny to provide a basis for future evolutionary hypothesis testing.
Material and methods
The study was initiated with a set of ca. 200 specimens mainly from western North America from
the study of Bunnell et al. (2008), after it became
clear that prevailing species concepts in Xylographa did not account for the range of diversity
encountered. In the absence of an existing morphology-based monograph and without knowing
a priori which characters are most diagnostic, we
adopted a strategy of “recursive sampling”, essentially testing ad hoc hypotheses of species recognition. This involved 1) screening material using
thin layer chromatography and basic morphology
into candidate species, 2) sampling candidates using the internal transcribed spacer (ITS) rDNA barcoding marker and/or mitochondrial small subunit
(mtSSU) rDNA, 3) returning to the material and
adjusting concepts based on available sequence
data and 4) when necessary, sampling new material
for DNA to test our species predictions. We later
added fresh material from other geographical regions for a total of 90 isolates, of which a subset of
mostly multilocus-sequenced individuals are used
for the present study.
DNA acquisition
Taxon sampling focused on the genus Xylographa and all available putatively related genera of
Baeomycetales. Speciically, all species of Xylographa for which fresh material was available
were sampled for DNA isolation. We also sampled
fresh material of potentially closely related genera
including Lithographa, Ptychographa and Rimularia and included these within a set of other related outgroup taxa of Trapeliaceae, Hymeneliaceae,
Baeomycetaceae and Icmadophilaceae mostly obtained from GenBank. We excluded Lignoscripta,
described by Ryan (2004b), which is only distantly
related and will be treated elsewhere (Spribille &
Resl in ed.). The only available DNA sequences
for Xylographa from GenBank were downloaded
and aligned with our present data set. In total 103
isolates were used for the present study (Table 1).
We did not design the taxon sampling to address
broader-level questions regarding family circumscription or the monophyly of Baeomycetales, and
use that name here in the broad sense. Hodkinson
& Lendemer (2011) recently proposed segregating
from the Baeomycetales the family Trapeliaceae,
based on a triangulation from several large-scale
phylogenetic studies, and erected for it the new
order Trapeliales. Multilocus data are scarce compared to the total number of taxa currently ascribed
to this group, however, and it remains unclear if a
close relationship of Trapeliaceae to Baeomycetaceae can be ruled out.
Genomic DNA was extracted using a DNeasy
Plant Mini kit (Qiagen, Hilden, Germany). Especially tiny or recalcitrant samples were extracted
using the QIAamp DNA Investigator Kit (Qiagen,
Hilden, Germany). Samples were eluted in 50 to 75
µl elution buffer and on account of the low DNA
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
Species
Geographical provenance
Voucher specimen
Original publication
ITS
mtSSU
28S
1088
Ainoa mooreana
SWEDEN. Jämtland
Nordin 7455 (UPS)
here
KJ462262
KJ462394
KJ462339
1089
A. mooreana
JAPAN. Nagano Prefecture
Thor 28340 (UPS)
here
KJ462263
KJ462395
KJ462340
A. mooreana
CZECH REPUBLIC.
Palice 5156 (hb. Palice)
Schmitt et al. (2003a)
-
AY212850
AY212828
P78
Baeomyces rufus
U.S.A. Alaska, Glacier Bay
NP, Shag Cove
Spribille 36414 (GZU)
here
KJ462264
KJ462396
KJ462341
P79
Dibaeis baeomyces
U.S.A. Alaska, Glacier Bay
NP, Dundas Bay
Spribille 38948 (GZU)
here
KJ462265
KJ462397
KJ462342
Hymenelia lacustris
SWEDEN.
Wedin 6876 (UPS)
Wedin et al. (2005)
-
AY853323
AY853371
1046
H. melanocarpa
CANADA. Yukon, LaBiche area, Mt. Martin
Spribille 28350-B (GZU)
here
KJ462266
KJ462398
KJ462343
P81
Icmadophila ericetorum
U.S.A. Alaska, Glacier Bay
NP, Bartlett Cove
Spribille 36042 (GZU)
here
KJ462267
KJ462399
KJ462344
1091
Lambiella insularis
U.S.A. Montana, Missoula
Co., Salmon Lake
Spribille s.n., 07/09/2012
(GZU)
here
KJ462268
KJ462400
KJ462345
L. psephota
AUSTRALIA.
Kantvilas 335/00 (HO)
Lumbsch et al. (2007b)
-
DQ871019
DQ871012
Lithographa tesserata
SWEDEN. Värmland
Muhr, 1988 (UPS)
Lumbsch et al. (2001)
AF274079
-
-
L. tesserata
U.S.A. Alaska, Glacier Bay
NP, Dundas Bay
Spribille 38950 (GZU)
here
KJ462269
-
KJ462346
Phyllobaeis erythrella
COSTA RICA. San Jose,
Los Santo Forest Reserve
DUKE-0047957 (AFTOLID 329)
Miadlikowska et al.
(2006)
-
DQ986888
DQ986780
P. imbricata
COSTA RICA. San Jose,
“at km 70”
DUKE-0047750 (AFTOLID 852)
Miadlikowska et al.
(2006)
HQ650635
DQ986895
DQ986781
Placopsis kerguelensis
[FRANCE OVERSEAS
TERR.] Île Kerguelen
Poulsen 456 (C)
Poulsen et al. (2001);
Schmitt et al.(2003a)
AY212813
AF381561
AF274116
P. macrophthalma
[FRANCE OVERSEAS
TERR.] Crozet Island
(US 9303)
Schmitt et al. (2003a)
AY212824
AY212866
AY212844
P. rhodophthalma
[FRANCE OVERSEAS
TERR.] Crozet Island
(US 9398)
Schmitt et al. (2003a)
AY212821
-
AY212838
Placynthiella icmalea
FINLAND.
S. Huhtinen 05/15 (TUR)
Stenroos et al. (2010)
EU940236
EU940300
EU940160
P95
1
T. Spribille et al.
Isolate
Ref
10
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
Table 1. Material used for the molecular portion of this study, with GenBank accession numbers. Isolate reference refers to lab isolates in Graz
(all numbers between 800 and 1200 and any numbers starting with P) and Chicago (numbers of the 2000 series).
GERMANY. RheinlandPfalz
Lumbsch 12059a (hb.
Lumbsch)
Lumbsch et al. (2001)
AF274082
AY212870
AY212846
P. uliginosa
FINLAND. Uusimaa:
Kirkkonummi, Porkkala,
Vetokannas
Stenroos 5679 (DUKE)
(AFTOL-ID 1365)
Miadlikowska et al.
(2006)
HQ650633
DQ986877
DQ986774
Ptychographa xylographoides
U.S.A. Oregon. Lane Co.,
H. J. Andrews Exp. For.*
McCune 25338 (OSC)
Schmitt et al. (2003a)
-
AY212872
-
2388
P. xylographoides
U.S.A. Washington, Skamania County, Columbia
River Gorge
Björk 14042 (UBC)
here
KJ462270
KJ462401
-
1122
P. xylographoides
U.K. Scotland, West Ross,
Talladale Gorge
Coppins 24229 (GZU)
here
KJ462271
KJ462402
KJ462347
1123
P. xylographoides
U.K. Scotland, Beinne
Eighe Natl Nature Reserve
Acton s.n. 30/04/2013
(GZU)
here
KJ462272
KJ462403
KJ462348
1062
Rimularia limborina
U.S.A. California, Mariposa Co., Sierra National
Forest
Fryday 9520 (MSC)
here
KJ462273
KJ462404
KJ462349
1076
R. limborina
U.S.A. Alaska, Glacier Bay
NP, Excursion Ridge
Fryday 10100 (MSC)
here
-
-
KJ462350
Thamnolia vermicularis
unknown
Brodo 28669-B (DUKE)
(AFTOL-ID 401)
Lutzoni et al. (2004)
HQ650718
AY584728
HQ650718
Trapelia involuta (syn. T.
glebulosa)
GERMANY. NordrheinWestfalen
Lumbsch 12057 (hb.
Lumbsch)
Lumbsch et al. (2001)
AF274080
AF381568
AF274098
T. placodioides
GERMANY. NordrheinWestfalen
Lumbsch 12058 (hb.
Lumbsch)
Lumbsch et al. (2001)
AF274081
AF431962
AF274103
Trapeliopsis granulosa
SWEDEN.
Niemann (ESS-8684)
Schmitt et al. (2003b)
AF274087
AF381567
AF274119
Tremolecia atrata
SWEDEN.
Wedin 7094 (UPS)
Wedin et al. (2005)
-
AY853347
AY853397
2422
Xylographa bjoerkii
CANADA. British Columbia, Southgate River
Björk 14570 (GZU)
here
KJ462274
KJ462405
-
1129
X. bjoerkii
U.S.A. Alaska, Taylor Bay,
Cross Sound
Spribille 39752 (GZU)
here
KJ462275
KJ462406
KJ462351
2401
X. bjoerkii
U.S.A. Oregon, Douglas
Co., Irwin Rocks
McCune 28535 (MCCUNE)
here
KJ462276
KJ462407
-
1024
X. carneopallida
CANADA. Yukon, LaBiche River, N of gas camp
Spribille 28528 (GZU)
here
KJ462277
KJ462408
KJ462352
11
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
P. icmalea
2
12
1147
X. constricta
CHILE. Antártica Chilena,
PN Alberto de Agostini
Buck 58580 (NY, holotype)
here
KJ462278
KJ462409
KJ462353
2396
X. difformis
CANADA. British Columbia, Kootenay River area
Spribille 17238 (GZU)
here
KJ462279
KJ462410
-
2404
X. difformis
CANADA. British Columbia, S of Carcross, Tutshi
River
Spribille 25050 (GZU)
here
KJ462280
KJ462411
KJ462354
2421
X. difformis
CANADA. British
Columbia, Selkirk Mtns.,
Silvercup Ridge
Spribille 20110 (GZU)
here
KJ462281
KJ462412
-
2382
X. difformis
U.S.A. Idaho, Coeur
d’Alene Mtns., Bloom
Peak
Björk 12123 (UBC)
here
KJ462282
KJ462413
-
822
X. disseminata
CANADA. New
Brunswick
Clayden 19609 (NBM)
here
KJ462283
-
KJ462355
823
X. disseminata
U.S.A. Tennessee, Great
Smoky Mtns NP
Tønsberg 37619 (BG)
here
KJ462284
-
KJ462356
2423
X. erratica
CANADA. British Columbia, Homathko Estuary
Björk 14550 (UBC)
here
KJ462285
KJ462414
-
820
X. erratica
RUSSIA. Khabarovskiy
Krai, Pravaya Bureya
River
Spribille 32039 (GZU,
holotype)
here
KJ462286
KJ462415
KJ462357
P99
X. erratica
U.S.A. Alaska, Icy Straits,
Fern Harbor
Tønsberg 41775 (BG)
here
-
KJ462416
KJ462358
818
X. hians
CANADA. British Columbia, Saanich Peninsula,
Observatory Hill
Spribille, Češka &
Češkas.n., 11 Oct 2010
(GZU)
here
KJ462287
-
KJ462359
1140
X. hians
U.S.A. Alaska, Glacier
Bay, Bartlett Cove
Spribille 38126 (GZU)
here
KJ462288
-
KJ462360
1053
X. hians
U.S.A. Alaska, Glacier
Bay, Bartlett Cove
Spribille 36071-B (GZU)
here
KJ462289
KJ462417
KJ462361
1052
X. hians
U.S.A. Alaska, Veteran’s
Hwy N of Auke Bay
Spribille s.n., Sept 2010
(GZU)
here
KJ462290
KJ462418
KJ462362
1
X. isidiosa
AUSTRALIA.
Elix 31849 (CANB,
isotype)
Bendiksby & Timdal
(2013)
KF360391
KF360430
KF360461
T. Spribille et al.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
Table 1 (cont.)
AUSTRALIA. Western
Australia, Caernarvon
Hills, 17 km NW of Narrogin
Elix 39837 (O-L-171593)
Bendiksby & Timdal
(2013)
KF360392
KF360431
KF360462
162
X. lagoi
SPAIN. Asturias, Muniellos Nature Reserve
Spribille 30267
here
KJ462291
KJ462419
KJ462363
1068
X. opegraphella
CANADA. New
Brunswick, New River
Beach Prov. Park
Spribille & Clayden s.n.,
08 Oct 2009 (GZU)
here
KJ462292
KJ462420
KJ462364
1069
X. opegraphella
CANADA. Québec, North
Shore of St. Lawrence,
Godbout
Spribille & Clayden s.n.,
01 Oct 2009 (GZU)
here
KJ462293
KJ462421
KJ462365
819
X. opegraphella
U.S.A. Alaska, Resurrection Bay, S of Lowell Pt
Muggia s.n. (TSB)
here
KJ462294
-
KJ462366
2411
X. opegraphella
U.S.A. Alaska, Dyea
Spribille 24979 (KLGO)
here
KJ462295
KJ462422
-
1150
X. pallens
AUSTRIA. Carinthia,
Gurktaler Alpen, Hochrindl
Resl 1143 (GZU)
here
KJ462296
KJ462423
KJ462367
1153
X. pallens
AUSTRIA. Carinthia,
Gurktaler Alpen, Hochrindl
Resl 1144 (GZU)
here
KJ462297
KJ462424
KJ462368
2385
X. pallens
CANADA. British Columbia, Glacier National Park
Goward 05-838 (UBC)
here
KJ462298
KJ462425
-
1133
X. pallens
CANADA. British
Columbia, Cassiar Hwy,
Gnat Pass
Spribille s.n., 13 Aug 2012
(GZU)
here
KJ462299
KJ462426
KJ462369
1064
X. pallens
SPAIN. Navarra, Roncal
Valley above Isaba
Spribille 30251 (GZU)
here
KJ462300
KJ462427
KJ462370
1063
X. pallens
TURKEY. Bolu Prov.,
Yedigöller National Park
Spribille s.n., 05 June 2007
(GZU)
here
KJ462301
KJ462428
KJ462371
1060
X. pallens
U.S.A. Montana, Lincoln
Co., Fitzsimmons Creek
Spribille s.n., 18 Sept 2011
(GZU)
here
KJ462302
KJ462429
KJ462372
1057
X. pallens
CANADA. British Columbia, km 1148 Alaska Hwy
Spribille 29559 (GZU)
here
KJ462303
-
KJ462373
1151
X. parallela
AUSTRIA. Carinthia,
Gurktaler Alpen, Hochrindl
Resl 1145 (GZU)
here
KJ462304
KJ462430
KJ462374
1061
X. parallela
AUSTRIA. Styria, Präbichl
Spribille s.n., 13 Nov 2010
(GZU)
here
KJ462305
KJ462431
KJ462375
13
X. isidiosa
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
2
14
2427
X. parallela
CANADA. British Columbia, Bute Inlet area
Björk 14520 (UBC)
here
KJ462306
KJ462432
-
2408
X. parallela
CANADA. British Columbia, Quesnel Lake, Penfold
River
Spribille s.n., 28 Sept 2007
(GZU)
here
KJ462307
KJ462433
-
1144
X. parallela
CHILE. Antártica Chilena,
Isla Navarino
Buck 60821 (NY)
here
KJ462308
KJ462434
KJ462376
1145
X. parallela
CHILE. Antártica Chilena,
Isla Navarino
Buck 60821-B (NY)
here
KJ462309
KJ462435
KJ462377
X. parallela
NORWAY.
Timdal 10892 (O-L152948)
Bendiksby & Timdal
(2013)
KF360416
KF360445
KF360476
2430
X. parallela
U.S.A. Montana, Flathead
Co., Lime Creek
Spribille 21171 (GZU)
here
KJ462310
KJ462436
-
2429
X. parallela
U.S.A. Montana, Lake Co.,
St. Mary’s Lake
Spribille 20604 (GZU)
here
KJ462311
KJ462437
-
1049
X. parallela (‘minutula’)
RUSSIA. Khabarovskiy
Krai, Pravaya Bureya
River
Spribille 32037 (GZU)
here
KJ462312
-
KJ462378
P106
X. rubescens
RUSSIA. Altai Republic,
Cherga, Sema River basin
Resl 1142 (GZU)
here
KJ462313
-
KJ462379
1065
X. rubescens
SPAIN. Navarra, Roncal
Valley above Isaba
Spribille 30255 (GZU)
here
KJ462314
KJ462438
KJ462380
2389
X. rubescens
U.S.A. Montana, Lincoln
Co., Sterling Creek
Spribille & Wagner s.n., 21
Oct 2007 (GZU)
here
KJ462315
KJ462439
KJ462381
1103
X. schoieldii
U.S.A. Alaska, Gustavus,
Falls Creek
Spribille 39088 (GZU,
holotype)
here
-
KJ462440
-
1056
X. septentrionalis s.lat.
U.S.A. Montana, Lincoln
Co., Grave Creek
Spribille s.n., 28 Aug 2011
(GZU)
here
KJ462316
KJ462441
-
2402
X. septentrionalis
CANADA. British Columbia, Cassiar Hwy
Spribille 25133 (CANL,
holotype)
here
KJ462317
KJ462442
KJ462382
2438
X. septentrionalis
CANADA. British Columbia, East Kootenays, White
River
Spribille 16905 (GZU)
here
KJ462318
-
-
X. soralifera**
TURKEY. Rize vilayet,
Kaçkar Mts, village Ayder
Palice 8610 (ESS-21522)
Schmitt et al. (2003a)
-
AY212878
AY212849
T. Spribille et al.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
Table 1 (cont.)
U.S.A. Montana, Lincoln
Co., Edna Creek
Spribille s.n., 09 Sept 2012
(GZU)
here
KJ462319
KJ462443
KJ462383
2415
X. soralifera
U.S.A. Montana, Lincoln
Co., Gray Creek
Spribille 21812 (GZU)
here
-
KJ462444
KJ462384
2416
X. soralifera
U.S.A. Montana, Sanders
Co., Bull River
Spribille 20754 (GZU)
here
KJ462320
KJ462445
-
1070
X. soralifera
U.S.A. Washington, Skamania Co., Elk Pass
Spribille 29853 (GZU)
here
KJ462321
KJ462446
KJ462385
1058
X. stenospora
CANADA. British
Columbia, Selkirk Mtns.,
Dennis Cr.
Spribille 20224 (GZU)
here
KJ462322
KJ462447
KJ462386
2400
X. stenospora
CANADA. British Columbia, near Canal Flats,
White River
Spribille 16951 (GZU)
here
KJ462323
KJ462448
-
2428
X. stenospora
CANADA. British Columbia, Incomappleux River
Spribille 18256 (GZU)
here
KJ462324
KJ462449
-
1059
X. stenospora
U.S.A. Montana, Glacier
Co., Upper Two Medicine
L.
Spribille & Wagner s.n., 15
Oct 2007 (GZU)
here
KJ462325
KJ462450
KJ462387
2424
X. stenospora
U.S.A. Washington,
Spokane Co., Riverside
State Park
Björk 14172 (UBC)
here
KJ462326
KJ462451
-
817
X. trunciseda
U.S.A. Alaska, Resurrection Bay, S of Lowell Pt
Muggia s.n. (TSB)
here
KJ462327
KJ462452
KJ462388
2387
X. trunciseda
CANADA. British Columbia, Clearwater River
Björk 12399 (UBC)
here
KJ462328
KJ462453
-
1051
X. trunciseda
NORWAY, Troms, Torsken, Senja
Tønsberg 40446 (BG)
here
KJ462329
KJ462454
-
1050
X. trunciseda
U.S.A. Montana, Lincoln
Co., Grave Creek
Spribille s.n., 25 Aug 2011
(GZU)
here
KJ462330
KJ462455
KJ462389
1146
X. vermicularis
CHILE. Antártica Chilena,
Isla Navarino
Buck 60823 (NY)
here
KJ462337
-
KJ462392
1130
X. vermicularis
RUSSIA. Khabarovskiy
Krai, 33 km W of Lazarev
Spribille 30992 (GZU)
here
KJ462331
KJ462456
-
2399
X. vermicularis
RUSSIA. Primorskiy Krai,
Mt. Oblachnaya
Spribille 23687 (GZU)
here
KJ462332
KJ462457
-
15
X. soralifera
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
1117
16
821
X. vermicularis
U.S.A. Alaska, Chulitna
River, Parks Hwy
Spribille 27762 (GZU)
here
KJ462333
-
KJ462390
1152
X. vitiligo
AUSTRIA. Carinthia,
Gurktaler Alpen, Hochrindl
Resl 1146, 2013 (GZU)
here
KJ462334
KJ462458
KJ462391
2403
X. vitiligo
CANADA. British Columbia, Quesnel Lake, Penfold
River
Spribille s.n., 28 Sept 2007
(GZU)
here
KJ462335
KJ462459
-
2417
X. vitiligo
CANADA. British Columbia, Glacier National Park
Goward 05-918 (UBC)
here
KJ462336
KJ462460
-
1066
X. vitiligo
U.S.A. Alaska, Glacier
Bay, Bartlett L trail
Spribille 36071-C (GZU)
here
KJ462338
KJ462461
KJ462393
*locality data provided by B. McCune (pers. comm., 2013)
**Published as X. vitiligo but since re-identiied; collection data provided by Z. Palice (pers. comm., 2011 & 2013).
T. Spribille et al.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
Table 1 (cont.)
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
17
Table 2. Primers used in this study.
Name
Sequence 5’-3’
Citation
ITS1F
CTTGGTCATTTAGAGGAAGTAA
Gardes & Bruns 1993
ITS4
TCCTCCGCTTATTGATATGC
White et al. 1990
LR0R
ACCCGCTGAACTTAAGC
Cubeta et al. 1991
LR3
CCGTGTTTCAAGACGGG
Vilgalys & Hester 1990
LR5
TCCTGAGGGAAACTTCG
Vilgalys & Hester 1990
LR7
TACTACCACCAAGATCT
Vilgalys & Hester 1990
LR4_Trap
TTTGCACGTCAGAACCGCTGCG
this study
mrssu1
AGCAGTGAGGAATATTGGTC
Zoller et al. 1999
mrssu3R
ATGTGGCACGTCTATAGCCC
Zoller et al. 1999
MSU7
GTCGAGTTACAGACTACAATCC
Zhou & Stanosz 2001
concentrations were typically used undiluted for
PCR template. DNA was ampliied from three loci
for the core part of our study. We sequenced the
internal transcribed spacer 1 and 2 and associated
5.8S ribosomal rDNA (hereafter ITS), the downstream 28S ribosomal DNA (28S), and mitochondrial small subunit ribosomal DNA (mtSSU) using
the primers listed in Table 2. Most of the sequences
from the primer combination mrssu1 and MSU7
were however not subsequently used, or were resampled with mrssu1 and mrssu3R, as they were too
short to capture the main polymorphic sites in
mtSSU in our taxon sample.
Sequence data were assembled in BioEdit
7.1.3.0 (Hall 1999), aligned using the ClustalW algorithm (Thompson et al. 1994) and manually adjusted. The data contained large introns occurring
in few sequences, especially in 28S, and thus the
raw alignments required culling for analysis. Missing data and non-conserved positions were iltered
using Gblocks 0.91b (Castresana 2000). We set the
ilter options to the most inclusive possible, with
the minimum number of sequences for both conserved and lank positions 52/103, the maximum
number of contiguous non-conserved positions set
to eight, the minimum length of a block set to two,
and gap positions allowed throughout.
We checked for incongruence, deined as strong
support for two different relationships, by irst ana-
lyzing the topology of each locus separately and
checking for supported incongruence. A node was
considered to be incongruent when an alternative
relationship was supported in different topologies.
Nucleotide substitution models were tested on the
loci individually using jModelTest v0.1.1 (Posada
2008).
Phylogenetic analyses
ML estimation. We performed ML phylogenetic
estimations of tree topologies and branch lengths
using RAxML (Stamatakis 2006) v7.4.2 (release
23 Nov 2012) implemented in raxmlGUI v1.3
(Silvestro & Michalak 2011). We implemented the
GTRGAMMA substitution model and calculated
1000 bootstrap replicates. The best-scoring tree
over ten runs was selected based on its log likelihood score. A strongly supported relationship was
taken as those nodes with a bootstrap value of 70%
or greater.
Bayesian inference. We performed Bayesian inference analysis of our DNA sequence data set using
the Markov chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) algorithm of MrBayes 3.2 (Ronquist & Huelsenbeck
2003) implemented in MrBayes_gpu v2.1.1 (Bao
et al. 2013). Prior distributions included allowing
for equal probabilities of all tree topologies (“uniform”), a uniform distribution over a range of alSymb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
18
T. Spribille et al.
pha values for the shape parameter of the gamma
distribution of rate variation, a uniform distribution
of invariable sites, a (1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1) Dirichlet distribution for the rate matrix, a (1, 1, 1, 1) Dirichlet
distribution for the state frequencies, a beta distribution for the transition/transversion ratio, and an
exponential, unconstrained branch length prior with
the parameter set to 10.0. The number of discrete
gamma categories was set to four. The analysis was
carried out with two parallel runs with four chains
each with one cold and three heated chains. The
temperature setting was tested at 0.2 (default), 0.1
and 0.05 to check for chain mixing under a single
swap default. Analyses were run initially for 2.5
million generations with tree sampling every 1000th
generation for a total of 2501 trees, of which the
irst 1500 were discarded as burn-in. After checking run behavior and convergence diagnostics a
inal run of 10 million generations was performed
with sampling every 1000th tree and a burn-in of
5001 trees for a posterior sample of 5000 trees from
which the consensus topology was calculated. Convergence was assessed with Tracer v1.5 (tree.bio.
ed.ac.uk/software/tracer/). A node was considered
strongly supported when the posterior probability
value was 0.95 or greater. Both ML and Bayesian
inference trees were visualized with FigTree v1.4.0
(tree.bio.ed.ac.uk/software/igtree/).
Chemistry
We employed thin layer chromatography (TLC)
to study secondary metabolites, as described for
lichens by Culberson (1972) with modiications
(Culberson & Johnson 1982). The nomenclature
of secondary metabolites follows Huneck & Yoshimura (1996), except for confriesiic and friesiic
acids, which follow Elix et al. (2004) and Elix
(2005). Friesiic acid is a rare, trinuclear, secondary
metabolic product in lichenized fungi, with both
depside and depsidone moieties (a depsido-depsone). Originally described from Xylopsora friesii
(= Hypocenomyce friesii; Bendiksby & Timdal
2013), it is also found in Xylographa isidiosa (Elix
2005, as Hypocenomyce isidiosa) and Trapeliopsis
colensoi (Elix 2011). Confriesiic acid was origi-
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
nally described by Elix (2005) as a homologue of
friesiic acid. In all Xylographa species including
the one originally studied by Elix (2005), confriesiic acid is the major substance and friesiic acid, if
present at all, occurs in trace amounts. Confriesiic
acid can be recognized in TLC by its Rf values of
(A)0.12, (B’)0.23 and (C)0.16, luorescing blue in
UV356nm prior to heating and treatment with H2SO4.
It corresponds to the substance called Xhn-1 in
Brodo (1992).
Morphology
Morphological characters were studied in water,
in potassium hydroxide (KOH), in Lugol’s potassium iodide solution (Roth N052.1, hereafter
ILugols) and in lactophenol cotton blue (LCB; Merck
1.13741.0100). Ascomatal length and width takes
into consideration living, current-generation ascomata and excludes dead excipular shells and mixed
complexes of young and old ascomata; measurements were carried out on dry ascomata and indicate smallest absolute measurement-largest absolute measurement unless otherwise speciied.
Hymenial amyloidity was assessed after Baral
(1987). Ascospores were measured by preferentially selecting random loose (outside of the ascus)
ascospores; where this was not possible, a single
ascospore per ascus was selected. Means were
calculated individually per specimen and measurements are provided as (smallest absolute value-)
smallest mean-largest mean (-largest absolute value) over all measured specimens, unless otherwise
speciied.
Scanning electron microscopy was conducted
on dry thalli ixed to aluminum stubs with carbon
impregnated double sided tape, using an FEI XL30 scanning electron microscope. Samples were
sputtercoated with gold (AGAR Sputter Coater)
and studied in high vacuum mode using secondary
electron detection.
In past work on Xylographa, the terms soredia,
isidia and goniocyst have been inconsistently applied. Soredia are generally deined as a more or
less globose, fungal-algal cyst produced in soralia or forming the majority of a thallus (Tønsberg
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
1992). In the lichenological literature, this term has
in practice almost only been applied when the cyst
in question has a roughened surface or somehow
appears “soft” (Figs. 20F, 24D). In Xylographa
vitiligo, the structures called soredia by Tønsberg
(1992) and Ryan (2004a) were termed goniocysts
by Lumbsch (1997). The term goniocyst was applied by Coppins (1983, for Micarea) and Ryan
(2004a), by contrast, to loose “soredia” not associated with soralia. When the cyst has a smooth
surface, appears “hard”, and in some cases is afixed at one end to the thallus, the term isidia has
been used (Elix 2005, in Xylographa isidiosa: Figs.
9E, F), though the structures Elix (2005) refers to
as isidia are clearly identical to the goniocysts of
Ryan (2004a). When morphologically otherwise
identical structures adhere to the substrate, they
have been called granules. Two key points of relevance to the evolutionary biology of this group
may become buried in the semantics: 1) in all cases
we are dealing with extremely similar structures,
sometimes scattered, sometimes in special receptacles; using different terms creates the impression
of character states more different from each other
than they actually are. Whether or not these cysts
are “soft” or “hard” in appearance may have as
much to do with whether they contain crystallized,
suricial secondary metabolites as with any difference in cell structure. 2) More problematically,
cysts identical to “soredia” and “isidia” occur below the surface in well known species universally
stated to lack soredia and isidia: in Xylographa,
hard and soft cysts are frequently scattered both on
and in the thallus in the X. parallela complex; and
19
hard cysts indistinguishable from those in X. isidiosa are found e.g. in X. trunciseda (Fig. 22E), albeit embedded in grains of wood, or scattered over
the surface.
Soredia and isidia are both terms that have come
to embody speciic concepts, especially in macrolichens. This is not the place to weigh in about the
use of these terms in those groups. We chose here
to use goniocyst as an umbrella term to encompass
soredioid and isidioid structures formed anywhere
on the thallus and in any constellation. We thus
deine goniocyst in a broader sense than Coppins
(1983) or Lumbsch (1997): goniocysts are a basic
unit of fungal-algal interaction consisting of a single layer of fungal hyphae wrapped around one or
more photobiont cells; they encompass all forms of
cysts discussed here, including soredia. They can
occur endosubstratally, scattered over the surface
of the substrate or on more extensive fungal-algal
matrices (thallus), in delimited suricial clusters
(which we continue to call soredia and soralia), or
can form a continuous suricial crust.
Studied Material
Over 1000 specimens were studied from the 23
herbaria listed in the acknowledgments, as well as
previously unaccessioned material from CANL,
LE and UBC. Fresh material was collected during
ield work in western North America (2007-2012),
eastern North America (2009), Austria (2013),
Spain (2009), Turkey (2007) and the Russian Far
East (2007, 2009). Specimen citation follows standard protocols with romanization of Cyrillic place
names following the BGN/PCGN system.
Results
We obtained a total of 204 new DNA sequences
including 168 of members of Xylographa from 68
new isolates as well as 36 of outgroup taxa from
13 new isolates. For Xylographa, three-locus coverage was complete for 33 individuals, while two
loci were obtained for a further 34 individuals.
Two single-locus individuals are included here but
a further 21 single-locus individuals were obtained
that were excluded from further analysis. Twentyone isolates were also incorporated from GenBank,
for a total data set of 103 isolates and 261 sequences (96 ITS, 90 mtSSU and 75 28S sequences). The
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
20
T. Spribille et al.
raw data matrix consists of 6143 positions, including long introns between the ITS1F primer binding site and the beginning of the ITS, and in the
middle of the 28S subunit. Obtaining full-length
28S fragments was made dificult through the frequent presence of introns in and adjacent to primer
binding sites, and 28S was not possible to obtain
for some samples. Following removal of introns,
lanking regions and non-conserved sites, the ITS
data set consisted of 610 BP, mtSSU 711 BP and
28S 750 BP for a total length of 2071 positions.
Testing of substitution models yielded GTR+I+G
for ITS, TIM2+I+G for mtSSU and TIM1+I+G for
28S excluding introns. Comparison of individual
gene trees revealed no supported topological conlict between any of the sampled loci and loci were
thus combined for all further analyses.
Bayesian analysis
The two runs of the MCMC analysis converged
on similar solutions after less than 500,000 generations. The mean standard deviation of frequencies of splits (SDSF) with a value of 0.1 or higher
across both runs was 0.009271 after 2.5 million
generations, and 0.003879 after 10 million generations. The best results for chain mixing were
obtained with single chain swapping and the heat
parameter set to 0.2. Parallel runs with the heat
parameter set to 0.025 and 0.1 yielded less chain
mixing and higher SDSF values.
Maximum likelihood
The topology obtained by the maximum likelihood
analysis was similar to that of the MCMC/Bayesian inference approach and there were no supported conlicts. The inal best scoring tree had a log
likelihood of –18691.91.
Relationships among sampled taxa
The Bayesian and maximum likelihood analyses
yielded similar topologies (Fig. 1). Among the
sampled outgroup taxa, Dibaeis and Icmadophila,
Baeomycetaceae (Baeomyces and Phyllobaeis)
and Hymeneliaceae (Hymenelia and Tremolecia)
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
are well supported while the genus Ainoa is recovered as its own monophyletic group. Genera traditionally assigned to Trapeliaceae are recovered in
a single strongly supported clade, which consists
of two non-supported, multigeneric clades. The
irst contains Rimularia s.str. (R. limborina, the
type species), Trapeliopsis, Placynthiella, Trapelia
and Placopsis; the second contains Lithographa,
Ptychographa, Rimularia psephota/R. insularis (=
Lambiella, see below) and Xylographa. Relationships among isolates of genera in the irst clade
are strongly supported with the exception of the
relationship of Rimularia s.str. to the remaining
genera. In the second clade, none of the genuslevel relationships are strongly supported. Furthermore, there is strong support for the monophyly
of Lithographa, Ptychographa and the Rimularia
psephota/R. insularis group based on our taxon
sample.
All pre-existing, described taxa previously assigned to Xylographa and included in our sample
are strongly supported as a monophyletic group.
In total, we recovered 15 low-level clades, corresponding to morpho-chemical units identiied in
the initial screening, as monophyletic and strongly
supported in both the Bayesian and maximum likelihood analyses. Eight of these, including several
single-individual tip clades, are described here as
new species (see Taxonomic section). Of the morphospecies we analysed, only two, X. vitiligo and
“X. vermicularis” are not strongly reciprocally
monophyletic. Sequences from the single isolate of
X. minutula were identical to and recovered within
X. parallela.
Within Xylographa, several higher level multispecies relationships are strongly supported in the
Bayesian analysis but not in the maximum likelihood analysis (species described as new later in
this paper are given in quotation marks): (1) the
monophyly of the X. opegraphella group, including X. opegraphella, X. hians and “X. erratica”;
(2) the monophyly of the X. vitiligo group including X. vitiligo and “X. vermicularis”; and (3) the
monophyly of the X. parallela group, including six
species: X. parallela, “X. septentrionalis”, X. difformis, “X. stenospora”, X. rubescens and X. pal-
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
lens. These three groups plus X. soralifera form a
well-supported monophyletic group together with
our single sample of X. carneopallida and a genetically aberrant sample of X. septentrionalis s. lat.,
again only in the Bayesian analysis. No resolution,
21
by contrast, was obtained for a group of basal taxa
including X. disseminata, X. trunciseda, X. isidiosa
and “X. bjoerkii”, which form a polytomy, or the
relationship of “X. lagoi” to the rest of the species
of the genus.
Discussion
The subclass Ostropomycetidae has seen considerable investment in recent decades to resolve
species diversity and relationships, particularly in
the orders Ostropales and Pertusariales (Schmitt
& Lumbsch 2004; Rivas Plata & Lumbsch 2011).
Large sampling gaps however still stand in the way
of understanding evolution in this subclass. Filling
these gaps is a prohibitive task: not only is investment needed in material acquisition and DNA
sequencing, but the taxonomy and nomenclature
are in many cases still stuck in the 19th century. In
the present paper, we present a irst molecular and
morphological reassessment of the genus Xylographa with support for roughly doubling the number
of currently accepted species.
Our phylogenetic sampling is comprehensive in
that it covers nearly all previously accepted species with the exception of the Sonoran Xylographa
crassithallia and X. pruinodisca (Ryan 2004a),
both of which are known only from their holotype
specimens. We recovered strong support for the six
widely recognized species X. disseminata, X. hians, X. opegraphella, X. parallela, X. trunciseda
and X. vitiligo as well as the recently described X.
isidiosa (Elix 2005; Bendiksby & Timdal 2013)
and X. soralifera (Holien & Tønsberg 2008). Of
species recognized in recent taxonomic works,
only X. minutula (recognized by Wirth et al. 2013)
is not supported and is clearly conspeciic with
X. parallela. In addition to these eight clades for
previously accepted species, we recovered an additional eight well-supported multi-individual
clades. Close examination of the specimen material behind these clades showed that all eight could
be distinguished by morphological and/or chemical characters. Three of the clades corresponded to
type specimens of historically recognized taxa (X.
difformis, Vainio 1883; X. pallens, Harmand 1900;
X. rubescens, Vainio 1921) and ive are described
below as new species (X. bjoerkii, X. erratica, X.
septentrionalis, X. stenospora, X. vermicularis).
Finally, we sequenced several putative new species known only from a single or few specimens
that were so morphologically distinct as to not be
reconcilable with any presently accepted species.
We recovered these single individuals as tip clades
distinct from other sampled species and take this
in combination with their divergent morphology to
support their recognition. One of these corresponds
to an earlier described variety (X. carneopallida,
Räsänen 1939, as a variety of X. rubescens) while
two others we describe as new species: X. constricta, a distinctive species forming ascomatal rings,
and the irst veriied non-lichenized member of
Baeomycetales, from extreme southern Chile; and
X. lagoi, the irst species of the genus with thamnolic acid, from northern Spain. Finally, one species,
X. schoieldii, was recognized as chemically and
morphologically distinct based on three specimens
but only a single locus (mtSSU) could be obtained,
which only narrowed its assignment to Xylographa. The inclusion of this sequence in the phylogenetic analyses signiicantly weakened backbone
support for other relationships due to the multiple
equally supported options for its placement, and
thus it was excluded from our inal analyses.
Backbone support for relationships between
species and species groups in Xylographa is weak,
as is support for relationships between Xylographa
and Lambiella, Lithographa and Ptychographa,
respectively. The reason for this is most likely
twofold: 1) The data set contains gaps and missSymb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
22
T. Spribille et al.
Fig. 1a. Phylogenetic relationships within Xylographa and its relationships to other genera of
Baeomycetales. Concatenated ITS, 28S and mtSSU rDNA (2071 characters). Consensus tree
calculated from 5000 tree posterior sample of Bayesian MCMC analysis. Node labels indicate
posterior probability/bootstrap values of maximum likelihood analysis.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
23
Xylographa parallela group
a
Fig. 1b. Continuation of Fig. 1a.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
24
T. Spribille et al.
ing data, particularly for the 28S locus. This can be
ascribed to the extreme dificulty in some cases of
obtaining PCR products from samples with low total nucleic acid concentrations (often <5 ng/µl) and
also the abundance of long Group I introns in 28S
primer binding sites in Xylographa and Rimularia
s.lat.. We were able to partly alleviate this problem by designing a Trapeliaceae-speciic 28S reverse primer that could be used in conjunction with
ITS1F for obtaining the irst 600-700 BP of the 28S
ribosomal subunit (primer LR4_Trap, Table 2),
though sometimes we obtained only shorter fragments using ITS1F in combination with LR3. Ultimately, fragment length varied enough after about
position 650 of 28S that we ended up excluding ca.
2/3 of our original alignment positions (most but
not all introns and lanking regions) in our Gblocks
analysis, as well as numerous individuals with particularly lacunose sequence data. 2) The three loci
were not equally informative, with the amount of
parsimony-informative sites decreasing in the order ITS>28S>mtSSU. This meant that behaviour
of many ITS-mtSSU two-locus individuals in the
phylogenetic analyses was largely driven by the
ITS data and particularly accentuated the problem
of missing 28S data. This was not clear at the beginning of our sequencing effort and might have
been offset had we been able to replace mtSSU
with a more informative protein-coding locus.
Evolution of ascomata in
xylographoid lichens
Early authors assumed that all crustose lichens
with “lirellae”, or linearized ascomata, are closely
related, and placed unrelated genera such as Graphis, Opegrapha, Ptychographa and Xylographa
in Graphidaceae (e.g., Zahlbruckner 1922; Redinger 1938). Implicit is the assumption that linearized
ascomata must have arisen only once in evolution.
While some early authors expressed skepticism
and pointed to similarities between Xylographa
and species with roundish ascomata, e.g. what is
now called Placynthiella (Hedlund 1892), it was
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
not until comparatively recently that these species
groups began to be formally reassigned, and thus
their multiple origins at least tacitly conceded. Our
molecular phylogeny conirms that three of these
genera, Lithographa, Ptychographa and Xylographa, evolved from a single common ancestor,
though the exact sister group relationships remain
unclear. It also shows that Rimularia, a genus
recognized to be closely related to Lithographa
already by Hertel & Rambold (1990), is indeed
closely related but consists of disparate elements.
The type species of the genus, R. limborina, was recovered in our study as sister to the clade including
Trapelia, Placynthiella, Trapeliopsis and Placopsis, though unsupported (Fig. 1), while two other
species (R. psephota, R. insularis) are recovered in
the vicinity of Lithographa, Ptychographa and Xylographa. These species, recognized as Lambiella
(Hertel 1984 and Taxonomic section, below), have
angular to roundish ascomata and insert further ascomatal variation into the clade with Xylographa.
The elucidation of the phylogenetic relationship of
Lambiella to Xylographa will probably be key in
understanding the evolution of the extraordinary
substrate speciicity in the latter genus. However,
reconstructing the ancestral state will not be possible until statistical support can be achieved for
the backbone relationships of these main groups.
The ascomatal architecture in our species lineup suggests that constraints on ascoma form must
be relaxed in the xylographoid genera, allowing a
considerable range of variation, and ixation of advantageous forms in different species groups. In Xylographa, this range of variation encompasses both
the shape and regenerative ability of the ascomata,
with the evolution of growth forms that appear to
enable lateral growth or “creep” of the ascomata.
Speciic growth patterns are strongly correlated
with the clades and species recovered here. Several apparently basal species of Xylographa have
striking ascomatal development patterns including
ring formation (X. constricta) and peri-ascomatal
budding, without much evident lateral creep (X.
bjoerkii, X. lagoi). In the remaining species, two
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
broad patterns can be distinguished: 1) “trunciseda-type” ascomata, which regenerate from tips of
necrotic former ascomata with a new, completely
marginate ascoma (i.e. an exciple is formed all
away around the new hymenium: Fig. 6B, 8F, 22C
and 2) “parallela-type” ascomata, which advance
25
continuously from the original starting point of the
ascoma and do not form a deinite margin facing
the necrotic shell they grow out of (Figs. 15B, 15D,
15F, 21B). Both of these ascomatal growth patterns
are unique, to our knowledge, to Xylographa.
Taxonomic section
Lambiella Hertel
Beih. Nova Hedwigia 79: 459 (1984). Typus generis: Lambiella psephota (Tuck.) Hertel
Hertel (1984) based the genus Lambiella on
the presence of an amyloid medulla (incidentally
shared with several Xylographa species), the nongyrose ascomata, and the less reticulate paraphysal
networks compared to Rimularia s.str. He however
stopped recognizing the genus only a few years later and recombined the type species into Rimularia
without explanation (Hertel 1987). Our molecular
results lend support to Hertel’s (1984) hypothesis that Rimularia psephota constitutes a distinct
group from the type of Rimularia, R. limborina.
Additional morphological support may be lent by
Xylographa (Fr. : Fr.) Fr.
Fl. Scan. 344 (1836). Typus generis: Xylographa
parallela (Ach. : Fr.) Fr. (Clements & Shear 1931).
= Stictis B. Xylographa Fr. : Fr., Syst. Mycol. 2(1):
197 (1822).
?= Spiloma Ach., Methodus: 9 (1803). Typus generis: apparently never typiied.
= Xylographomyces Cif. & Tom., Atti Istit. Bot.
Univ. Lab. Crittog. Pavia, ser. 5, 10: 42 (1953),
nom. illeg. (Lücking & Hawksworth 2007).
Ascomata hemiangiocarpic, angular to linear, with
exposed to nearly concealed disc; exciple of interwoven hyphae, pigmented but non-carbonaceous,
detailed study of ascus apical structures, already
depicted by Hertel & Rambold (1990). A discussion of this and the necessary re-circumscription
of generic characters will be discussed at length
elsewhere. In the interim, the following new combination is necessary for one of the common and
characteristic elements of this clade:
Lambiella insularis (Nyl.) T. Sprib., comb.
nov. Mycobank No. MB 805263.
Lecidea insularis Nyl., Bot. Not. 1852: 177 (1852);
Rimularia insularis (Nyl.) Hertel & Rambold,
Lecideac. Exs. Fasc. 8: 9, no. 159 (1985). Type:
[Sweden:] ad Holmiam [=Stockholm], 1852, W.
Nylander (H-NYL 14031).
not amyloid, folded at termina of ascoma, growth
tips nearly always with strongly birefringent (POL+)
cell walls, and sometimes also inspersed with POL+
crystals; hypothecium of swollen hyphae, paraplectenchymatous as visible in section, giving way
upwards to strongly thickened ascogenous hyphae,
hemiamyloid or not amyloid; hymenium usually
hemiamyloid, rarely euamyloid, with brown pigmentation, often also with a slate gray, HNO3–, C–,
KOH– pigment in the inner walls of paraphyses;
asci unitunicate, clavate to almost cylindrical, gelatinous sheaths covering the walls amyloid, tholus
lacking internal amyloid structures, similar to that
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
26
T. Spribille et al.
in Trapelia; ascospores 8/ascus, single-celled, thinwalled, colourless, broadly to narrowly ellipsoid.
Conidiomata pycnidia, globose, 2/3 immersed
to suricial and ±adnate, with conidiogenous hyphae of Type V (Vobis 1980); conidia iliform,
curved.
Sterile hyphae occuring in lignum interstices, non-amyloid, rarely (e.g. in X. vermicularis)
euamyloid in dense patches below the ascoma (well
below the hypothecium); usually forming an endosubstratal to episubstratal thallus irst with small
“plugs” of algal cells, occasionally also more extensive suricial crusts, in one species non-lichenized.
Trebouxia spp. veriied as photobiont in several
species by DNA sequencing (K. Schneider & T.
Spribille, unpublished data).
Key to the species of Xylographa
1. Thallus with a distinct suricial layer or piles
of corticate goniocysts or isidia; ascomata
present or more often absent. .........................2
1. Thallus without or at most with scattered
goniocysts; always fertile. .............................8
2. Thallus P–, KOH–. ........................................3
2. Thallus P+ orange, KOH+ yellow-orange to
dingy brown-yellow, containing stictic, norstictic or fumarprotocetraric acids. ................6
3. Thallus granular or apparently isidiate, the
goniocysts prominent, whitish, to 0.12 mm;
ascomata usually present; with fatty acids. ......
................................................... X. disseminata
3. Thallus with small brown goniocysts usually
not more than 0.06 mm diam.; with confriesiic
acid. ................................................................4
4. Goniocysts conined to punctiform soralia,
these strongly convex; ascomata not known. ..
......................................................X. schoieldii
4. Goniocysts not conined to soralia, forming a
thin to thick crust. ..........................................5
5. Goniocysts sparse, dispersed over wood or
endolignic; ascomata present, dark brown to
black, strongly constricted at base, with thick
margins. [see lead 12: X. bjoerkii]
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
5. Goniocysts abundant, forming a thick crust;
ascomata not known. .......................X. isidiosa
6. Soralia strongly convex; thallus with fumarprotocetraric acid. ....................... X. soralifera
6. Soralia concave to weakly convex; thallus
with stictic and/or norstictic acid. ..................7
7. Soralia creamy to salt-and-pepper pigmented
or grayish; goniocysts matte, roughened in
surface view and indistinctly demarcated in
squash preparations; ascomata, when present,
short, ±trunciseda-type, budding, forming
chains or contorted stars. .................X. vitiligo
[rare soraliate forms of X. vermicularis will
key here, and can be separated only by TLC:
confriesiic acid in addition to stictic acid]
7. Soralia dark brown; goniocysts appearing
“hard”, easy to see as sharply delimited brown
balls in squash preparations; ascomata, when
present, parallela-type. ....... X. septentrionalis
8. Ascomata short, L/W ratio 1.5–3, usually with
a complete exciple, single or regenerating
from tips of spent ascomata to form chains or
stars. ................................................................9
8. Ascomata long, L/W ratio 3–8 or more, often
with open exciples towards the spent portions
of the ascoma (X. parallela group). .............18
9. Thallus P–, KOH–. ......................................10
9. Thallus (or ascomatal sections) P+, KOH+
yellow to orange. .........................................14
10. Ascomata dark brown or nearly black, nearly
as tall as wide in section, strongly constricted
at the base; ascomata not obviously regenerating from tips of dead ascomatal shells; tips
of paraphyses and excipular hyphae pigmentcapped. .........................................................11
10. Ascomata pale brown to grayish brown;
ascomata regenerating from tips of ascomatal
shells; paraphysis tips and excipular hyphae
weakly if at all pigment-capped. .................13
11. Ascomata produced in rings, these squeezing
grains of wood into small mounds when mature.
Lacking symbiotic algae. ...............X. constricta
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
11. Ascomata not produced in rings; algae always
present (though sometimes hard to see: check
transverse sections). .....................................12
12. Thallus immersed or barely visible along
or above grains of wood, consisting of tiny,
brown goniocysts to 0.04 mm diam.; with
confriesiic acid. ...............................X. bjoerkii
12. Thallus suricial, verrucose-granular, with
whitish gray granules to 0.12 mm; with fatty
acids.[lead 3: X. disseminata]
13. Ascospores averaging 12.2–14.1 × 6.8–8.4 µm;
hymenium 80–120 µm tall; ascomata beige to
pale brown, not forming regular chains, often not
arranged in a linear plane; thallus immersed to
suricial, smooth, pale brown to grayish brown;
confriesiic acid, with or without accessory stictic
acid (the common, KOH+ yellowish form;
keyed under lead 17). .................. X. vermicularis
13. Ascospores averaging 10.1–11.3 × 5.2–6.1
µm; hymenium 60–85 µm tall; ascomata
brown, forming regular chains in a single
linear plane from dead excipular shells; thallus
immersed, consisting of goniocysts developed
in the hollowed remains of lignum cells; confriesiic acid. ................................ X. trunciseda
14. Ascomatal disc jet black, the margin white and
lexuose; with thamnolic acid. ............X. lagoi
14. Ascomatal disc brown to gray; thallus with
stictic and/or norstictic acid. ........................15
15. Ascospores short and narrow, averaging
9.4–11.3 × 3.4–3.9 μm; ascomata variably
with concealed or exposed disc when moist,
or hymenium abortive; ascomatal pigments
brown, usually with some admixed gray
pigment; often with norstictic acid as major
constituent in thallus ..............X. opegraphella
15. Ascospores generally >11 μm long and >5
μm wide; ascomata usually with exposed disc
when moist; ascomatal pigments brown, gray
present or absent; major constituent almost
always stictic acid. ....................................... 16
27
16. Ascospores 11.0–12.2 × 5.3–6.0 μm (average
of 10 spores); hymenium 60-80 µm tall; ascomata usually not aggregated, growing mainly
in one direction, not forming spikes or stars;
hymenial brown pigments present, gray pigments lacking; moistened (!) thallus with gray
or (rarely) reddish prothallus .........X. erratica
16. Ascospores averaging >12 µm long and >6.0
µm wide; ascomata single or aggregated;
hymenium (50-)80-130 µm tall; hymenial
pigments absent or present, brown to gray;
moistened thallus usually not with gray prothallus and never with reddish prothallus ... 17
17. Thallus always with confriesiic acid (major),
usually also with stictic acid (TLC); ascomata
pale beige, upper 1/5 of paraphyses unpigmented or pale brown; ascomata simple or
proliferating in two directions, not forming
stars; ascospores broad, 12.2–14.1 × 6.8–8.4
μm (average of 10 spores). [lead 13: X.
vermicularis]
17. Thallus with stictic acid, never with confriesiic acid (TLC); ascomata brown to gray, gray
pigments often prominent in exciple and upper hymenium; ascomata variable, but usually
budding in two to multiple directions, growing out from excipular shell to form spikes
or stars; ascospores averaging 12.1–13.5 ×
6.2–7.4 μm (average of 10 spores) ..... X. hians
18. Ascomata growing in one or at most two
directions from point of origin, linear and narrowly ellipsoid or with an irregular, lexuose
outline. ..........................................................19
18. Ascomata growing in two or many directions
from point of origin, creating “stars” (examine
mature material). ..........................................22
19. Ascomata essentially unpigmented: exciples
lighter than discs, prominent; upper 1/5 of
paraphyses not pigmented. ......X. carneopallida
19. Ascomata pigmented: exciples brown, usually
not lighter than discs; paraphysis tips conspicuously pigment-capped. ........................20
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
28
T. Spribille et al.
20. Hymenium strongly infused above with gray
pigment, discs thus essentially black; ascospores narrow, averaging 10.9–12.7 × 3.3–4.5
µm. ..............................................X. stenospora
20. Hymenium pigmented brown or with slight
tinge of gray, or unpigmented; ascospores
averaging >4.5 µm wide or if narrower then
>12.5 µm long. .............................................21
21. Ascomata irregular, with lexuose margin
prominent in young ascomata, brown to pale
creamish, forming loose colonies; ascospore
L/W ratio 2.74±0.74, averaging 4.1–6.1 µm
wide (measure 10 ascospores); exciple internally full of crystals and POL+; hymenium
inspersed with scattered POL+ crystals or guttulae; ascomata and adjacent thallus in section
KOH+ yellow-orange, forming red needles
(norstictic acid); conidia 14–19 µm long. ........
........................................................X. difformis
21. Ascomata ±straight, margin straight, brown,
narrow, margin sometimes only visible at
tips, forming dense regularly spaced colonies;
ascospore L/W ratio 2.03 ±0.35, averaging
5.9–7.6 µm wide (measure 10 ascospores);
exciple internally with faint POL+ birefringent
cell walls but no crystals; hymenium without
crystals or guttulae; ascomata and adjacent
thallus in section KOH+ yellow or KOH–
(stictic acid or no substances); conidia 9–14
µm long. ....................................... X. parallela
22. Ascomatal margins prominent, lexuose,
pale creamish, lighter than disc, persistent;
ascomata usually in ±linear groups, discs often
characteristically fragmented, often forming
chains of broken hymenia; thallus with pale
creamish goniocysts; with dominant norstictic
acid (KOH+ bleeding orange-red crystals) in
thallus or at least in ascomatal margin..............
...................................................... X. rubescens
22. Ascomatal margins inconspicuous, straight,
brownish, usually ±concolourous with disc,
usually receding and ascomata becoming apparently emarginate; ascomata often forming
star-like groups, discs not fragmented, remaining continuous or with few irregular breaks
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
in old ascomata; thallus often with brown
goniocysts; with stictic acid and ±accessory
norstictic acid (KOH+ oozing yellow in section, occasionally also with some red crystals).
...........................................................X. pallens
Xylographa bjoerkii T. Sprib., sp.
nov. (Fig. 2) Mycobank No.: MB
805255.
Similar to X. disseminata, but ascospores shorter,
thallus reduced and containing confriesiic acid as
major secondary metabolite; algae lacking in immediate vicinity of ascomata, but alga-containing
goniocysts scattered between ascomata.
Type: Canada: British Columbia, Coast Ranges, Bute
Inlet, Homathko Valley, 117 km NNE of Campbell River,
Smith Creek waterfall on west side of valley near Brew
Creek; 51°01.532’N, 124°58.343’W, lignicolous on
Thuja plicata log in waterfall spray zone, 45 m elev., 15
Sept 2009, C.R. Björk 19856 (UBC, holotype; CANL,
isotype).
Etymology: Xylographa bjoerkii is named for Curtis
Björk, originally of Spokane, Washington, in recognition of his outstanding contributions to botany in western
North America, and his collection of original material of
this species.
Ascomata with lateral growth of truncisedatype, with limited “budding” from parent ascomata; form angular, variably broadly or narrowly ellipsoid, strongly constricted basally,
(0.18–)0.24–0.45 × 0.09–0.18 mm, L/W ratio
2.66±0.86; disc strongly concave, dark brown to
black, matte, with thick, light to dark brown to
black, lexuose margin; exciple of laterally interwoven hyphae, appearing paraplectenchymatous
in vertical section, lush with the hymenium surface in section, often strongly thickened, 15–75
µm wide; excipular hyphae pigmented brown externally, with expanded, almost bulbous, strongly
dark brown-pigmented terminal cells to 4 µm
diam., exciple lacking crystals but internally
with weakly birefringent cell walls; hypothecium
70–120 µm deep, hyaline; hymenium 50–80 µm
deep, pale brownish to hyaline, hemiamyloid
(ILugols+ greenish blue à rust red); consisting of
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
29
Fig. 2. Xylographa bjoerkii T. Sprib. A, arrangement of ascomata and goniocysts on bare wood; B, ascomata, in water;
C, section through ascoma, in LCB; D, conidia, in water. A, C, D: Canada, British Columbia, Björk 14570 (UBC, DNA
voucher 2422); B, holotype. Scale bars: A, 0.2 mm; B, C, 50 µm; D, 10 µm.
asci 45–65 × 11–12 µm embedded in a matrix of
thin, branched and anastomosed paraphyses ca.
1.0–1.5 µm at midpoint, distally thickened to 4–5
µm in the apical cell, with brown and sometimes
also gray wall pigments; ascospores 8/ascus,
hyaline, old spores occasionally olivaceous or
brownish, simple, rarely apparently 1-septate, ellipsoid, (10–)11.6–13.2(–15) × (4.5–)5.6–6.8(–8)
µm (L/W ratio 2.04±0.23) (n = 32). Conidiomata seen in one specimen, occurring in a separate
zone from ascomata, adnate, cupular, with wall
of laterally interwoven hyphae appearing paraplectenchymatous in section, hyphae with internal gray or gray-black to brown wall pigments;
conidia iliform, curved, 10 × ca. 0.5 µm. Sterile
hyphae intercalated among xylem cells, irregu-
larly forming darkly pigmented goniocysts 30–65
µm diam, these suricial or immersed. Associated
algae chlorococcoid, 6–8 µm diam.
Chemistry: confriesiic acid only.
substrate affinity: on wood (almost certainly of
conifers), including on maritime driftwood.
maCroeCology: maritime coastal rainforests and
open salt marshes, 0–600 m.
Xylographa bjoerkii is a rarely collected species
from the hypermaritime coast of western North
America. Without secondary chemistry results it
can be dificult to distinguish from some forms of
X. hians. It is the only species of Xylographa with
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
30
T. Spribille et al.
confriesiic acid in which the terminal cells of the
paraphyses and excipular hyphae are expanded and
the ascomata develop deeply concave discs with
thickened excipula (Fig. 2B see also Table 3, p.
43). The thallus in X. bjoerkii is sparse and consists
of goniocysts 10–40 µm in diametre, which may
be visible only upon wetting or in section. Xylographa bjoerkii may be related to the unlichenized
species X. constricta and it is conceivable that X.
bjoerkii is only facultatively lichenized.
additional speCimens examined: Canada: British Columbia, Southgate River near Bishop conluence, no
date, C.R. Björk 14570 (UBC); U.S.A.: Alaska, Glacier Bay National Park and Preserve, Taylor Bay in Icy
Straits, lignicolous on beach log, 9 Aug 2012, T. Spribille
39752 & A. Fryday (GZU); Oregon, Douglas Co., Coast
Range 12 km W of Winston, Irwin Rocks, Bushnell-Irwin
Rocks Research Natural Area, 43.124°N, 123.561°W,
[lignicolous] on gnarly old Pseudotsuga, 600 m, 6 Dec
2006, B. McCune 28535 (herb. McCune).
Xylographa carneopallida (Räsänen)
T. Sprib., comb. nov. (Fig. 3)
Mycobank No.: MB 805264.
Xylographa rubescens var. carneopallida Räsänen,
Ann. Bot. Soc. Zool.-Bot. Fenn. Vanamo 12(1): 181
(1939). Type: Finland: S[avonia] b[orealis], Kuopio,
Tiiholankylä, Vehmasjärvi, 26 Jul 1909, K. Linkola (H,
holotype!). The type specimen consists of two pieces of
wood with a mixture of Xylographa parallela s .str., X.
trunciseda and, on the outside parts of the fragment, two
thalli of X. carneopallida. These have lighter ascomata
than the rest of the sample and were obviously tested previously with KOH, and are considered the holotype. The
smaller piece of wood contains only X. parallela and X.
trunciseda.
Ascomata with lateral growth of parallela-type,
not proliferating through “budding” ascomata,
continuously growing in opposite directions, form
linear, 0.66–2.1 × 0.12–0.24 mm, L/W ratio 2.75–
17.5 (absolute measurements); disc lat, beige to
pale brown, matte, with thin, white, straight, persistent margin; exciple appearing paraplectenchymatous in vertical section, 18–45 µm wide laterally; excipular hyphae unpigmented, illed with
POL+ crystals throughout entire exciple; hypothecium 70–80 µm deep, hyaline; hymenium 80–90
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
µm deep, hyaline, inspersed with scattered POL+
crystals or guttulae, euamyloid (ILugols+ royal blue),
consisting of asci 63–75 × 8–10 µm embedded in
a matrix of slender paraphyses 1.5–2 µm wide at
midpoint, not thickened apically and unpigmented; ascospores 8/ascus, ellipsoid, (9.5–)11.4(–13)
× (4.5–)5.3(–6) µm (L/W ratio 1.9–2.4) (n = 10).
Conidiomata not seen. Sterile hyphae mostly
lichenized, conluent around clumps of algae, rimose, lumpy with convex areoles, to 70 µm thick;
lacking goniocysts. Associated chlorococcoid,
8–12 µm diam.
Chemistry: norstictic and stictic acids in apparently ±equal amounts.
substrate affinity: on wood (logs).
maCroeCology: in boreal and upper montane forests, too disjunct to generalize.
Xylographa carneopallida is an enigmatic species,
the only member of the genus with parallela-type
ascomata lacking ascomatal pigments. Its long
ascomata suggest a member of the X. parallela
group, but molecular data from a sample collected
in the Yukon suggest it occupies a position outside
of, and possibly ancestral to, both that group and
X. opegraphella. Räsänen (1939) described it as a
variety of X. rubescens, but it differs from that species in its long, narrow, irmly attached ascomata
that do not detach or fragment, and the complete
lack of dark pigments. It appears to be a rare but
widespread species; it is known to us only from
the type and one collection each from Alaska, New
Hampshire, the Yukon and Russia.
additional speCimens examined: Canada: Yukon, banks
of LaBiche River north of Kootaneelee natural gas facility, 60°09.081’N, 124°04.906’W, 379 m, 26 Aug 2008,
T. Spribille 28528 (GZU); same locality, same date, C.
Miller, T. Spribille & C. Printzen 10763 (FR); Russia:
Khabarovskiy Kray, Bureinskiy Zapovednik, upper reach
of the Pravaya Bureya River, Tsarskaya Dorogа, ca. 650
m N of patrol cabin ‘Staraya Medvezhka’, 25 km SE
of Soiysk and 2.6 km N (upstream) of the patrol cabin
‘Novaya Medvezhka’, 52°09.002’N, 134°19.035’E,
872 m, 02 Aug 2009, T. Spribille 31772 (H); U.S.A.:
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
31
Fig. 3. Xylographa carneopallida (Räsänen) T. Sprib. A, habit and arrangement of ascomata; B, section through
ascoma, in water; C, hymenium showing immature asci and thin, ilamentous paraphyses, in water; D, ascospores, in
water. All photos from Canada, Yukon, Spribille 28528 (GZU, DNA voucher 1024). Scale bars: A, 0.5 µm; B, 20 µm;
C, D, 10 µm.
Alaska, Fairbanks-North Star Borough, ca. 49 km ENE
of Fairbanks, Chena River State Recreation Area, along
main road, near start of Compleau Trail, 64°45.338’N,
148°22.921’W, 278 m, 11 Aug 2008, T. Spribille 27432
& C. Miller (GZU); [New Hampshire,] White Mtns, H.
Willey (FH).
Xylographa constricta T. Sprib.,
sp. nov. (Fig. 4) Mycobank No.: MB
805256.
Ascomata similar to those of X. disseminata, narrow with thinly exposed discs, arising in small
groups and growing concentrically outwards,
squeezing wood ibres together into a raised “hill”.
Sterile hyphae not associated with algae.
Type: Chile: Prov. Antártica Chilena, Comuna Cabo de
Hornos, Parque Nacional Alberto de Agostini, N shore of
Isla Hoste, SE end of Península Cloué, S end of Estero
Fouque, S shore of stream that drains Lago Covadonga,
55°10’59”S, 69°34’50”W; boulder ield just ESE of glacier, on lignum, 21 Jan 2012, W.R. Buck 58580 (NY,
holotype).
Etymology: named for the ascomata, which form a ring
and give the appearance of constricting or squeezing
wood ibres together in its centre.
Ascomata appearing as narrow slits, apparently
beginning as a single ascoma and then radiating
outwards, ultimately forming a ring, in the centre
of which wood grains become squeezed together
into a shallow “hill”; form of ascomata narrowly
angular, tips acuminate, 0.24–0.42 × 0.06–1.2 mm,
L/W ratio 2.5–4.7 (absolute measurements); disc
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
32
T. Spribille et al.
Fig. 4. Xylographa constricta T. Sprib. A, arrangement of ascomata forming constricting ring, creating raised areas of
wood ibre; B, detail of ascomata; C, hand section through ascoma and wood substrate; D, asci with immature ascospores, in ILugols after preteatment with KOH. All photos from holotype (DNA voucher 1147). Scale bars: A, 1 mm; B,
0.2 mm; C, 50 µm; D, 10 µm.
concave, dark brown, matte, with thin brown margin; exciple paraplectenchymatous in vertical section, in lower part integral with and incorporating
xylem cells (Fig. 4C), 18–22 µm wide laterally;
excipular hyphae pigmented brown externally;
hypothecium 60–70 µm deep, pale reddish brown;
hymenium 60–65 µm deep, pale hazy brown
throughout, euamyloid (ILugols+ blue, turning violet
when lushed with KOH), consisting of asci 70–97
× 15–18 µm mingled with sparsely branched paraphyses ca. 2.5 µm at midpoint, distally thickened
to 3–4 µm in the apical cell, with brown wall pigments; ascospores 8/ascus, ellipsoid, (12–)13.4(–
16) × (6–)7.0(–7.5) µm (L/W ratio 1.7–2.3) (n =
12). Conidiomata ca. ¾ immersed, globose, wall
hyphae with internal brown and gray pigments;
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
empty in the only specimen seen, conidia not seen.
Sterile hyphae not lichenized, intercalating with
wood hyphae.
Chemistry: no substances detected.
substrate affinity: on bleached wood.
maCroeCology: from glacial forelands in Cape
Horn.
Though known so far only from a single collection, Xylographa constricta is one of the most distinctive members of the genus, its characters and
DNA evidence so clear that we feel it warrants
description based on even scant material. Its asco-
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
mata form concentric “fairy rings” that appear to
squeeze the wood ibres and raise them into small
heaps (Fig. 4A, B). It is also the only known member of the genus not to be associated with algae,
supporting the hypothesis of reversion to saproby
in Xylographa.
Xylographa difformis (Vain.) Vain.
(Fig. 5)
Ann. Acad. Scient. Fennicae, ser. A, 27(6b): 106 (1928).
Xylographa parallela var. difformis Vain., Med. Soc.
Fauna Flora Fenn. 10: 148 (1883). Type: [Finland:
Ostrobottnia kajanensis], Kuhmon kirkko. Varjoisella
seinällä [= Kuhmo church, on shaded wall], 1877, E.
Vainio (TUR-V 29123, lectotype, second piece from left,
designated here!). TLC: norstictic acid only.
= Xylographa pruinodisca B.D. Ryan & T.H. Nash, Lichen Flora of the Greater Sonoran Desert Region 2: 615
(2004). Type: U.S.A.: Arizona, Cochise Co., Chiricahua Mountains, north slope of Monte Vista Peak along
Turtle Creek Trail, 31°49’45”N, 109°18’30”W, 2770 m,
on wood, 4 Sept 1983, T.H. Nash 21049 (ASU-563143,
holotype!). TLC: norstictic acid only.
?=Xylographa crassithallia B.D. Ryan & T.H. Nash,
Lichen Flora of the Greater Sonoran Desert Region 2:
613 (2004). Type: U.S.A.: Arizona, Apache Co., Sunrise
ski area, Fort Apache Reservation, spruce-ir forest, on
rotten wood, elevation 9200’, 29 Aug 1975, T.H. Nash
11694-a (ASU-563144, holotype!). TLC: no substances
detected.
Ascomata with lateral growth of parallela-type,
not proliferating through “budding” ascomata;
form angular, irregular, variably broadly or narrowly ellipsoid, 0.36–1.2 × 0.09–0.3 mm, L/W
ratio 4.12±2.09; disc lat to convex, brown, matte,
with thin brown to pale cream, lexuose margin,
prominent in young ascomata, quickly receding
in older ascomata; exciple of laterally interwoven
hyphae, appearing paraplectenchymatous in vertical section, lush with the hymenium surface in
section, often strongly thickened, 22–80 µm wide;
excipular hyphae pigmented brown externally,
illed with POL+ crystals; hypothecium 70–150
µm deep, hyaline or pale hazy yellowish; hymenium 50–100 µm deep, pale hazy yellow-brown
throughout, interspersed with scattered POL+
crystals or guttulae, euamyloid (ILugols+ royal blue)
in all samples studied, consisting of asci 37–70 ×
33
11–20 µm embedded in a matrix of stout, sparsely
branched paraphyses 2.5–4 µm at midpoint, distally moniliform and thickened to 4–6(–6.5) µm
in the apical cell, with brown and sometimes also
gray wall pigments; ascospores 8/ascus, narrowly
ellipsoid, (10.0–)12.4–14.5(–20) × (3–)4.1–6.1(–7)
µm (L/W ratio 2.74±0.74) (n = 55). Conidiomata
seen in three specimens, adjacent to ascomata but
tending to occur in ±elongated, segregated zones,
adnate, cupular, with wall of laterally interwoven hyphae appearing paraplectenchymatous in
section, hyphae with internal gray or gray-black
to brown wall pigments; conidia long-iliform,
curved, 14–19 × ca. 0.5 µm. Sterile hyphae mostly lichenized, becoming conluent around clumps
of algae, lacking goniocysts; sometimes appearing
rimose or scurfy. Associated algae trebouxioid,
8–18 µm diam.
Chemistry: norstictic acid only or stictic acid and
submajor to trace amounts of norstictic acid.
substrate affinity: on wood, especially of snags.
maCroeCology: in continental boreal and high
elevation, montane conifer forests; in Finland in
boreal lowlands, in western North America at altitudes of 1000–2200 m.
There are three specimens from Finland in TURV under the name X. parallela var. difformis, that
correspond to localities in the protologue (Vainio
1883). They all appear to belong to the same species. Of these, the specimen from Kuhmo is the
richest and is designated here as the lectotype. The
specimens closely correspond to DNA vouchers
sampled in western North America for the present study in the non-breaking excipular-hymenial
transition (indicating it is not a member of the X.
opegraphella group), the strongly thickened and
pigment-capped paraphysis tips, and the proportionately long and narrow ascospores. Xylographa difformis is similar to X. rubescens and like
that species, it usually contains norstictic acid as
its main secondary substance (see Table 4, p. 54
for a comparison of this species with other memSymb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
34
T. Spribille et al.
Fig. 5. Xylographa difformis (Vain.) Vain. A, B, C: habit and arrangement of ascomata and thallus; D, section of hymenium showing thickened terminal portions of paraphyses and ascospores; E, habit of the type specimen of Xylographa
crassithallia Ryan & Nash (ASU); F, habit of the type specimen of Xylographa pruinodisca Ryan & Nash (ASU). A, D,
lectotype of X. difformis (TUR-V 29123); B, Canada, British Columbia, Spribille 20110 (GZU, DNA voucher 2421);
C, British Columbia, Spribille 25050 (GZU, DNA voucher 2404). Scale bars: A, E, F, 1 mm; B, C, 0.5 mm; D, 10 µm.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
bers of the X. parallela group). It can be distinguished from X. rubescens by its long, narrow ascospores averaging 12.4–14.5 × 4.1–6.1 µm, L/W
ratio 2.74±0.74 (10.8–12.5 × 5.5–6.7, L/W ratio
1.98±0.33 in X. rubescens), euamyloid, ILugol’s+
blue hymenium (I+ green turning rust red in X.
rubescens), stout paraphyses and pigment-capped
paraphysis tips (paraphyses thinner and lacking
pigment-capped tips in X. rubescens), and inally
its plain brown, receding margins (rarely pale and
thick; margins prominent, persistent and paler than
disc in X. rubescens). Xylographa difformis appears not to be closely related to X. rubescens and
forms a distinct clade together with the goniocystbearing species X. septentrionalis. Confusion with
X. opegraphella is also conceivable, but that species has shorter and narrower ascospores, 9.4–11.3
× 3.4–3.9 µm. Xylographa difformis is likely to be
dificult to detect in the ield because most thalli
look like a poorly developed or parasitized specimen of a member of the X. parallela group. Xylographa difformis may especially be confused with
forms of X. pallens, but has a habit of developing
contorted ascomata without a clear direction of
growth (Fig. 5B), unlike X. pallens, and they do
not lift off the substrate. The ascospore L/W ratio
is typically also larger than in most other members
of the X. parallela group. Xylographa pruinodisca
(Fig. 5F) was described from 2800 m elevation in
the mountains of Arizona by Ryan (2004a) based
on a single specimen, and is tentatively listed as
a synonym here. It shares with X. difformis the
short, lexuose ascomatal habit (note the scale bar
in Ryan 2004a indicates 2 mm but the ascomata,
as clearly indicated in the text, are no longer than
0.5 mm), stout, semimoniliform paraphyses and
pigment-capped paraphysis tips, receding, brown
margins, the long, narrow ascospores 12–20 x 4–6
µm, and the thick, suricial thallus with norstictic
acid. The “pruina” in X. pruinodisca are not in fact
pruina but unpigmented surface striations, created by paraphysis tips, that give the impression
of pruina. Final conirmation that it is conspeciic
with X. difformis will likely require sampling of a
larger range of material (only a single sample of X.
pruinodisca is known) and DNA sampling of fresh
35
material from the type locality, something that
was not possible in the current study. Xylographa
crassithallia (Fig. 5E) is another species described
by Ryan (2004a) from Arizona. We were unable to
obtain fresh material of this species for molecular
sampling. It is similar to X. difformis and the only
clear difference between the two appears to be its
lack of secondary metabolites. It may ultimately be
found to be a synonym of the latter.
Our knowledge of the distribution of Xylographa difformis is spotty, with a cluster of records
from boreal Finland and European Russia, and
several specimens from western North America,
from about 31°N in the Chiricahua Mountains of
Arizona to almost 60°N in the British ColumbiaYukon border region. Most western North American collections are from snags and not from logs,
although the data are too sparse to draw any inferences as to its ecology at this point. A specimen
in TUR from western Siberia, deposited under this
name by Vainio, has similar ascomata to those of
the lectotype but possesses distinct areoles that
break open apically into salt-and-pepper-coloured
soralia, and may represent another undescribed
species. Another enigmatic specimen is Poelt s.n.,
12.06.1965 (M), from the Lindbergschachten in
the Bavarian Forest in southeastern Germany, with
ascomata similar to X. difformis but small, bluegreenish thallus areoles unlike any otherwise seen
in Xylographa (stictic acid by TLC). Both of these
specimens may constitute rare forms or undescribed species from the vicinity of X. difformis,
but fresh material is needed.
additional speCimens examined: Canada: British Columbia, East Kootenays, Kootenay River E of Canal
Flats, Dry Creek, 04 Aug 2005, T. Spribille 17238 (GZU);
NW of province, S of Carcross, B.C. side, White Pass
hwy. at Tutshi River, T. Spribille 25050 (GZU); Selkirk
Mtns., Silvercup Ridge, T. Spribille 20110 (GZU); Russia: Karelian Republic, Belomorsk District, Vygostrov,
1996, T. Ahti 54300d (H); U.S.A.: Idaho, Shoshone Co.,
Bloom Peak, weathered snag, Jul 2006, C. Björk 13073
& R. O’Quinn (GZU, UBC).
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
36
T. Spribille et al.
Fig. 6. Xylographa disseminata Willey A, habit and arrangement of ascomata and thallus; B, ascomata and thallus
granules in water; C, detail of goniocyst, showing paraplectenchymatous cortex, in water; D, section through ascoma,
in water; E, asci and paraphyses in ILugols without pretreatment with KOH; F, asci and ejected ascospores in ILugols after
pretreatment with KOH. A, B, D, F from Canada, New Brunswick, Clayden 19609 (NBM, DNA voucher 822); C, E
from U.S.A., North Carolina, Tønsberg 37619 (BG, DNA voucher 823). Scale bars: A, 0.5 mm; B, C, 0.1 mm; D, 20
µm; E, F, 10 µm.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
37
Xylographa disseminata Willey
(Fig. 6)
Chemistry: 1-3 unidentiied fatty acid(s) (major),
confriesiic acid (trace).
in Tuckerman, Synopsis of North American Lichens 2:
112 (1888). Type: [U.S.A.: Massachusetts,] New Bedford, H. Willey (FH-00060438, lectotype, designated
here; BM, F, G, H-NYL p.m. 6772!, NY, US, isolectotypes). TLC (FH specimen): unidentiied fatty acid (major, RF class A2, B4, C3), confriesiic acid (trace).
substrate affinity: on wood, apparently mainly of
Cupressaceae; Willey (in the protologue, Tuckerman 1888) reported it from Cupressus wood and
we have seen collections from Thuja wood.
Ascomata with lateral growth of trunciseda-type,
regenerating in multiple directions off the edges of
spent excipular shells, ascomatal complexes sometimes forming rings or stars; form angular, variably broadly or narrowly ellipsoid or irregularly
lobed, strongly constricted basally, 0.18–0.54 ×
0.09–0.18 mm, L/W ratio 2.43±0.72; disc deeply
concave, black, matte, when dry almost completely
concealed by margins, these thick, black, lexuose,
prominent; exciple of laterally interwoven hyphae,
appearing paraplectenchymatous in vertical section, overtopping hymenium surface in section,
often strongly thickened, 15–70(–90) µm wide;
excipular hyphae pigmented dark brown externally, lacking birefringence; hypothecium 50–150
µm deep, hyaline; hymenium 50–80 µm deep, hyaline, ±hemiamyloid (ILugols+ blue-green à rust red,
with localized persistent blue patches), consisting
of clavate asci 56–85 × 12–16 µm embedded in
a matrix of slender, branched and anastomosing
paraphyses 1–2 µm wide at midpoint, distally
scarcely thickened, to 3 µm in the apical cell, not
or weakly pigmented; ascospores 8/ascus, long-ellipsoid to almost fusiform, (12–)15.9–18.2(–23) ×
(4.5–)5.7–6.4(–8.7) µm (L/W ratio 2.43±0.72) (n =
33). Conidiomata seen once, partially immersed,
globose, 85–110 µm diam, the studied conidiomata
empty; conidia not seen. Sterile hyphae forming
an extensive, well developed lichenized thallus,
consisting of round, isidioid, white granules 0.05–
0.12 mm diam, these contained in paraplectenchymatous fungal sheaths, the cells unpigmented;
granules occasionally nearly absent and conined
to sheltered cracks in the wood. Associated algae
Trebouxia, 6.5–13 µm diam.
maCroeCology: temperate forests and on driftwood in salt marshes in the Atlantic coastal plain
of eastern North America, to montane elevations in
the Appalachians.
Xylographa disseminata is unique in the genus
for its coarse isidioid thallus (Fig. 6A, B), which
is sometimes conined to cracks in the wood, the
presence of fatty acids in the thallus, and its long,
nearly fusiform ascospores (Fig. 6F). It is one of
only a few nemoral Xylographa species, and is
known in eastern North America from Nova Scotia
to North Carolina.
additional speCimens examined: Canada: New Brunswick, S. Clayden 19609 (NBM); Charlotte Co., St.
James Parish, M. Shchepanek s.n. (CANL-109941);
Nova Scotia, Yarmouth Co., East Barclay Brook, 1999,
T. Ahti 57155a (H); U.S.A.: Maine, Bangor, C. Pringle
502 (FH); North Carolina, Haywood Co., southern Appalachians, Great Smoky Mountains National Park, Purchase, 2006, T. Tønsberg 37619 (BG); Vermont, Charlotte, C. Pringle 395 (FH).
Xylographa erratica T. Sprib., sp.
nov. (Fig. 7) Mycobank No.: MB
805257.
Similar to and chemically concordant with X. hians, but ascomata developing one at a time in one
direction, never developing hyaline laps, lacking
gray pigments, and ascospores 5.3–6 µm wide.
Type: Russia: Khabarovskiy Krai, Bureinskiy Zapovednik, upper reach of the Pravaya Bureya River, 25 km
SE of Soiysk, Tsarskaya Dorogа, patrol cabin ‘Novaya
Medvezhka’, 52°07.918’N, 134°17.436’E, in stream
below cabin and on the slope opposite, lignicolous on
logs in Larix gmelinii forest near stream, 880 m, 08 Aug
2009, T. Spribille 32039 & L. Yakovchenko (H, holotype; CANL, GZU, UBC, isotypes).
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
38
T. Spribille et al.
Fig. 7. Xylographa erratica T. Sprib. A-D. Habit and arrangement of ascomata, A and C dry, B and D moistened; E, section through hymenium, in LCB; F, detail of paraphyses, in LCB; G, ascus with immature ascospores, in ILugols without
pretreatment with KOH. A-B: holotype (DNA voucher 820); C-F, Canada, British Columbia, Björk 14550 (UBC, DNA
voucher 2423). Scale bars: A, B, 0.5 mm; C, D, 1 mm; E, 20 µm; F, G, 10 µm.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
Etymology: Named for the ascomata, the tips of which
point erratically in different directions, instead of being
aligned with the grain of the wood.
Ascomata with lateral growth of trunciseda-type,
with ascomata regenerating in a single direction
from the ends of spent excipular shells, irregularly
narrowly to broadly ellipsoid, eccentric, with tips
pointing away from main axis of disc, 0.21–0.69
× 0.075–0.3 mm, L/W ratio 2.84±1.18; disc exposed to hidden or exposed only when moist, lat
to concave, brown, matte, with thick to thin, pale
to dark brown margin; exciple appearing paraplectenchymatous in vertical section, ±lush with the
hymenium surface in section, 11–33 µm wide laterally; excipular hyphae pigmented brown externally, internally hyaline with birefringent cell walls
(POL+); hypothecium 70–130 µm deep, hyaline;
hymenium 60–80 µm deep, hyaline or pale hazy
brown, hemiamyloid (ILugols+ blue-green à rust
red), consisting of asci 55–75 × (6–)12–15 µm,
embedded in a matrix of slender, sparsely branched
paraphyses 1–1.5(–2.0) µm at midpoint, distally
scarcely thickened, with brown wall pigments;
ascospores 8/ascus, ellipsoid, (9–)11.0–12.2(–15)
× (4–)5.3–6.0(–7.5) µm (L/W ratio 2.09±0.35)
(n = 31). Conidiomata adjacent to ascomata but
segregated, ca. ½ immersed, globose, 55–150 µm
diam, wall hyphae with internal brown pigments;
conidiophores bearing terminal conidia, ca. 7.5 ×
2 µm; conidia long-iliform, curved, 15–20 × ca.
0.5 µm. Sterile hyphae permeating wood, becoming lichenized with endosubstratal plugs of algae to
300–600 × 100 µm, becoming conluent, displacing wood ibres when wet and swelling, and given
the thallus an “unkempt” appearance; goniocysts
not observed. Associated algae chlorococcoid,
9–20 µm diam.
Chemistry: stictic acid (major), rarely trace, norstictic acid trace or absent.
substrate affinity: on conifer wood.
maCroeCology: in humid boreal conifer forests
and along coastal beaches, to 880 m elev., currently
39
known from scattered occurrences in northern Europe, NE Asia and western North America between
51° and 60°N latitude.
Xylographa erratica is similar to X. opegraphella
and X. hians and can easily be confused with both.
Like X. opegraphella, it can grow on coastal driftwood in the intertidal zone and develop ascomata
closely resembling those of X. opegraphella. Unlike that species, however, it also occurs both on
coastal driftwood and deep inland in relatively dry
forest habitats, especially in the continental boreal forests of the Russian Far East, where it can
be abundant. It is characterized by the following
combination of characters: small, football-shaped
ascomata that tend to occur singly and have a single direction of growth; brown pigmentation without any hint of gray; the ascospores 5–6 µm wide;
the presence of stictic acid in the thallus; the habit
of the thallus to develop areoles just below the
irst layer of wood ibre, eventually swelling and
distending the ibre, creating a cracked, unkempt
appearance; and inally the presence of a visible
hypothallus. The habit of developing below and
eventually distending the wood ibre is similar to
X. vermicularis, but that species can be separated
from X. erratica by its larger ascospores, lack of
hymenial pigments and the constant presence of
confriesiic acid (in addition to stictic acid; see Table 3, p. 43 for a trait-by-trait comparison).
Three specimens of X. erratica from the intertidal
zone were found to develop a hypothallus or thalline ring with a KOH+ purplish substance, possibly
an anthraquinone, leaving a pink stain on the wood
at the edges of the thallus.The identity of at least
one of these (isolate P99) as X. erratica has been
conirmed through DNA. The ascomatal discs of
X. erratica may remain open when dry or collapse,
recalling the habit of X. opegraphella, and it may
be necessary to moisten specimens to gain a full
impression of their habit (Fig. 7B, D).
In Europe, X. erratica has been confused with X.
trunciseda; Brodo (1992) cites a specimen from
Vězda’s Lichenes Selecti Exsiccati as being “abSymb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
40
T. Spribille et al.
errant” X. trunciseda. Xylographa erratica can be
separated from X. trunciseda by the presence of
stictic acid, ascomatal tips pointing in apparently
random directions (as opposed to being aligned
with the wood grain as in X. trunciseda), and the
thallus, which is strongly scurfy from developing
robust areoles below the wood surface and lifting it
off (as opposed to the ilmy, smooth thallus surface
and subsuricial goniocysts in X. trunciseda).
exsiCCate: Sweden: Värmland, Vězda, Lich. Selecti Exs.
2100 (BM!, GZU!, H!, M!, as X. trunciseda).
additional speCimens examined: Canada: British Columbia, Coast Ranges, Homathko Estuary South, 15 Jun
2007, C.R. Björk 14550 (UBC); Finland: Regio aboensis, Lokala[hti], 21 Jul 1882, H. Hollmén & V. Sederholm (H, KW); Rovaniemi, 8 Jun [19]21, V. Räsänen
s.n. (H); U.S.A.: Alaska, Kodiak Island, T. Tønsberg
15582 (BG: form with anthraquinones); Glacier Bay National Park, Icy Straits, Fern Harbor, T. Tønsberg 41775,
41775a (BG: form with anthraquinones).
Xylographa hians Tuck. (Fig. 8)
Synopsis of North American Lichens 2: 113 (1888). Type:
[U.S.A.:] Washington Terr[itor]y, W. N. Suksdorf (FH00370115!, lectotype, designated here; FH-00370116,
H-NYL p.m. 6771!, UPS, US [image!], isolectotypes).
TLC (FH specimens): stictic acid (major), norstictic acid
(trace).
= Xylographa micrographa G. Merr., Ottawa Naturalist
27: 121 (1913). Type: [Canada: British Columbia], Surrey, J. Macoun (FH-00370117, holotype!). TLC: stictic
acid (major), norstictic acid (trace).
Ascomata with lateral growth of trunciseda-type,
regenerating from the edges of spent excipular
shells in multiple directions, to form chains or stars,
broadly ellipsoid, 0.21–0.45(–0.6) × 0.09–0.27
mm, L/W ratio 1.84±0.89; disc widely exposed,
lat to concave, brown to ochre gray, matte, with
thin brown to gray or pale cream, lexuose margin,
often with overhanging chartaceous “laps”, occasionally margin inconspicuous; exciple of laterally
interwoven hyphae, appearing paraplectenchymatous in vertical section, overtopping the hymenium
surface in section, 15–30(–40) µm wide; excipular
hyphae pigmented brown and/or gray externally,
internally or wholly with birefringent fungal cell
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
walls (POL+); hypothecium (40–) 60–150 µm
deep, hyaline; hymenium easily separating from
exciple in gentle water squash, 50–130 µm deep,
hyaline, hemiamyloid (ILugols+ blue-green à rust
red), consisting of clavate asci 55–110 × 12–15
µm embedded in a matrix of slender, sparsely
branched, gangly paraphyses 1.2–2 µm wide at
midpoint, not or scarcely distally thickened, with
brown and sometimes also gray wall pigments; ascospores 8/ascus, ellipsoid, (10.0–)12.1–13.5(–17)
× (5.2–)6.2–7.4(–9) µm (L/W ratio 1.84±0.89) (n
= 64). Conidiomata common, dark gray or black,
segregated from ascomata and often ringing “thallus” margins, ca. ½ immersed, globose, 60–105
µm diam, with wall of laterally interwoven hyphae
ca. 10 µm thick, appearing paraplectenchymatous
in section; hyphae with internal gray and some
brown wall pigments; conidia long-iliform, falcate, 11–18 × 0.3–0.5 µm. Sterile hyphae at least
sometimes amyloid, ILugols+ blue in patches below
ascoma, permeating wood, becoming lichenized
with endosubstratal plugs of algae up to 0.7 mm
below the wood surface, plugs 160–370 × 50–90
µm, goniocysts not observed. Associated algae
chlorococcoid, 7–17 µm diam.
Chemistry: stictic acid (major), rarely (Macoun
209, FH) norstictic acid (major) and stictic acid
(submajor).
substrate affinity: on wood of conifers and Quercus garryana.
maCroeCology: in temperate to boreal conifer forests of North America, from sea level to over 500 m.
Xylographa hians is a widespread species distributed on wood in the coastal temperate and boreal
rainforest of the northwest North American coast.
When well developed, X. hians can be distinguished from all other species of Xylographa by
the combination of short ascomata, long, wide ascospores and abundant gray pigments, the latter especially in pycnidia and the excipula of new ascomatal initials. However, the species as treated here
encompasses some confounding variability (Fig.
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
41
Fig. 8. Xylographa hians Tuck. A-D. Habit and arrangement of ascomata; E, habit of several individuals showing lineup
of conidiomata at border between thalli (arrows); F, ascomata, in water. A, lectotype (FH, photo E. Timdal); B, Canada,
British Columbia, Spribille s.n., 11 Oct 2011 (GZU, DNA voucher 818); C, U.S.A., Alaska, Spribille s.n. (GZU, DNA
voucher 1052); D, F, Spribille 8887 (GZU); E, Spribille 36071-B (GZU, DNA voucher 1053). Scale bars: A–C, 0.5 mm;
D, 1 mm; E, 2 mm; F, 0.1 mm.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
42
T. Spribille et al.
8A-D). In northern coastal regions (Haida Gwaii to
the Aleutians) as well as at higher elevations farther
south, the ascomata are easily recognizable by the
gray pigments and the presence of a chartaceous
excipular lap over the discs of many ascomata. In
the southern part of its range, X. hians occurs on
Quercus garryana and Pseudotsuga wood in thermophilous lowland forests; ascomata in these areas
may be compound and a few lack gray pigments.
These forms include the type of X. micrographa
G. Merr. from lower mainland British Columbia
(Merrill 1913). These southern forms can be dificult to separate from X. erratica, but they nearly
always proliferate in two to more directions from
the margins of a dead, central ascoma (as opposed
to X. erratica, in which they are single and grow in
one direction), and in nearly all specimens some
gray pigment can be found (never present in X. erratica). Diagnostic characters of these species and
X. opegraphella are compared in Table 3. Xylographa hians is one of the few species to regularly
produce abundant conidiomata on the same thallus
as the teleomorph, albeit segregated. In X. hians
they are produced at the outer edge of the thallus
and are rich in gray pigment, forming concentric
rings of black dots at some distance from the centre
of the thallus (Fig. 8E).
We have seen two specimens that closely resemble
Xylographa hians from southern Chile which possess grayish ascomatal pigments and stictic acid.
However we have not been able to verify beyond
doubt that they can be assigned here barring DNA
analysis. Further collecting in the Nothofagus forests of extreme southern Chile may prove this to be
another bipolar species.
exsiCCates: Canada: British Columbia, Brodo, Lich.
Can. Exs. 149 (BG!, BM!, as X. parallela); U.S.A.: California, California Fungi 850 (F!, H!, as X. parallela).
additional speCimens examined (X. hians): Canada:
British Columbia, Vancouver Island, Sidney, 1913, J.
Macoun 209 (FH); Queen Charlotte Islands, Moresby
Island, Tasu, 1980, T. Ahti 38956 (CANL); Prince Rupert area, N shore of Skeena River, 02 Sept 1991, T.
Goward 91-1583 & H. Knight (UBC); U.S.A.: Alaska,
Mitkof Island, 2011, T. Tønsberg 41139 (BG); Aleutian
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
Islands, Unimak Island, 27 Aug 2011, T. Ahti & S.S.
Talbot 70438 (H); Oregon, Polk Co., Rickreall Ridge,
11 Mar 1992, B. McCune 19503 (UBC); Washington,
Klickitat Co., near Husum, 21 Jun 1894, W.N. Suksdorf
403 (WSU); Whatcom Co., Mt. Baker[-Snoqualmie] National Forest, Sulfur Creek Lava Flow, 460–550 m, 29
Mar 1992, T. Ahti 51006 & F. Rhoades (H).
additional speCimens examined (X. aff. hians): Chile:
Region X, Parque Nacional Puyehue, Antillanca,
40°46’S, 72°12”W, 1100-1500 m, 2 Dec 1986, B.J.
Coppins, D.J. Galloway, G. Guzmán & P.W. James
4573 (BM); Prov. Antártica Chilena, Comuna Cabo de
Hornos, Parque Nacional Alberto de Agostini, N shore
of Isla Gordon, extreme SW end of Bahía Romanche,
54°58’07”S, 69°32’13”W, coastal Nothofagus betuloides
forest with small waterfalls and landslide, 31 Jan 2012,
W.R. Buck 59086 (NY).
Xylographa isidiosa (Elix) Bendiksby
& Timdal (Fig. 9).
Taxon 62:952 (2013). Hypocenomyce isidiosa Elix,
Mycotaxon 94: 219 (2005). – Type: Australia: Western
Australia, Avon district, Charles Gardner Flora Reserve,
central track, 20 km SW of Tammin along old York
Road, 31°47’24”S, 117°28’07”E, alt. 305 m, on dead,
charred wood in Eucalyptus woodland with Casuarina
and Acacia in shallow gully, 22 April 2004, Elix 31849
(PERTH, holotype, not seen; CANB, isotype, seen by
Bendiksby & Timdal 2013).
Ascomata and Conidiomata not seen. Sterile
hyphae lichenized, associated with algal plugs developing endosubstratally in the wood ibre, internally prosoplectenchymatous and mixed with algae, externally all areas of thallus covered in a thin
to thick layer of goniocysts, these grouping into
plates or areoles 450–650 µm; goniocysts consisting of tightly packed algae surrounded by brown,
angular, paraplectenchymatous fungal hyphae, in total 25–50 µm diam, easily dislodged and
free in water squash preparations, macroscopically
pigmented dark brown. Associated algae chlorococcoid, 7–11 µm diam.
Chemistry: confriesiic and friesiic acid (Elix 2005).
substrate affinity: on charred wood.
Table 3. Diagnostic characters in esorediate lichenized species with short ascomata
X. erratica
X. hians
X. lagoi
X. opegraphella
X. trunciseda
X. vermicularis
two to multiple, regenerating
from both ends
of dead ascomata
mostly regenerating from one
end and thus
unidirectional
two to multiple,
regenerating from
both ends of dead
ascomata
regeneration not
observed
two to multiple,
regenerating from
both ends of dead
ascomata
two, regenerating
from ends
two, regenerating
from ends
Ascoma length/
width ratio
(mean±SD)
2.66±0.86
2.43±0.72
2.84±1.18
1.84±0.89
-
2.56 ±1.04
2.22±0.48
2.19±0.57
Birefringence in
exciple (POL+)
inner exciple
lacking
inner exciple
inner exciple to
whole exciple
-
inner exciple
inner exciple
inner exciple to
whole exciple
Hymenial pigments
brown and gray
±unpigmented
brown
brown, usually also
gray, abundant in
young portions of
ascomata
brown and gray
brown and sometimes gray
pale brown
±unpigmented
Hymenial amyloidity
hemiamyloid
hemiamyloid
hemiamyloid
hemiamyloid
-
hemiamyloid or
euamyloid
hemiamyloid
hemiamyloid or
euamyloid
paraphysis terminal cells
expanded to
5 µm
expanded to
3 µm
scarcely expanded
scarcely expanded
expanded to 7 µm
expanded to 5 µm
expanded to 3.5
µm
not expanded, unpigmented
Mean ascospore
length (µm)
11.6–13.2
15.9–18.2
11.0–12.2
12.1–13.5
9.5
9.4–11.3
10.1–11.3
12.2–14.1
Mean ascospore
width (µm)
5.6–6.8
5.7–6.4
5.3–6.0
6.2–7.4
6
3.4–3.9
5.2–6.1
6.8–8.4
Ascospore L/W
ratio (mean±SD)
2.04±0.23
2.43±0.72
2.09±0.35
1.84±0.89
1.18−2.03
2.92±1.04
2.22±0.48
1.77±0.2
Thallus
sparse, immersed algal plugs
immersed algal
plugs, breaking
out into abundant granules
immersed algal
plugs, sometimes
developing areoles to 0.4 mm
and distending
wood ibres
immersed algal
plugs
sparse, immersed
algal plugs
variable, immersed
algal plugs to
robust surface
thallus
immersed goniocysts
immersed algal
plugs, sometimes
developing endoxylic
areoles and distending wood ibres
Goniocysts
present
present (granules)
absent
absent
present
absent
present, immersed,
very rarely suricial
occasionally produced in “soralia”
Major substances
confriesiic acid
fatty acids (major), confriesiic
acid
stictic (norstictic)
stictic (norstictic)
thamnolic acid
norstictic and/or
stictic acids
confriesiic acid
confriesiic and stictic
acids
Distribution
Paciic North
America
Eastern North
America
Boreal, North
America, Europe, Asia
Paciic North
America
Spain
Northern maritime
coasts
Boreal-montane,
North America,
Europe, Asia
Paciic Rim of Asia,
North and South
America
43
X. disseminata
two, regenerating from ends
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
X. bjoerkii
Ascomata regeneration
44
T. Spribille et al.
Fig. 9. Xylographa isidiosa (Elix) Bendiksby & Timdal A, B, habit; C, D, goniocysts in water viewed with light microscope; E, F, goniocysts viewed in SEM. All photos from Australia, Elix 39837 (O). Scale bars: A, 1 mm; B, 0.5 mm;
C, E, 50 µm; D, 10 µm; F, 20 µm.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
maCroeCology: known only from Western Australia.
This species, described by Elix (2005), is only
known without ascomata, and was recently transferred to Xylographa based on molecular data
by Bendiksby & Timdal (2013). Its thallus form
and goniocysts (Fig. 9) are similar to those of the
Northern Hemisphere species X. septentrionalis
but are more continuous and thicker. It strongly resembles a Placynthiella (e.g., P. icmalea) in habit
and could easily be overlooked as such.
speCimen examined: Australia: Western Australia, Caernarvon Hills, Dryandra Woodland, 17 km NW of Narrogin, 32°48’21”S, 117°03’21”E, 325 m, 6 Apr 2006, J.A.
Elix 39837 (O).
Xylographa lagoi T. Sprib. & PérezOrtega, sp. nov. (Fig. 10) Mycobank
No.: MB 805258.
Species with black ascomatal disc and white, internally unpigmented excipulum and thick thallus,
with thamnolic acid as the main secondary metabolite.
Type: Spain: Asturias, Cangas del Narcea, Reserva de
la Biosfera de Muniellos, Muniellos Mount, Quercus
petraea forest along Fuenculebrera trail, 43°02’02”N,
06°41’59”W, on fallen, decorticated branches of Quercus petraea, 1156 m, 04 May 2009, S. Pérez-Ortega
1975, T. Spribille & V. Wagner (MAF, holotype; GZU,
isotype); same locality, same day, T. Spribille 30267 (H,
UPS, topotypes).
Etymology: The new taxon is named in memory of Manuel Lago ‘Chiquito’, a ranger for the forest service in the
Muniellos Nature Reserve, who was murdered by poachers in 1980 while working in the Reserve.
Ascomata frequent, elongated, up to 0.3 mm wide,
forming star-like clusters up to 1.2 mm in diam;
disc lat to slightly concave, dark brown; exciple
white, thin, up to 50 µm wide, inner exciple more or
less thick, up to 90 µm, outer part tinged by brownish pigment, inner part paraplectenchym-atous and
composed of thin-walled hyphae; hypothecium
hyaline; hymenium hyaline, up to 100 µm high,
with brown and gray pigments above, becoming
45
dark brown in KOH asci subcylindrical to clavate,
55−80 × 12−16 µm (n = 10), 8-spored, tholus distinct, pale blue in ILugols, paraphyses septate, more
or less straight, simple or sparely branched, often
anastomosed, 2–3 µm thick, upper cells elongated
and in some paraphyses usually much wider, up to
7 µm, with a greenish brown pigment becoming
dark brown in KOH; ascospores simple, hyaline,
ellipsoid to ovoid, irregularly biseriate, thickwalled (up to 1.5 µm thick), (7.5−) 9.5±0.9 (−11.5)
× (5.5−) 6±0.8 (−7.5) µm (ratio 1.18−2.03) (n =
35). Conidiomata not observed. Sterile hyphae
forming a crustose, lichenized thallus, mostly episubstratal but endosubstratal in areolate areas or
areas lacking goniocysts; areoles convex, usually
developing convex soralia; soralia white, rounded
and convex, conluent, usually covering several
mm2 of the thallus; goniocysts (soredia) rounded,
rather coarse, more or less corticate, up to 90 µm in
diam, consoredia not observed. Algal cells chlorococcoid, 10–14 µm in diam, forming plugs within
the fungal thallus.
Chemistry: thamnolic acid.
Xylographa lagoi was collected on ca. 30 cm diam.
fallen, decorticated branches of Quercus petraea.
It is only known from the type locality. The Muniellos Preserve is one of the best studied regions
of northern Spain for its lichen lora (Barreno &
Pérez-Ortega 2003), and despite this the species
was not detected prior to 2009. Xylographa lagoi
is a striking and instantly recognizable crustose lichen (Fig. 10A, B) and we consider it likely that
it would have been reported before if it had been
collected, and thus that our single collection represents bona ide rarity. The species is recommended
for tracking by the IUCN on account of extreme
rarity and paucity of dead wood in managed forests on the Iberian Peninsula. Further surveys are
needed.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
46
T. Spribille et al.
Fig. 10. Xylographa lagoi T. Sprib. & Pérez-Ortega A, B, habit; C, section through ascoma (in LCB); D, exciple, in LCB; E, F, paraphyses; G, H, asci with immature ascospores, in ILugols without preteatment with KOH;
I, J, K, ascospores. All photos from holotype (DNA voucher 162). Scale bars: A, 2mm; B, 0.5 mm; C, 50 µm;
D, 10 µm; E–H, 5 µm; D, 10 µm; I–K, 2.5 µm.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
47
Fig. 11. Xylographa opegraphella Nyl. Habit and arrangement of ascomata. All specimens except A (the type) veriied
to be conspeciic based on ITS. A, isolectotype (H); B, Tønsberg 39916 (BG); C, Norway, Timdal 12068 (O); D, Canada,
Québec, Spribille s.n. (GZU, DNA voucher 1069); E, U.S.A., Alaska, Spribille 24979 (KLGO); F, Canada, New Brunswick, Spribille s.n. (GZU, DNA voucher 1068). Scale bars: A–F, 0.5 mm.
Xylographa opegraphella Nyl. (Fig.
11–12)
in Rothrock, Proc. U.S. National Museum 7(1): 8 (1884).
Type: [U.S.A.:] Alaska, at Cooks Inlet, 1880, Dr. T.H.
Bean (F-119631, lectotype, designated here; H-NYL
4721, isolectotype!). TLC (specimen from F): norstictic acid (major), stictic acid (submajor). An additional
note on the type specimen in F in an unknown handwriting says ‘From the “spit”, Coal Point, Chugachik Bay,
Cook’s Inlet. July 1, 1880. Bean.’ The H-NYL specimen
says “Fret. Behring, Alaska at Cooks Inlet, Dr. Bean, 1/
vii/1880”, Nylander having erroneously believed Cook
Inlet to be in the Bering Straits.
= Opegrapha stictica Tuck. & Fr. in Tuck., Lich. Amer.
Sept. Exs. no. 97 (1854) (nom. nud. Art. 38); non Opegrapha stictica (Durieu & Mont.) Nyl., Mém. Soc. Sci.
Nat. Cherbourg 2: 335 (1854).
= Xylographa arctica Vain., Ark. Bot. 8(4):154 (1909),
nomen illeg., non Xylographa arctica Fuckel (see “excluded taxa”). = Xylographa sibirica Zahlbr., Cat.
Lich. Univ. 2: 155 (1922) as nom. nov. Type: [Russia:
Magadanskaya Oblast’,] Sibiria sept., Pagum Pitlekai,
ad lignum, E. Almquist (TUR-V 29512, lectotype, designated here). TLC (performed by I. Brodo, 3/1993): stictic acid, trace of norstictic, fatty acid A7, B6, C7. This
typiication establishes the var. arctica and by extension
the var. sibirica of Zahlbruckner’s nomen novum. When
Vainio (1909) described Xylographa arctica, he distinguished only two varieties, var. incrustans and var. subhians, encompassing the entire variation in the species.
Original material labeled var. incrustans (and already annotated in herb. by I.M. Brodo as “var. arctica”, 1993, referring to the Herb. Vainio no. 29095 = TUR-V 29512!)
is here designated as the lectotype of var. arctica, and by
extension also X. sibirica var. sibirica.
= Xylographa arctica var. incrustans Vain., Ark. Bot.
8(4): 154 (1909), nomen illeg. Xylographa sibirica var.
incrustans (Vain.) Zahlbr., Cat. Lich. Univ. 2: 155 (1922
[1924]), nom. illeg. See comment under X. arctica.
= Xylographa arctica var. subhians Vain., Ark. Bot. 8(4):
154 (1909). Xylographa sibirica Zahlbr. var. subhians
(Vain.) Zahlbr., Cat. Lich. Univ. 2: 155 (1922 [1924]).
Type: [Russia: Magadanskaya Oblast’,] Sibiria sept.,
Peninsula Jinretlen, ad lignum [E. Almquist] (TUR-V
29511, lectotype, designated here; material is also present in S but was not studied). TLC: (performed by I. Brodo, 3/1993): trace of stictic acid, fatty acid A7, B6, C7.
= Xylographa borealis Rehm, Hedwigia 39: 321 (1900).
Type: Canada, Newfoundland, Shoal Point, 1896, A. C.
Waghorne 205 (S-F5584, holotype, image!)
Ascomata with lateral growth of trunciseda type;
irst generation ascomata broadly to narrowly elSymb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
48
T. Spribille et al.
Fig. 12. Xylographa opegraphella Nyl. Anatomy of fertile and sterile forms. A, longitudinal section through sterile
ascoma (in water with polarizing ilter); B, latitudinal vertical section through ascoma, showing abortive asci and free
paraphyses (in LCB); C, section through fertile ascoma with “normal” hymenium, in water; D, sterile hyphae between
xylem cell walls showing lichenized and non-lichenized hyphae, in LCB; E, section through fertile ascoma, showing
paraphyses and immature asci, in ILugols after pretreatment with KOH; F, conidioma vertical view showing patch of gray
pigment around ostiole, in water. A, B, D: Canada, Québec, Spribille s.n. (GZU, DNA voucher 1069); C, Canada, New
Brunswick, Lendemer 27781 (M); E, Norway, Timdal 12068 (O); F, Iceland, Orange 17027 (M). Scale bars: A, C, F,
20 µm; B, D, E, 10 µm.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
lipsoid or linear, 0.21–0.48 ×0.06–0.21 mm, L/W
ratio 2.56 ±1.04, dark brown to castaneous brown,
sometimes pale translucent, later generation ascomata regenerating at both ends of necrotic margin
and resembling those of the irst generation, growing linearly in two directions from mother ascoma
or in multiple directions, necrotic shells in old individuals sometimes building up to form encrusted
waxy cushions over 200 µm or more thick; exciple
of laterally interwoven hyphae, apparently paraplectenchymatous in vertical section, usually overtopping the hymenium surface (forming “laps”),
14–32 µm wide at widest point, excipular hyphae
pigmented brown externally, internally with a distinct layer of unpigmented, birefringent (POL+)
but non-crystalliferous hyphae between outer exciple and hymenium; hypothecium hyaline to hazy
reddish brown, 30–110(–150) µm deep in section;
ascomata with two paths of development: 1) fertile, with exposed dark-brown disc; hymenium
40–70(–90) µm deep, consisting of a matrix of asci
45–72 × 8–11 µm, rooted deep in a tangle of ascogenous hyphae, and simple or sparing branches paraphyses 1.5–2.5 µm at midpoint, thickened to 4–5
µm apically, thin to rather stout, straight to distinctly moniliform, curving at their tips and sprawling
over surface of ascoma; hymenium hemiamyloid
or euamyloid, ILugols+ blue-green turning rust red or
ILugols+ royal blue; hymenium unpigmented or hazy
yellowish brown, darkening to dark brown, the paraphysis walls in upper 1/5 infused with brown pigment, usually with additional gray pigment; ascospores present, hyaline, 8/ascus, appearing healthy
with intact walls and internal features, narrowly
ellipsoid, (9.0–)9.4–11.3(–13.5) × (2.8–)3.4–3.9(–
5.0) µm (L/W ratio 2.92±1.04) (n = 70), rarely
with distinct plasma bridges resembling septa; 2)
sterile, hemiangiocarpic ascomata prematurely
shedding the excipular covering along suture lines
(easly separating in section in water), resultant ascomata appearing “hollowed out”, in section with
scattered longer paraphyses and abundant, abortive
asci to ca. 30 µm long; ascospores rarely developed. Conidiomata rare, adjacent to ascomata but
segregated, ca. 2/3 immersed, globular, with wall
of interwoven hyphae appearing paraplectenchy-
49
matous in section, hyphae with internal brown wall
pigments, additional gray pigment formed around
ostiole; conidia iliform, curved, 9–12 × ca. 0.7–
1.0 µm. Sterile hyphae running through interior
of necrotic wood grains, contacting concentrated
endoxylic plugs of algae (Trebouxia sp.), 100–200
× 60–100 µm; suricial thallus occasionally well
developed (as in type), forming convex, creamcoloured areolae 0.12–0.48 × 0.09–0.21 mm; goniocysts not observed.
Chemistry: norstictic and stictic acids, alternating
as major and submajor substances, rarely norstictic
or stictic acid alone; confriesiic acid rarely present
(e.g. Gowan 2062, CANL; Kershaw s.n., CANL).
substrate affinity: on driftwood affected by ocean
saltspray, at least during periodic storms, rare in
freshwater habitats.
maCroeCology: in the upper intertidal zones of
coastlines at latitudes from about 35°N to 70°N, in
the Atlantic, Paciic and Arctic Oceans.
Xylographa opegraphella is the most pronouncedly maritime species of the genus, with DNA-veriied occurrences on Paciic and Atlantic coasts as
well as the Arctic Ocean. It has been considered
a fairly straightforward species but its identiication may be complicated by the presence of X. erratica, which can occur in the same habitats and is
essentially a cryptic species within the X. opegraphella complex (see below). Inland records of X.
opegraphella are rare, and usually associated with
shorelines or lowing water (e.g. Pringle 364, FH).
Not all major shoreline sites are associated with
saltwater: locations are also known from Lake Superior, e.g. in the Apostle Islands (Wetmore 60928,
CANL). Xylographa opegraphella is a variable
species. The ascomata range from closed to open
and short to elongate, and ITS sequence data have
conirmed they are conspeciic. The typical form
(Fig. 11A, the type specimen, also Fig. 11B) is easy
to identify, but forms exist with straight ascomata
that resemble short forms of X. parallela (e.g. Brodo 29630, F, also in part Fig. 11D). It is dificult to
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
50
T. Spribille et al.
distinguish from X. erratica, which also occurs on
maritime driftwood, even side-by-side with X. opegraphella. The two are most easily separated by
the prominent brown margins in X. opegraphella
(often translucent in sterile specimens), its habit of
forming multidirectional ascomatal growth, and its
short, narrow ascospores rarely >5 µm wide (see
Table 3, p. 43). Xylographa erratica by contrast
has a scarcely differentiated exciple that does not
form conspicuous margins, its ascomata are almost always simple and grow in a single direction,
and its ascospores are longer and wider (Table 3).
While X. opegraphella is known mostly from maritime driftwood, X. erratica also occurs far inland
in upland forests. The thallus of X. opegraphella
can also be extremely polymorphic, ranging from
suricial and areolate (Fig. 11A, B) to completely
immersed (Fig. 11D). Vainio (1909), in describing Xylographa arctica Vain. from the extreme
eastern tip of Russia, accorded these status as var.
incrustans (with a thick thallus; = var. arctica)
and var. subhians (with immersed thallus), noting
the similarity of the latter to Willey’s Xylographa
hians (Tuckerman 1888). To add to the morphological complexity of this species, Xylographa
opegraphella has a propensity to produce sterile,
abortive ascomata (Fig. 12A, B). Sterile forms are
supericially similar to typical X. opegraphella
but instead of developing a gelatinized hymenium
they develop a free matrix of simple paraphyses
and aborted asci. The paraphysis-ascus matrix is
covered by an extended excipular cap that easily erodes and/or separates from the matrix under
light pressure in H2O (Fig. 12A). Ascoma genesis
happens in that a single ascoma is formed initially,
with a paraphysis-ascus matrix developing under
an excipular mantle as in immature hemiangiocarpic ascomata. In contrast to the normal development of such ascomata, however, the excipular
mantle is fragile and can easily be detached with
light pressure under a cover slip, exposing the free
paraphyses and abortive asci. These in turn can detach and may serve as dispersal propagules. The
resultant, empty ascoma regenerates from the most
recent growth tips, developing a new ascoma at
each end, in which this process is repeated.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
exsiCCates: Canada: New Brunswick, Lendemer, Lich.
Eastern North America Exs. 437 (M!); Québec, Macoun,
Can. Lich. 72 (BM!, mixed with X. parallela); ibid.,
Brodo, Lich. Can. Exs. 225 (ALA!, GZU!); Sweden:
Västerbotten, Santesson, Lich. Selecti Exs. Upsal. 250
(GZU!, M!); Öland, Vězda, Lich. Selecti Exs. 180 (G!,
M!, as X. trunciseda).
additional speCimens examined: Canada: British Columbia, Port Edwards, 2006, T. Spribille 22693 (GZU);
New Brunswick, Fundy National Park, S. Gowan 2062
(CANL); Nunavut, East Pen Island area, K.A. Kershaw
s.n. (CANL-98552); Finland: Alandia, Eckerö, Storby,
vanha tukki rannalla [=old log on shore], 12 Jul 1935,
L.E. Kari 12765 (F); Iceland: Norður-Þingeyjarssla,
near Þórshöfn, Lambanes, 16 June 2007, A. Orange
17027 (M); Norway: Finnmark, Båtsfjord, W of Hamningberg, S of Skjåvika, 25 Jun 2010, T. Tønsberg 39916
(BG); Vadsø, Krampenes, alt. 5 m, 25 Jun 2011, E. Timdal 12068 (O); Russia: Sakhalinskaya Oblast’, Kuril’skie
O[stro]va, Ostrov Shikotan [= Kurile Islands, Shikotan
Island], 11 Jul 1965, O. B. Blum s.n. (KW); Ostrov Kunashir [= Kunashir Island], 15 Aug 1965, O. B. Blum s.n.
(KW); U.S.A.: Alaska, [Chukchi Sea,] Ogotoruk Creek
area, A.W. Johnson et al. 329 (ALA); Amchitka Island,
L.W. Sowl s.n. (CANL); Glacier Bay National Park,
Muir Point, A. Fryday 10251 (MSC); Massachusetts,
New Bedford, 1876, H. Willey (G); Vermont, no locality,
C. Pringle 364 (FH); Wisconsin, Ashland Co., Apostle
Islands National Lakeshore, Outer Island at southern tip
on sand spit, C. Wetmore 60928 (CANL).
Xylographa pallens (Nyl.) Harm.
(Fig. 13–14).
Bull. Soc. Sci. Nancy, Ser. II 16(34): 47 (1900). Xylographa parallela var. pallens Nyl., Actes Soc. linn. Bordeaux 21: 393 (1857 [“1856”]). Type: [France:] In Vogesis, Dr. Mougeot (H-NYL 4684, lectotype, designated
here). TLC: stictic acid.
= Xylographa rubescens var. degelii Räsänen in Ann.
Bot. Soc. Zool.-Bot. Fenn. Vanamo 12(1): 182 (1939);
Xylographa abietina var. degelii (Räsänen) Makar,
Handb. Lich. U.S.S.R. 4: 222 (1977), nom. inval. – Type:
[Russia: Murmanskaya Oblast’, Pechenga:] Lt [Lapponia tulomensis,] Petsamo, Mattert–Ala-Köngäs, ad
lignum vetust[um], 20 Jun 1931, V. Räsänen (F, neotype,
designated here).
Ascomata occurring clustered, with patches of
ascomata amid sterile interspaces; lateral growth
of parallela type, irst generation ascomata linear,
0.5–2.8 × 0.09–0.33 mm, L/W ratio 7.79±4.75, lat-
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
51
Fig. 13. Xylographa pallens (Nyl.) Harm. Habit and arrangement of ascomata. A, holotype (H-NYL); B, U.S.A., Montana, Spribille s.n. (GZU; DNA voucher 1060); C-D, Canada, British Columbia, Spribille 17029 (GZU); E-F, Austria,
Resl 1143 (GZU, DNA voucher 1150). A, ca. 1 mm; B, D, F, 0.5 mm; C, 1 mm; E, 2 mm.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
52
T. Spribille et al.
Fig. 14. Xylographa pallens (Nyl.) Harm. A, colony in axenic culture (in vitro in GZU); B, exciple section; C, asci with
ascospores; D, conidia and conidiogenous hyphae. B, D: U.S.A., Montana, Spribille s.n. (GZU, DNA voucher 1060); C:
Canada, British Columbia, Björk 13789 (UBC). Scale bars: A, 1 mm; B–D, 10 µm.
er generation ascomata regenerating at both ends
of necrotic margin and resembling those of the
irst generation, growing linearly in two to many
directions from mother ascoma, forming “stars”
(Fig. 13); ascomata sometimes “peeling off” when
old; disc lat to concave, pale to dark brown, matte,
with thin brown to pale margin (rarely completely
“bleached” as in X. rubescens), the margin receding in older ascomata; exciple of laterally interwoven hyphae, appearing paraplectenchymatous
in vertical section, usually lush with the hymenium surface in section, 15–35(–50) µm wide at
widest point; excipular hyphae pigmented brown
externally, internally hyaline with a distinct layer
of unpigmented, birefringent (POL+) but noncrystalliferous hyphae between outer exciple and
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
hymenium; hypothecium 80–140(–200) µm deep,
hyaline; hymenium (40–)60–110(–120) µm deep,
unpigmented or hazy yellowish brown, darkening
to dark brown, hemiamyloid, ILugols+ blue-green
turning rust red, consisting of a matrix of asci 52–
85 × 9–20 µm, admixed with slender, branched and
anastomosing paraphyses 1.5–2.0 µm at midpoint,
thickened to 4–6 µm apically, arising ±straight
through the ascus matrix until reaching the surface,
then continuing laterally in knot-like tangles over
surface of disc, with brown wall pigments; ascospores 8/ascus, ellipsoid, (10.0–)12.3–16.1(–18.5)
× (5–)5.8–7.2(–10) µm (L/W ratio 2.1±0.4)(n =
73). Conidiomata infrequent, formed in lines that
appear to demarcate individuals, adnate, globular
to cupular, with wall of interwoven hyphae ap-
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
pearing paraplectenchymatous in section, hyphae
with internal brown wall pigments; conidia iliform, curved, 12–13 × ca. 0.5 µm. Sterile hyphae
mostly lichenized, forming a thallus, with lens-like
patches/areoles 100–150 × 40–60 µm, sometimes
appearing rimose or scurfy, sometimes forming
secondary corticate goniocysts 35–90 µm diam.
Associated algae chlorococcoid, 7–21 µm diam.
Chemistry: stictic acid (major), norstictic acid
(usually trace, rarely major), often with an unidentiied fatty acid (trace).
substrate affinity: on wood, especially in exposed habitats that become xeric in summer.
maCroeCology: mainly montane to subalpine conifer forests, a high elevation species in the Alps, up
to 4300 m in Tibet, lowland records occasional at
high latitudes (e.g. Finland).
Xylographa pallens is a widespread species in the
northern hemisphere. It is more common in mountain regions and areas with a seasonally dry climate
than is X. parallela, which is more strictly borealmontane. It appears to be be abundant in western
North America, northern, central and southeastern
Europe and the Altai, but we have not yet seen any
specimens from northeastern Asia or eastern North
America. It is characterized by aggregated ascomata that grow outwards in two or more directions,
often creating a star-like pattern. Microscopically
it is virtually identical to X. parallela and young
material is nearly impossible to distinguish without DNA sequencing. Mature thalli of the two species are quite distinct and can be easily identiied
with a hand lens. In X. pallens, the ascomata are
aggregated into groups with ascomatal tips growing outwards in two or more directions (Fig. 13A,
D-F); old ascomata will often contain a pallid
“dead zone” in the middle where only remnants of
previous ascomatal shells remain (Fig. 13A). The
ascomata are thus non-evenly distributed, leaving
signiicant ascoma-free portions of open wood or
thallus (Fig. 13A, B, E). In X. parallela, by contrast, ascomata are more or less evenly distributed,
53
and the vast majority of ascomata grow unidirectionally, i.e. after emergence they develop a rounded end and pry open the wood in a single direction
(Fig. 15A, C, E).
Notwithstanding its microscopic similarity to
X. parallela, our sequence data suggest the nearest relative to X. pallens to be X. rubescens. This
relationship can be seen in the occasional persistence of the excipular margins in X. pallens and
the presence in some X. pallens specimens of an
excipular cuticle, causing the margins to appear
whitish. Xylographa pallens further differs from
X. rubescens in the absence or only trace occurrence of norstictic acid (abundant in X. rubescens),
the star-forming habit of ascomatal aggregates (not
known from X. rubescens) and the comparatively
better developed thallus in X. rubescens (Table 4).
Xylographa pallens was described by Nylander
(1857) in a description of the occurrence of X.
parallela in France. The rank at which Nylander
wanted to describe pallens would seem to be ambiguous; he does not list it at equal rank with X.
parallela and X. lexella (= Elixia lexella), other
species recognized in his catalogue, instead calling it a variety but using the species combination
(“ejus verisimiliter modo est varietas X. pallens
Nyl., ibidem occurrens, apotheciis pallide testaceis
vel rufescentibus”, p. 393). Other indications that
Nylander did not intend to recognize it as a species come from a reference to it in a catalog a year
later at varietal rank (Nylander 1858), and from the
Mougeot specimen itself in H-NYL, on which is
clearly written Xylographa parallela var. pallens.
Some authors regularly used binary names for varieties in the 19th century (A. Sennikov, pers. comm.,
2013) and thus there is little doubt that Nylander
intended to describe this as a variety. It was validly
and unambiguously combined as a species by Harmand (1900).
The only Vosges specimen in H-NYL collected by
Mougeot has aggregated ascomata and corresponds
to the concept of X. pallens used here; the name
derives from the beige, empty excipular “shells”
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
54
X. carneopallida
X. difformis
X. pallens
X. parallela
X. rubescens
X. septentrionalis
X. stenospora
Ascomatal regeneration
bidirectional, linear
irregular, deformed
bidirectional, multiple growth tips, old
ascomata forming
stars
mainly unidirectional,
often one apothecium
end blunt
bidirectional, multiple growth tips, old
ascomata forming
(irregular) stars
bidirectional, multiple growth tips,
old ascomata occasionally forming
weak stars
bidirectional, linear, old ascomata
tending to become
deformed
Ascoma length/width
ratio (mean±SD)
2.75–17.5
4.12±2.09
7.79±4.75
5.69±2.56
8.73±7.45
6.89±3.78
3.71±1.33
Ascomatal margin colour
and habit
pale, lighter than
disc, straight
brown to pale cream,
thin, lexuose
brown to cream,
±straight
brown
brown to cream,
lexuose
brown to cream,
±straight
brown to black,
usually “crimped”
or lexuose
Birefringence in exciple
(POL+)
entire exciple full of
true crystals
entire exciple full of
true crystals
inner exciple
inner exciple
entire exciple full of
true crystals
entire exciple full of
true crystals
inner exciple
Ascoma “peeling”
no
no
frequently
frequently
frequently, also
fragmenting
no
no
Hymenial pigments
±unpigmented
brown and sometimes also gray
brown
brown and gray
brown and gray
brown and sometimes also gray
gray and brown
Hymenial amyloidity
euamyloid
euamyloid
hemiamyloid
hemiamyloid
hemiamyloid
hemiamyloid
hemiamyloid
Paraphysis terminal cells
not expanded
expanded to 6 µm
expanded to 6 µm
expanded to 6 µm
expanded to 5 µm
expanded to 6.5 µm
expanded to 5 µm
Mean ascospore length
(µm)
11.4
12.4–14.5
12.3–16.1
11.3–14.5
10.8–12.5
11.9–16.1
10.9–12.7
Mean ascospore width
(µm)
5.3
4.1–6.1
5.8–7.2
5.9–7.6
5.5–6.7
5.9–7.8
3.3–4.5
Ascospore L/W ratio
(mean±SD)
1.9–2.4
2.74±0.74
2.1 ±0.4
2.03 ±0.35
1.98 ±0.33
2.05±0.41
3.06±0.33
Thallus
well developed,
white, lumpy
endoxylic to well
developed, white,
lumpy
well developed,
white, forming lenslike suricial patches
consisting of lichenized algal clumps
between wood ibres,
seldom suricial
granular to rimose
and lumpy
consisting of
lichenized algal
plugs between wood
ibres, breaking out
in goniocysts
consisting of sparse
lichenized algal
plugs between
wood ibres
Goniocysts
absent
absent
often present
often present
usually present
constant, abundant,
forming soralia
absent
Major substances
norstictic and stictic
acids in ±equal
amounts
norstictic only or
norstictic and stictic
acids in ±equal
amounts
stictic acid (major),
norstictic (trace)
stictic acid or substances not detected
norstictic only or
norstictic and stictic
acids in ±equal
amounts, norstictic
localized
norstictic only or
norstictic and stictic
acids in ±equal
amounts
stictic acid or
substances not
detected
Distribution
Boreal-montane,
North America,
Europe, Asia
Boreal-montane,
western North America, Europe
Boreal-montane,
North America,
Europe, Asia
Boreal-montane,
North America,
Europe, Asia
Boreal-montane,
western North
America, Europe,
central Asia
Boreal-montane,
North America
Inland western
North America
T. Spribille et al.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
Table 4. Diagnostic characters in species with long, parallela-like ascomata
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
left behind by advancing ascomata (Fig. 13A).
There is however no indication that Nylander actually subsequently interpreted the taxon as it is used
here. Most specimens annotated with this name
during the 19th century belong to X. trunciseda or
X. soralifera. The misconception of X. pallens was
propagated by the distribution of an exsiccate under the name X. parallela f. pallens that is in fact
X. trunciseda (see that species). In fact, the species
represented by the type specimen – a member of
the X. parallela group with aggregated ascomata –
was never recognized as a distinct taxonomic unit
by European taxonomists. The earliest indication
that it was recognized as a distinct species is notes
on herbarium material in ASU by Bruce Ryan, who
penciled in the unpublished epithet “aggregata”.
Xylographa pallens as circumscribed here includes, in addition to the common stictic acidcontaining form, a norstictic acid-dominant forms
with linear ascomata. These forms correspond to
the entity that Räsänen (1939) called Xylographa rubescens var. degelii (also X. parallela var.
nilssonii in herb.). Räsänen (1939: footnote, pp.
181–182) originally described this as a hypothetical variety after sending Gunnar Degelius a mixed
specimen of X. rubescens and X. parallela s.lat.,
which Degelius subsequently concluded could
not be distinguished. Räsänen rather acridly described the KOH+ red form with long ascospores,
if it should really exist, as X. rubescens var. degelii
Räsänen, clearly without seeing any specimen that
matched these characters (“hat Nilsson-Degelius in
Schweden wirklich mit KOH rotfärbende Xylographa-Individuen mit grösseren Sporen … gefunden,
so gehören diese dann zu einer neuen Varietät,
die folgenderweise beschrieben werden mag”).
Räsänen must have however come to believe in the
variety as he annotated one of his own specimens
(not cited in the protologue), collected in Petsamo
in 1931, variously as var. degelii (specimen in H)
or var. nilssonii (duplicate of the same collection
in F, here designated as a neotype). This specimen
closely matches material we have sequenced corresponding to X. pallens (e.g. isolate 2385). It differs from X. rubescens in its linear ascomata, nar-
55
row discs, dark exciples and immersed thallus, but
possesses dominant norstictic acid. Single-locus
DNA sequencing results of further individuals (not
shown) suggest these forms are separated from X.
pallens by several substitutions in the ITS region
but still cluster with X. pallens rather than X. rubescens. Morphologically the forms are dificult to
separate from specimens of X. pallens with submajor amounts of norstictic acid, and they may constitute an incipient species.
exsiCCates: France: Pyrénées-orientales, Santesson,
Lich. Selecti Exs. Upsal. 200 (BM!, H!, as X. parallela);
Greece: Thessalia, Gyelnik, Lichenotheca 105, BM!, H!
p.p., mixed with X. parallela); Norway: [Hordaland],
J.J. Havaas, Lich. Exs. Norv. 117 (H!, as X. parallela).
additional speCimens examined: Austria: Styria,
Hörsterkogel, 2009, T. Spribille 32101 (GZU); Canada:
British Columbia, East Kootenays, km 12 on Skookumchuck Road, 49°57.806’N, 115°49.244’W, 1271 m, 2
Aug 2005, T. Spribille 17029 & I. Houde (CANL, GZU,
NY); [central interior,] Opax/Mud Lake, C. Björk 15105
(UBC); ibid., Opax Mtn., C. Björk 13789 (UBC); China:
Tibet, prov. Sichuan, Tibetan fringe mountains (Hengduan Shan), Shaluli Shan, 4300 m, 5 Aug 2000, W. Obermayer 9470 (GZU); Finland: Nyl[andia], Helsingfors,
Degerö, 1938, E. Häyrén (H); U. Artjärvi: Villikkala,
Palomäki, 2009, V. Haikonen 27247 (H); [Regio aboensis,] Lohja, Skraatila, 2003, J. Pykälä 23847 (H); [Lapponia sompiensis,] Sodankylä: 6 km W of Korvanen, on
log by river Kopsusjoki, 1959, T. Ahti 11956 (H); Germany: Bayern [=Bavaria], Nationalpark Berchtesgaden,
Steinernes Meer, Feldkogel, 18 Sept 1985, R. Türk & H.
Wunder 5341 (M); südliches Lattengebirge, Almwiesen
oberhalb der Lattenbergalmen, 6 Oct 1987, H. Wunder 4870a (M); Italy: Südtirol [=Trentino-Alto Adige],
Schlern Klamm, 18 Jul [18]67, F. Arnold (H); Norway:
Dovre, Jan 1864, Th.M. Fries (BM); Slovakia: Nízke
Tatry, path between Čertovica and Ďumbier, on sitting
bench, 28 Aug 2009, T. Spribille 32149 & V. Wagner
(GZU); Sweden: Härjedalen, Storsjö par., c. 5 km WNW
of village of Messlingen, 720 m, 3 Aug 1976, R. Santesson 27097 (BM); Switzerland: Canton Valais, Zermatt,
Börter, 2220 m, A. M. Burnet 114 (BM); near Tüfteren,
2215 m, A. M. Burnet 161 (BM); Turkey: Bolu Prov.,
Yedigöller National Park, 5 Jun 2007, T. Spribille s.n.
(GZU); U.S.A: Arizona, Coconino Co., along trail to Mt.
Humphreys timberline, 07 Jul 1994, T.H. Nash 35206
(ASU); California, Madera Co., Shinn Grove, 29 Jun
1994, B.D. Ryan 32027d (ASU, p.p.); Colorado, Boulder Co., Ward Science Lodge, 21 Jul 1961, A. Henssen
13039c (H); Montana, Flathead Co., Whiteish Range,
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
56
T. Spribille et al.
Kimmerly Creek, T. Spribille 4059 (COLO); Wyoming,
Johnson Co., Bighorn National Forest, USFS 31 at West
Fork of Crazy Woman Creek, 29 Jul 2007, C. M. Wetmore 96729 (GZU).
Xylographa parallela (Ach. : Fr.) Fr.
(Fig. 15–16).
Summa Veg. Scand.: 372 (1849). Stictis (Xylographa)
parallela (Ach.) Fr. : Fr. Syst. Mycol. 2(1): 197 (1822);
sanctioned name according to Art. 15.1; Lichen parallelus Ach., Lichenogr. Suec. Prodr.: 23 (1799 [“1798”]);
Opegrapha parallela (Ach.) Ach., Method. Lich.: 20
(1803); Hysterium parallelum (Ach.) Wahlenb., Fl.
lapp.: 523 (1812); Xylogramma parallelum [as “parallela”] (Ach.) Wallr., Fl. crypt. Germ. (Norimbergae) 2:
509 (1833). Type: [Sweden: “habitat ad ligna denudata
emortua truncorum Betulae”]; locality not speciied on
packet, [E. Acharius] 253 (BM-ACH 000500495, lectotype, designated here). Note: The type material at BM
consists of four pieces glued to a single sheet (Fig. 16),
labeled A, B, C and D. Of these, A, B and C represent typical material of X. parallela (TLC: stictic acid in each)
and D appears to represent immature material of X. pallens (Nyl.) Harm. We have chosen the fragment labeled
A (top centre on the sheet) to be the lectotype.
= Hysterium abietinum Pers., Ann. Bot. (Usteri) 15: 31
(1795). Xylographa abietina (Pers.) Zahlbr., Cat. Lich.
Univers. 2: 151 (1922); name not available for use under
Art. 15.1. Type: not found.
= Xylographa incerta A. Massal., Miscell. Lich. 1856:
17 (1856). Type: [Germany:] Ad ligna Herciniae superioris, Hampe (VER, holotype!). TLC: stictic acid.
= Xylographa parallela var. sessitana Bagl. in Arnold,
Flora 67: 663 (1874). Type: [Italy: Piemonte, Prov. Vercelli] sui tronchi scortecciati delle conifere esposti alle
intemperie, presso Riva in Valsesia [= Riva Valdobbia],
1861, Carestia, Erbar. Crittogam. Ital. 843 (WU!, lectotype, designated here; BM!, G!, H, S [image]!, TO!,
isolectotypes).
= Xylographa minutula Körb., Parerga Lichenologica:
276 (1861). Type: [Poland: Silesia] R Sl. [= Riesengebirge, Seifenlehne, currently Złotowka, (valley of the
brook Złoty Potok near lake Mały Staw), Poland; see
Liška 2013] 1/8 46 [= 1 Aug 1846, G.W. Körber]. (L0788902, holotype!)
= Xylographa laricicola Nyl., Flora 68: 13 (1875). Type:
[United Kingdom: Scotland,] supra corticem Laricis
(prope basio truncorum) in Scotia prope Ben Lawers, J.
C. Crombie (H!, lectotype, designated here; BM!, E, G!,
isolectotypes).
= Stictis linearis Cooke & Ellis, Grevillea 7: 7 (1878); Xylographa linearis (Cooke & Ellis) Sacc. in Michelia 2:
141 (1880); Xylogramma lineare (Cooke & Ellis) Sacc.,
Syll. Fung. 8: 678 (1889). Type: [U.S.A.: New Jersey,]
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
Newield, J.B. Ellis (FH-00370118!, lectotype, designated here; G!, isolectotype). TLC: no substances.
Ascomata narrowly ellipsoid, elongate, with lateral
growth, densely and evenly distributed in colonies
of up to 188/cm2, linear, 0.45–1.14× 0.09–0.23 mm,
L/W ratio 5.69±2.56; ascomata growing by extending one end of the ascoma laterally, leaving behind
a blunt end or - in older ascomata - a translucent
excipular shell, occasionally also growing linearly
in two directions; ascomata sometimes “peeling
off” when old; disc lat to slightly convex, locally
concave near tips, dark brown to black, matte, with
thin brown to black margin (never pale), the margin receding in older ascomata and often visible
only at the tips; exciple of laterally interwoven hyphae, appearing paraplectenchymatous in vertical
section, usually lush with the hymenium surface
in section, 15–37 µm wide; excipular hyphae pigmented brown externally, internally hyaline with a
distinct layer of unpigmented, birefringent (POL+)
but non-crystalliferous hyphae between outer exciple and hymenium; hypothecium 40–150 µm deep,
hyaline or a haze of pale brown, of densely packed
hyphae; hymenium 55–110(–150) µm deep, hyaline or hazy, very pale yellow-brown throughout,
hemiamyloid (ILugols+ blue-green turning rust red)
or euamyloid (ILugols+ royal blue), consisting of asci
(30–)52–95 × 8–21(–29) µm embedded in a matrix
of strongly contorted, branched and anastomosing
paraphyses 1.7–2.5 µm at midpoint, often distally
moniliform and thickened to (2.5–)4–6(–8) µm in
the apical cells, the last 4-5 cells continuing lying horizontal in knot-like tangles over surface of
disc and with brown and sometimes also gray wall
pigments; ascospores 8/ascus, ellipsoid, (10.0–
)11.3–14.5(–16.5) × (3.5–)5.9–7.6(–8.5) µm (L/W
ratio 2.03±0.35) (n = 82). Conidiomata infrequent,
adjacent to ascomata but segregated, partially immersed, globose, with wall of laterally interwoven
hyphae appearing paraplectenchymatous in section,
hyphae with internal brown wall pigments; conidia
iliform, curved, 9–14 × ca. 0.5–0.7 µm. Sterile hyphae mostly lichenized, with corticate goniocysts
35–100(–200) µm diam, becoming conluent into
lichenized algal plugs or a ±continuous but largely
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
57
Fig. 15. Xylographa parallela (Ach. : Fr.) Fr. Habit and arrangement of ascomata. A, B: Austria, Spribille s.n. (GZU,
DNA voucher 1061); C, D: U.S.A., Montana, Spribille 21171 (GZU, DNA voucher 2430); E, F: U.S.A. Montana, Spribille 20604 (GZU, DNA voucher 2429). Scale bars: A, B, E, 0.5 mm; C, 1 mm; D, F, 0.2 mm.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
58
T. Spribille et al.
Fig. 16. Type specimen of Xylographa parallela at BM. The specimen top centre is designated as the lectotype.
immersed thallus, sometimes appearing rimose or
scurfy. Associated algae chlorococcoid, 7–16(–20)
µm diam.
Chemistry: stictic acid or secondary substances not
detected.
substrate affinity: on conifer wood, including
logs, snags and fenceposts and rails, rarely on conifer (Larix or Pinus) bark..
maCroeCology: montane and boreal forests between about 35°N to 65°N, mostly in the conifer
forest zone but also south to the New Jersey Pine
Barrens in eastern North America.
Xylographa parallela is a widespread species in
the northern hemisphere and the only one we have
unambiguously conirmed based on DNA sequence
data to occur also in the Southern Hemisphere.
Along with X. pallens it is one of the most common species of the genus. It is easily recognized
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
by its simple, evenly distributed ascomata that tend
to exhibit growth in only one direction, meaning
most ascomata typically have a pointed “leading”
and blunt “trailing” end. The name X. parallela
has long been the only name in widespread use for
Xylographa species with linear ascomata considerably longer than wide, and thus has been applied to
a large range of material, which we now recognize
as belonging to other species, especially X. pallens.
The two species are microscopically almost identical, but can easily be separated by their growth
habit, with X. parallela forming regular, evenly
spaced colonies of single ascomata strictly aligned
with the grain of the wood, and X. pallens developing ascomata in clusters with multiple leading tips
growing outward from a central point, and considerable ascoma-free space between each ascomatal
cluster (Table 4). The genetic distinction of these
two species is likewise unambiguous.
Bark-dwelling forms of X. parallela have long
been recognized as a distinct species, X. minutula,
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
as recently as Wirth et al. (2013). However, DNA
sequence data from a recent specimen from the
Russian Far East, agreeing morphologically with
the type of X. minutula and on Larix bark, does
not differ from that in X. parallela. Xylographa
minutula was long thought to be a sorediate species, beginning with the protologue and continuing
into the 20th century (Lettau 1911; Zahlbruckner
1922). The type specimen of X. minutula at L is
extremely small but exhibits the short, irregular ascomata and stain-like thallus seen in other
specimens. In his protologue, Körber (1861: 276)
described the species as “tenuissime leprosus
albido-cinerascens”, but he was seeing the accompanying species Lecidea pullata on the type.
It is not known what controls the ability of X.
parallela to colonize bark, but it may constitute
a secondary relaxation of whatever mechanism
otherwise enforces the high afinity to wood in Xylographa. Remarkably, while lignicolous X. parallela is still common and widespread, the “X. minutula ecotype” appears to have all but disappeared
from Europe. The species was collected in the 19th
century in Tyrol (Austria), Germany, the presentday Czech Republic and Scotland (where it was
described as X. laricicola), but we have seen only
one collection from Europe from after 1950, from
Switzerland (1998, M. Dietrich 11633, G).
The authorship for the combination of parallela in
Xylographa is often attributed to Behlen and Desberger (Zahlbruckner 1922, 1932; Santesson 1993;
Giavarini & Orange 2009) based on the appearance
of the species in an early book on German forest
cryptogams (Behlen & Desberger 1835). However,
the latter authors clearly recognized Xylographa as
a kind of unranked section of Stictis, and parallela was listed within that genus as “St. parallela”.
Thus neither was the genus validated here, nor the
species combination in Xylographa. The earliest
valid combination is that of Fries (1849). Because
of the sanctioning of the Acharius epithet through
Fries (1822), the full proper author citation has to
be (Ach. : Fr.) Fr. Santesson et al. (2004) recognized this error and provided a corrected species
authorship.
59
seleCted exsiCCates: Czech Republic: Moravia, Kovář,
Cryptog. Exs. Vindob. 1025 (BM!, FH!, H!, M!; corresponds to the X. “minutula” ecotype, distributed under
X. parallela f. elliptica); France: Plantae Graecenses 56
(BM!); Italy: Erbar. Crittogam. Ital. 843 (as X. parallela
var. sessitana, see synonym list for herbaria); Norway:
Vězda, Lich. Selecti Exs. 2315 (BM!); Poland: Tobolewski, Lichenoth. Polon. 334 (BM!); Romania: Cretzoiu, Lich. Rom. Exs. 84 (BM!); Slovakia: Timkó, Fl.
Hung. Exs. 512 (F!); Switzerland: Luzern, Kunze, Fungi
Sel. Exs. 368 (H!, mixed with Agyrium rufum).
seleCted additional speCimens examined: Argentina:
Tierra del Fuego, S side of Paso Garibaldi, 54°41’S,
67°50’W, 6 Nov 1997, R. Guderley, H.T. Lumbsch &
G. Vobis 12031a (F); Chile: Prov. Antártica Chilena,
Comuna de Hornos, N shore of Isla Navarino, N slopes
of Pico de la Bandera from Río Róbalo dam to 400 m
marker, 22 Jan 2013, W.R. Buck 60821 (NY); Germany: [Niedersachsen,] Harz, Braunlage, 10 Jul 1906,
H. Zschacke (H); Japan: Hokkaido, Ishikari Prov.,
Kamikawa gun, Kamikawa cho, E of Obako Gorge
Tourist Centre, 10 Jun 1995, T. Tønsberg 23129 (BG);
Turkey: Prov. Gümüsane, Kalkani Mts., Zigana Pass,
40°38’25”N, 39°23’59”E, on bark of Pinus, 2000 m, 12
Jul 2001, A. Guttová, J. Halda & Z. Palice 11830 (herb.
Palice; = X. “minutula” ecotype); U.S.A.: Alaska, Denali
Borough, Summit Lake, Parks Highway, 63°07.411‘N,
149°27.447‘W, lignicolous, 587 m, 17 Aug 2008, T.
Spribille 27762 (GZU); Montana, Lake Co., St. Mary’s
Lake, T. Spribille 20604 (GZU).
Xylographa rubescens Räsänen
(Fig. 17)
in Vainio, Medd. Soc. Fauna Flora Fenn. 47: 51 (1921).
Type: [Finland: Ostrobottnia ultima,] O[strobot-tnia]
b[orealis]. Simo, Tiurasenkrunni, lautakatolla [on board
roof]. 14/6 [19]20, V. Räsänen (H!, lectotype, designated
here; the thallus labeled “1.”). Two specimens collected
a year later may be considered topotypes: O[strobottnia]
b[orealis]. Simo, Tiurasenkrunni, laholla lautakatolla
[on rotten board roof]. 10/VII.21, V. Räsänen (H!);
O[strobottnia] b[orealis]. Simo Tiurasenkrunni, laholla
lautakatolla, 20/VI.21, V. Räsänen (H!).
Ascomata occurring clustered, with patches of
ascomata amid sterile interspaces; lateral growth
of parallela type; irst generation ascomata linear, very variable in length, 0.4–4.4 × 0.11–0.45
mm, L/W ratio 8.73±7.45; later generation ascomata regenerating at both ends of necrotic margin and resembling those of the irst generation,
growing linearly in two to many directions from
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
60
T. Spribille et al.
Fig. 17. Xylographa rubescens Räsänen A, B, habit of type material; C, habit showing fragmenting ascomata; D, detail
showing “peeling” ascomata (arrows); E, habit, showing adjacent parts of thallus with (KOH+ red) and without (K-)
norstictic acid; F, detail, showing pseudopruinose ascomatal discs. A, B: holotype (H); C, Finland, Norrlin s.n. (H); D,
U.S.A., Montana, Spribille s.n., 15 Oct 2007 (GZU); E, Sweden, Vänskä 7534 (H), F, U.S.A., Washington, Spribille
17491 (GZU). Scale bars: A, C, ca. 1 mm; B, E, ca. 0.5 mm; D, F, 0.5 mm.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
mother ascoma, forming contorted, lexuose aggregates, rarely recognizable “stars” (Fig. 17D,
E); ascomata often fragmenting into multiple sectors (Fig. 17C), “peeling off” when old (Fig. 17D);
disc lat to strongly convex, pale to red brown
or dark brown, matte, often apparently pruinose,
with thick, pale, “bleached” margin, the margin
persistent; exciple of laterally interwoven hyphae,
appearing paraplectenchymatous in vertical section, lush with the hymenium surface in section
or overtopping it, 18–60(–90) µm wide at widest
point; excipular hyphae pigmented brown externally, internally hyaline and illed throughout with
birefringent (POL+) crystals; hypothecium 80–170
µm deep, hyaline; hymenium 60–120 µm deep, unpigmented or hazy yellowish brown, darkening to
dark brown above, lacking crystals or with obscure
POL+ guttulae, hemiamyloid, ILugols+ blue-green
turning rust red, rarely euamyloid, consisting of a
matrix of asci 43–93 × 13–20 µm, admixed with
slender, branched and anastomosing paraphyses
1.5–2.5 µm at midpoint, thickened to 3–5 µm apically, arising ±straight through the ascus matrix until reaching the surface, then continuing laterally in
knot-like tangles over surface of disc, with brown
and gray wall pigments, rarely unpigmented; ascospores 8/ascus, ellipsoid, (9.0–)10.8–12.5(–14.0)
× (4.5–)5.5–6.7(–8.5) µm (L/W ratio 1.98±0.33)
(n = 61). Conidiomata infrequent, adjacent to
ascomata but segregated, adnate, globular to cupular, 60–170 µm diam, with wall of interwoven
hyphae appearing paraplectenchymatous in section, hyphae with internal brown wall pigments;
conidia iliform, curved, 12–14 × ca. 0.5 µm. Sterile hyphae mostly lichenized, forming a thallus,
verruculose-areolate to rimose, forming distinct
granular patches of unpigmented or brown goniocysts, these 50–70 µm diam, corticate and strongly
infused with POL+ crystals, KOH+ bleeding red
norstictic acid crystals out of the fungal cells. Associated algae chlorococcoid, 8–16 µm diam.
Chemistry: norstictic acid (major), alone or occasionally with stictic acid (submajor to trace). North
American specimens agreeing in ITS sequence can
have stictic and norstictic acids estimated to be in
61
near equal amounts on TLC plates, or even no detectable norstictic acid, as the latter appears sometimes to be localized in certain thallus parts or in
the exciple (Fig. 17E).
substrate affinity: on conifer wood, especially in
exposed habitats that become xeric in summer.
maCroeCology: lowland boreal conifer forests
(in Canada and Finland), also in montane conifer
forests at elevations up to 1700 m (in the Altai,
Pyrenees and Sierra Nevada of California) and to
3000 m in the Rocky Mountains of Colorado.
The name Xylographa rubescens has been in circulation for nearly a century in Finland following
its description by Veli Räsänen in Vainio (1921),
but there has never been consensus on whether it is
a distinct species. Nilsson (1930; the earlier name
of Gunnar Degelius) argued that the ascospore size
of a piece provided to him by Räsänen was the
same as for X. abietina (= X. parallela) and that
X. rubescens was no more than a ‘chemical species’; he reduced it to a variety of the former (we
found ascospore size is not a good distinguishing
character). The topic of the merit of X. rubescens
as a species was again taken up by Brodo (1992),
apparently independent of the discussion by Degelius and Räsänen. Brodo likewise concluded that
X. rubescens was no more than a chemical form of
X. parallela.
In fact, molecular data support the recognition of
X. rubescens and suggest that it is more closely
related to X. pallens than X. parallela; the sister
group relationship is nearly supported in both the
Bayesian MCMC and ML analyses, and is fully
supported in analysis of unpruned DNA data (not
shown). The close relationship is relected in the
morphology, especially the tendency of X. rubescens to develop aggregate ascomata and “stars”,
and the shared habit of both species to have pale,
thickened margins (though much more strongly the
case in X. rubescens).
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
62
T. Spribille et al.
When well developed, X. rubescens is distinctive
and cannot be confused with any other species:
in particular, its combination of pale margins in
young ascomata, ascomata regularly fragmenting
when old, and norstictic acid in the thallus (KOH+
orange-red even in macroscopic spot tests) is not
found in any other species. Several members of
the X. parallela group (notably X. parallela s.str.
and X. pallens) can develop “deciduous” ascomata
that peel off and fragment, but no species develops such an extreme case of this as X. rubescens
(exempliied for instance in Haikonen 20951, H).
In dry weather, these “peeling ascomata” point
perpendicularly off from the wood surface and are
brittle and clingy, making it likely that fragments
become lodged in the fur or feathers of passing
squirrels and birds.
Distinguishing young X. rubescens from X. pallens in areas where they co-occur can be dificult,
even with mature material. In some cases, X. pallens can also develop pale margins, non-negligible
amounts of norstictic acid and fragmenting ascomata. However, even in mixed collections (e.g.
Haikonen 22289, H), the two species maintain
distinguishing features (Table 4). In X. rubescens,
(1) the ascomata are coarser and shorter (long and
thin in X. pallens), with broader discs, larger, dark
brown to pale margins, hymenia which fragment
in older ascomata, shedding chunks of hymenia
and leaving behind pale excipular shells (seldom
the case in X. pallens); (2) thallus granules are pale
creamish, seldom darkly pigmented as in X. pallens; and (3) norstictic acid predominates giving
a strong KOH+ orange-red reaction (most X. pallens have predominantly stictic acid, KOH+ pale to
strong yellow, not turning red). Xylographa rubescens is by far the rarer of the two species at middle
latitudes, becoming more common at high latitudes
(such as central Finland) and higher altitudes (Altai, Pyrenees, Rocky Mountains) and in general in
more continental climates. In critical cases it may
be necessary to sequence barcode loci such as ITS
to verify the identity of the material.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
exsiCCates: Finland: Räsänen, Lich. Fenn. Exs. 842
(M); U.S.A.: Colorado, Weber, Lich. Exs. COLO 163
(ALA!, FH!, as X. spilomatica; for other replicates see
X. septentrionalis, X. vitiligo).
additional speCimens examined: Canada: British Columbia, East Kootenays, Rocky Mountains,
White River region E of Canal Flats, Moscow
Road, 50°20.490’N, 115°35.255’W, 1053 m, 01
Aug 2005, T. Spribille 16974-B (UBC); Manitoba,
W shore of Blueberry Lake, 15 Jun 2003, I.M. Brodo
31221A (CANL); Yukon, Wernecke Mtns., Carpenter
Lake, 64°30’N, 135°06’W, 25 Jul 1972, G.W. Scotter 19376 (CANL); Finland: Regio aboensis, Lohja,
Nummenkylä, J. Pykälä 22782 (H); Tavastia australis,
Tavastia, J. P. Norrlin (H), Sysmä, Liikola, Viljamenvuori, 16 Sept 2001, V. Haikonen 20737 (H); Heinola,
Lusi, Näätävuori, 28 Oct 2001, V. Haikonen 20951
(H); Russia: [Komi Republic,] Rossia bor., ad lum[en]
Petschora, Varjanga, 15 Jun 1891, A.O. Kihlman (H); Altai Republic, Altai Mts., distr. Shebalino, Cherga: right
side of the Sema river approx. 4.6 km N-NNE of the village, 51° 36.823’N, 85° 35.140’E, 495 m, P. Resl 1142
(GZU); Spain: Navarra, Roncal Valley above Isaba, 2
May 2009, T. Spribille 30255 & S. Pérez-Ortega (GZU);
Sweden: Uppland, Vänge, Fiby urskog, 27 Sept 1959,
A. Henssen 4849 (H); Jämtland, Åre parish, Mt. Snasahögarna, Snasahögsvallen, 14 Aug 1974, H. Vänskä
7534 (H); U.S.A.: California, Madera Co., Shinn Grove,
37°14’45”N, 119°25’30”W, 29 Jun 1994, B.D. Ryan
32027d (ASU); Montana, Glacier Co., Upper Two Medicine Lake, 15 Oct 2007, T. Spribille s.n. & V. Wagner
(GNP); Washington, Pend Oreille Co., Frater Lake, 19
Aug 2005, T. Spribille 17491 (GZU, NY, UBC).
Xylographa schoieldii T. Sprib., sp.
nov. (Fig. 18). Mycobank No.: MB
805259.
Similar to Xylographa vitiligo (Ach.) J.R. Laundon, but with goniocysts with a smooth, compact
surface and chemically with confriesiic acid instead of stictic acid as main substance; on wood in
hypermaritime regions.
Type: U.S.A.: Alaska, E of Gustavus, just outside
boundary of Glacier Bay National Park and Preserve,
Falls Creek, 58.43788°N, 135.63509°W, 21m elev., on
suspended, exposed conifer log in boggy Tsuga heterophylla-Malus fusca thicket, 28 Jul 2012, A. Fryday, M.
Svensson & T. Spribille 39088 (NY, holotype; CANL,
GZU, H, UBC, isotypes)
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
63
Fig. 18. Xylographa schoieldii T. Sprib. A, B, habit of type material; C, D, goniocysts, in water. All photos from holotype (DNA voucher 1103). Scale bars: A, 2 mm; B, 0.2 mm; C, F, 50 µm; D, 10 µm; E, 500 µm.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
64
T. Spribille et al.
Etymology: Named for Wilfred B. “Wilf” Schoield
(1927–2008), professor of botany at University of British Columbia, an inspiration to many and collector of the
irst specimen of this species.
Ascomata and Conidiomata not seen. Sterile hyphae lichenized, bound to algal plugs developing
endosubstratally in the wood ibre, white, regularly breaking out on the surface as round, strongly
convex soralia 0.21–0.9 mm diam, gray-green externally, internally pinkish when damaged or exposed, becoming conluent; goniocysts 27–50(–87)
µm diam, forming “consoredia” held together by
a paraplectenchymatous hyphal matrix, pigmented
brown when exposed. Associated algae chlorococcoid, 8–10 µm diam.
Chemistry: confriesiic acid (major).
substrate affinity: on conifer wood.
maCroeCology: known only from hypermaritime
coastal rainforests on the outer west coast of NW
North America in the Gulf of Alaska.
Xylographa schoieldii is similar to X. vitiligo in
habit but differs in chemistry, containing confriesiic acid. It is not included in our phylogenetic tree
because we were able to obtain only a single locus
(mtSSU) despite multiple re-sampling of the Alaskan material. The sequence conirms its placement
in Xylographa but due to the low level of variability in mtSSU and absence of other loci, the inclusion of this species in the tree would only serve
to weaken the support for other relationships. The
species is known from only three collections but
can be expected to be more widespread in hypermaritime coastal rainforests of southeastern Alaska
and British Columbia.
additional speCimen examined: Canada: British Columbia, Queen Charlotte Islands, Graham Island, McClinton
Bay, SW Masset Inlet, on log of upper salt marsh, 30 Jul
1967, W.B. Schoield 35238a (CANL); U.S.A.: Alaska,
same locality as type, 28 July 2012, A. Fryday 10275
(MSC).
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
Xylographa septentrionalis T. Sprib.,
sp. nov. (Fig. 19). Mycobank No.: MB
805260.
Similar to Xylographa parallela (Ach. : Fr.) Fr.
with linear ascomata but thallus producing compact goniocysts in soralia and thallus with stictic
and norstictic or only norstictic acid.
Type: Canada: British Columbia, Cassiar Highway,
Dease River area, 5 mi N of Baking Powder Creek, 14
mi N of Boya Lake, 59°32.780’N, 129°14.067’W, open
Pinus woodland, on logs, 708 m, 9 Oct 2007, T. Spribille
25133 (CANL, holotype; GZU, H, isotypes).
Etymology: septentrionalis (Latin), northern, in reference to the provenance of the type material.
Ascomata when present with lateral growth of
parallela type, not proliferating through “budding”, ascomata linear or narrowly long-ellipsoid,
0.33–1.9 × 0.06–0.3 mm, L/W ratio 6.89±3.78;
disc lat to convex, brown, matte, with thin brown
to pale cream, straight margin, lighter than disc;
exciple of laterally interwoven hyphae, appearing
paraplectenchymatous in vertical section, 18–50
µm wide laterally; excipular hyphae pigmented
brown externally, wholly illed with POL+ crystals; hypothecium 70–140 µm deep, hyaline or
pale hazy yellowish; hymenium 60–80 µm deep,
hyaline to pale hazy yellow-brown throughout,
sparingly inspersed with POL+ hymenial crystals, hemiamyloid (ILugols+ blue-greenà rust red),
consisting of clavate asci 58–75 × 15–19 µm,
embedded in a matrix of straight, stout, sparsely
branched paraphyses 2–2.5 µm wide at midpoint,
distally ±moniliform and thickened to 4–6.5 µm
in the apical cell, with brown and sometimes also
gray wall pigments; ascospores 8/ascus, ellipsoid,
(11–)11.9–16.1(–22) × (5–)5.9–7.8(–9.5) µm (L/W
ratio 2.05±0.41) (n = 43). Conidiomata inconspicuous, intermingled among ascomata, immersed,
globose, ca. 80 µm diam, with light brown pigmented wall; conidia long-iliform, curved, 20–22
× ca. 0.5 µm. Sterile hyphae lichenized, connecting to algal plugs to 100 µm long developing in
the wood ibre, white, regularly breaking out on
the surface with convex mounds of dark brown
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
65
Fig. 19. Xylographa septentrionalis T. Sprib. A-D, habit and arrangement of ascomata. D, goniocysts, in water; E,
soralia and F, goniocysts in SEM. A, B, D, E, F: holotype (DNA voucher 2402); C: U.S.A., Arizona, Nash 39348 (M).
Scale bars: A, 0.5 mm; B, C, 0.2 mm; D, 10 µm; E, 200 µm; F, 50 µm.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
66
T. Spribille et al.
pigmented goniocysts (= soralia), these roundish,
indeterminate, 0.12–0.27 mm diam; goniocysts 1834 µm diam, forming “consoredia” held together
by a paraplectenchymatous hyphal matrix, puzzlepieced in surface view, pigmented dark brown
when exposed. Associated algae chlorococcoid,
6–11 µm diam.
Chemistry: stictic/norstictic acid or only norstictic
acid.
substrate
logs.
affinity:
on conifer wood, especially
maCroeCology: in boreal and montane forests, a
rather continental species. Records from the western Cordillera of North America may belong in
part to another, undescribed species (see below).
This species has been widely confused with Xylographa vitiligo, from which it differs even in sterile
material in its much smaller soralia with darker,
sparser and more compact goniocysts (compare the
“hard” goniocysts of Figs. 19E, F with the roughened goniocysts of Figs. 24C, D). Fertile material
can be instantly distinguished from both X. soralifera and X. vitiligo on account of its “parallelatype”, linear ascomata as opposed to the short,
“trunciseda-type” ascomata of those two species.
X. septentrionalis and X. vitiligo are not closely
related; X. septentrionalis is a close relative of X.
difformis. X. septentrionalis is widespread, especially in western North America, and represented
by several rich collections in the herbaria studied.
It can be expected to be found in boreal Asia and
Europe as well.
Xylographa septentrionalis appears to consist of
at least two genetically distinct entities. The irst,
described here as the type, was sampled in both the
Yukon (three locus sample) and southeastern British Columbia (only ITS obtained: Spribille 16905).
A second form was sampled from Montana (Fig. 1:
accession 1056) and appears to be closely related
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
to Xylographa carneopallida, outside the core X.
parallela group; it is not included in the diagnosis and measurements for X. septentrionalis here.
Furthermore, we have observed some specimens to
contain only norstictic acid and others to include
both stictic and norstictic acid. It is not clear if
more than two entities are involved and how they
can be distinguished, if at all. Xylographa septentrionalis is a highly variable species (note range of
ascospore sizes, even in sequenced material) and
we do not fully understand this variation. In addition, while numerous specimens exist in herbaria
that formally it to the description of the species,
there is little fresh material. We refrain from describing a second species until we have more material for DNA sampling and understand the limits of
morphological, chemical and genetic variation in
X. septentrionalis.
exsiCCate: Canada: British Columbia, Brodo, Lich.
Can. Exs. 150 (M!, as X. vitiligo); U.S.A.: Arizona, Nash,
Lich. Exs. Arizona State Univ. 200 (G!, M!,, issued as X.
vitiligo); ibid., Nash, Lich. Exs. Arizona State Univ. 300
(BM!, G!, issued as X. hians); Colorado, Weber, Lich.
Exs. COLO 163 (M!, mixed with X. pallens; for other
replicates see X. rubescens and X. vitiligo).
additional speCimens examined (norstictic acid only):
Canada: British Columbia, Rocky Mountains, bench
on west bank of the White River, ca. 13 km north of
Whiteswan Lake, 50°16.060’N, 115°30.719’W, 1183 m,
31 Jul 2005, T. Spribille 16905 (UBC); U.S.A.: Arizona,
Apache Co., W side of Escudilla Mtn., 21 May 1975, T.
H. Nash 10679 p.p. (ASU); Minnesota, St. Louis Co.,
Voyageurs National Park, 3.5 mi W of Kettle Falls, 12
Jun 1978, C.M. Wetmore 32943 (CANL).
additional speCimens examined (stictic/norstictic chemistry): Canada: British Columbia, Brackendale, 10 Jun
1916, J. Macoun s.n. (F, FH); Moresby Island, Alliford
Bay, 18 Jul 1967, I.M. Brodo 11757 (CANL); Northwest Territories, Reindeer Station, J.W. Thomson & J.
A. Larsen 15607 p.p. (CANL); Glacier (Brintnell) Lake,
1939, H.M. Raup 3557 p.p. (CANL, FH); Mexico: Chihuahua, Sierra Madre Occidental, 20 km SE of Cusárare,
27°32’N, 107°23’50”W, 22 Jul 1994, J. Hafellner 37802
(GZU); U.S.A.: Arizona, Apache Co., Mt. Baldy Wilderness, 30 Sept 1997, T.H. Nash 39348 (ASU); Sunrise Ski
Area, Fort Apache Reservation, 29 Aug 1975, T.H. Nash
11694b (ASU); Colorado, Garield Co., NW of Mead-
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
ow Lake Campgound, 24 Jun 1992, T.H. Nash 31936a
(ASU); Michigan, Isle Royale National Park, Wallace
Lake, 10 Jul 1983, C.M. Wetmore 47633 (CANL); Montana, Lincoln Co., Grave Creek at Cat Creek, 2011, T.
Spribille s.n. (GZU); Oregon, Lincoln Co., public ishing pier below Yaquina Bay bridge, B. McCune 27218
(F); South Dakota, Pennington Co., Medicine Mt. Rd.,
19 Jul 1960, C.M. Wetmore 7757 (CANL); on west side
of south arm of Deerield Reservoir, 19 Jul 1960, C.M.
Wetmore 7811 (CANL).
Xylographa soralifera Holien &
Tønsberg (Fig. 20).
Graphis Scripta 20: 58 (2008). Type: U.S.A.: Washington, Kittitas Co., 25 km NE of Cle Elum, off Hwy 97,
0.95 miles along Old Blewett Road towards Old Blewett
Pass, 47°20’N, 120°41’W, alt. 1000 m, on wood of conifer log, on W-facing, dry slope with Pinus ponderosa
and Pseudotsuga menziesii, 24 Sept 1999, T. Tønsberg
28049 (BG, holotype; isotypes to be distributed in Tønsberg, Lich. Isid. Sor. Crust. Exs.).
Ascomata solitary or adjacent in groups to 3 mm
in diameter, with lateral growth of trunciseda type,
straight to slightly curved, mostly ± ellipsoid or
rounded, sometimes linear, rarely stellate, 0.20–
0.36 × 0.10–0.32 mm; margin to 0.08 mm wide,
dark brown to medium brown, becoming light
brown with age, in uppermost part often becoming
thin, whitish and ± lacerate; disc concave to lat,
rarely convex, grayish white to brown, becoming
pale brownish to rose in widely exposed discs; exciple 35–80 μm wide in uppermost part, brown in
outer part, colourless to faintly yellowish towards
the hymenium, with POL+ birefringence present in
inner part of exciple; hymenium pale yellowish in
top 10 µm with some POL+ crystals present, colourless below, 70 to 140 μm deep; hypothecium
not well separated from excipulum in lower part,
colourless, 50–70 μm deep; asci clavate, 52–70(–
130) × 12–17 μm; ascospores 8/ascus, sometimes
sticking together when out of ascus in squash
preparations, simple, mostly straight, sometimes
slightly curved, elongate with rounded ends to
ellipsoid, sometimes, especially in upper part of
ascus, obovoid, rarely globose, (7–)9.5–13.3(–17)
× (3–)5.3–6.3(–8) μm (L/W ratio 2.19±0.57) (n =
74). Conidiomata not observed. Sterile hyphae
67
lichenized, developing in the wood, colourless,
forming convex endosubstratal areoles (tuberculae) which at irst are covered by the uppermost
layer of the wood, some bursting open to form
convex soralia producing conglutinated goniocysts
(= soredia); soralia at irst often brown due to pigmentation of the external soredia, later when external, pigmented soredia are shed becoming pale
greenish to dirty white, rounded, 0.3–0.6 mm wide;
soredia colourless or, especially in the outwardly
facing part of external soredia, brown, globose
with a more or less distinct paraplectenchymatous
wall but with a rough surface (Fig. 20F), 15–36 μm
diam, becoming conglutinated (Fig. 20C, F). Photobiont (endosubstratal and in the soredia/consoredia) chlorococcoid, 6–13 μm.
Chemistry: fumarprotocetraric acid ± traces of
satellites. Brown pigment in excipulum and wall
of soredia/consoredia: K–, N– or + brown with a
reddish tinge.
substrate affinity: on conifer wood, especially
logs, at least two records from conifer bark.
maCroeCology: in montane conifer forests, especially in suboceanic regions (e.g., the Alps, the
Scandes, the interior wet belt of NW North America).
Xylographa soralifera was long overlooked within
the variability of the X. vitiligo complex until it
was recognized and described in detail by Holien
& Tønsberg (2008). It is most easily distinguished
from X. vitiligo by its strongly convex, greenish
soralia and its distinctive chemistry (see Heininger
& Spribille 2009 and Fig. 20). Our molecular results provide strong support for all specimens with
fumarprotocetraric acid forming a monophyletic
clade. The only NCBI voucher of Xylographa previous to this study, originally accessioned as X. vitiligo, was recovered by our analyses in this clade
and subsequently revised to X. soralifera, an observation backed up by TLC analysis (Z. Palice, pers.
comm.). The voucher for that specimen represents
the irst for Turkey and Asia for this species.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
68
T. Spribille et al.
Fig. 20. Xylographa soralifera Holien & Tønsberg A, B, habit dry (A) and moistened (B); C, squash preparation of
whole soralium and D, individual goniocysts in water; E, soralium in SEM; F, close-up of goniocysts in SEM, showing
conglutination of goniocysts. All photos: U.S.A., Washington, Spribille 29853 (DNA voucher 1070). Scale bars: A, B, 1
mm; C, 50 µm; D, 10 µm; E, 200 µm; F, 50 µm.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
Xylographa soralifera is one of the only species
of Xylographa with a described lichenicolous fungus, Bellemerella ritae (Pérez-Ortega & Spribille
2007). Other lichenicolous fungi are however
known from X. trunciseda and X. vitiligo (unpublished) as well as undescribed coelomycetous fungi from the X. parallela group.
Some specimens from the southern edge of the species’ range in North America (Arizona, Colorado)
have strongly salt-and-pepper-pigmented external
soredia and smaller soralia (e.g., Nash 7874, ALA;
Anderson s.n., 29 Sept 1962, FH). Interestingly,
this form has also been seen at low latitudes in Europe (Austria: Brodo 19900, CANL). They appear
otherwise typical. Specimens cited here and in Table 1 considerably extend the range of this species.
exsiCCate: France: Roumeguère, Lich. Gallici exs. 89
(M!); U.S.A.: Montana, Weber, Lich. Exs. COLO 526
(ALA!, BG!, GZU!, FH!, G!, H!, M!, for the most part;
mixed with X. vitiligo (in FH) and X. rubescens in some
replicates).
representative speCimens examined (only specimens
not cited in previous papers): Canada: British Columbia, Shuswap Highland, Trophy Mountain Recreation
area, 24 Aug 1994, T. Ahti 52094 (H); Glacier National
Park, on bark[!], T. Goward 05-223 (UBC; veriied by
mtSSU rDNA); Okanagan Lake area, ca. 25 km NNW of
Kelowna, Wrinkley Face Mt., 27 Sept 2008, I.M. Brodo
32377 (CANL); Norway: [Møre og Romsdal,] Skiri i
Romsdalen, Aug. 1904, J.J. Havaas (BG-L-56149, BGL-56150); Nordland, Grane, the S slope of Lillefjellet,
65°07’N 13°22’E, alt. 530 m, 22 Aug 1981, T. Tønsberg
6085 (BG-L-36778); Grane, Majavatn, the W-facing
foothills of Litlfjellet, 65°09.86’N 13°22.58’E, 350–400
m, 13 June 2011, T. Tønsberg 41033 (BG); Troms, Bardu,
N of Setermoen, E of Sponga, 68°52.47’N 18°22.65’E,
alt. 60–80 m, 13 July 2010, T. Tønsberg 40236 (BG-L89242); Finnmark, Nalganas i Alten, J.M. Norman (BGL-56170); Russia: [Krasnoyarsk Krai,] Guv. Jenisejsk,
Polovinka, 68°15’ n. Br., 16 Sep 1876, M. Brenner 411k
(H); Sweden: Åsele Lappmark, Vilhelmina, 18 km N of
Stalon, Mt. Mörrösjöliden, 9 Aug 1991, T. Ahti 50331
(H); Switzerland: Canton de Vaud, commune et réserve
forestière de Montricher, 29 Sept 2004, M. Mola s.n. (G);
U.S.A.: Arizona, Apache Co., trail to Mt. Baldy, 25 May
1973, T.H. Nash 7874 (ALA); Mt. Baldy Wilderness, 02
Jul 1994, T.H. Nash 34760 (ASU); Colorado, Boulder
Co., Rocky Mtn. National Park, Wild Basin, 29 Sept
69
1962, R.A. Anderson s.n. (FH); Montana, Gallatin Co.,
Yellowstone National Park, 16 Jul 1998, C.M. Wetmore
80593 (ASU); Washington, Skagit Co., 27 Sept 1993, B.
D. Ryan 30478-A (ASU).
Xylographa stenospora T. Sprib. &
Resl, sp. nov. (Fig. 21). Mycobank
No.: MB 805261.
Similar to Xylographa parallela (Ach. : Fr.) Fr.,
but with consistently narrow ascospores and strong
gray pigments in the ascomata, causing them to be
black.
Type: Canada: British Columbia, Mt. Revelstoke National Park, summit trail on Mt. Revelstoke, 51°02’N,
118°00’W, lignicolous on Abies [lasiocarpa] snag, oldgrowth ESSF [Engelmann spruce-subalpine ir forest]
with Tsuga mertensiana, ca. 1800 m, 01 Aug 2005, T.
Goward 05-83 (UBC, holotype; GZU, isotype).
Etymology: From Greek στενός, narrow + spore, a reference to the characteristic narrow ascospores.
Ascomata with lateral growth of parallela-type;
form linear to narrowly ellipsoid, 0.55–1.6 × 0.2–0.8
mm, L/W ratio 3.71±1.33; disc lat to slightly concave, dark brown to black, matte with a roughened
surface, margin straight or occasionally “crimped”,
black in young ascomata, persistent in older ascomata; exciple of laterally interwoven hyphae, appearing paraplectenchymatous in vertical section,
lush with the hymenium surface in section, 22–55
µm wide laterally; excipular hyphae pigmented
brown and gray externally, internally with birefringent hyphal cell walls (POL+); hypothecium ca.
70 µm deep, hyaline; hymenium 70–100 µm deep,
hyaline; hemiamyloid (ILugols+ greenish à rust red),
consisting of asci 50–70 × 14–20 µm, embedded in
a matrix of slender, simple or sparsely branched paraphyses 1.5–3 µm wide at midpoint, distally moniliform and abruptly thickened to 5 µm in the apical cell, with both brown and gray wall pigments,
together appearing at times greenish; ascospores 8/
ascus, narrowly ellipsoid, (10.0–)10.9–12.7(–14)
× (3–)3.3–4.5(–5) µm (L/W ratio 3.06±0.33) (n =
80). Conidiomata black, globose, adjacent to and
apparently freely mixed with ascomata, not segregated, ca ¾ immersed, ca. 100–120 µm diam,
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
70
T. Spribille et al.
Fig. 21. Xylographa stenospora T. Sprib. & Resl Habit and arrangement of ascomata. A, B: holotype [Goward]; C, D:
Canada, British Columbia, Björk 13454 (UBC); E, F: U.S.A., Montana, Spribille 20345 (GZU). Scale bars: A, C, E, 1
mm; B, D, F, 0.2 mm.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
with wall of laterally interwoven hyphae appearing
paraplectenchymatous in section, hyphae with internal brown wall and gray pigments; conidia iliform, curved, 14–18 × ca. 0.5 µm. Sterile hyphae
contacting immersed algal plugs 90–250 × 40–90
µm situated between wood ibres, these occasionally forming shallow suricial areoles; goniocysts
not seen. Associated algae Trebouxia sp., 10–15
µm diam.
Chemistry: stictic acid, or no substances detected
in about half the specimens.
substrate affinity: apparently early successional
on recently decorticated wood: six of the eleven
recent collections seen are from hard snags, one
from hard wood of a bridge deck, and four from
hard logs.
maCroeCology: mainly in mid-elevation, montane
conifer forests.
This is one of the most geographically restricted of
the new species described here, according to present knowledge. It is known only from subcontinental regions in the Rocky Mountains and nearby
mountain ranges in a line running from the northern British Columbia to western Montana, with
two occurrences in central Canada.
Xylographa stenospora possesses the same gray
pigment known from other members of the X.
parallela group but in no other species is it as
dominant. As a result, the ascomata are typically
jet black, a good ield character for recognition. In
addition, the ascomata of X. stenospora have not
been seen to break or peel off the substrate as is
common in X. pallens, X. rubescens and sometimes X. parallela. X. stenospora is similar to X.
difformis but the latter species always has a well
developed suricial thallus and contains norstictic
acid, in addition to possessing longer ascospores
(Table 4).
additional speCimens examined: Canada: British Columbia, Mile 81 Alaska Highway, 10 Jul 1967, J.W. Thomson
71
23452 & T. Ahti (CANL); Wells Gray Prov. Park: Philip
Lake Meadows, 14 Jun 1978, T. Goward 78-383 (UBC);
East Kootenays, White River area, 28 Jul 2005, T. Spribille 16628 (UBC); ibid., 31 Jul 2005, T. Spribille 16884
(UBC); East Kootenays, Rocky Mountains, White River
region E of Canal Flats, Moscow Road, 50°20.559‘N,
115°35.277‘N, 1062 m, 01 Aug 2005, T. Spribille 16952
(UBC); Kootenay River E of Canal Flats, Dry Creek, 04
Aug 2005, T. Spribille 17204 (UBC); Selkirk Mountains,
Incomappleux River drainage, Boyd Creek, on worked
wood of bridge deck, 23 Aug 2005, T. Spribille 18256
(GZU); Selkirk Mountains, Goat Range, Dennis Creek,
18 Jul 2006, T. Spribille 20224 (GZU); Mud Lake, C. R.
Björk 13454 (UBC); Manitoba, W shore of Blueberry
Lake, S of Lake Kisseynew, ca. 35 km NE of Flin Flon,
54°54’27”N, 101°26’33”W, 15 Jun 2003, I.M. Brodo
31221B (CANL); Northwest Territories, Keewatin, N
end of Lake Ennadai, 19 Jul 1960, J. W. Thomson 20773
(CANL); U.S.A.: Montana, Glacier Co., Glacier National Park, Lower Two Medicine Lake, Scenic Point
Trail just above trailhead, 15 Oct 2007, T. Spribille s.n.
(GZU); Lincoln Co., Ten Lakes Scenic Area, Wolverine
Basin, 21 Jul 2006, T. Spribille 20345 (GZU); Washington, Spokane Co., Riverside State Park, C.R. Björk
14172 (UBC).
Xylographa trunciseda (Th. Fr.)
Minks ex Redinger (Fig. 22).
Rabenhorsts Kryptogamenlora 9, Abt. 2/1: 216 (1938);
Lecidea trunciseda Th. Fr., Lichenographia Scandinavica, pars secunda: 467 (1874). Type: [Sweden:]
Dalsland, Heden i Laxarby, 1870, J. Hulting s.n. (LD1163605, lectotype, designated here; H, isolectotype).
TLC: confriesiic acid.
= Xylographa parallela f. elliptica Nyl. apud Leight.,
Lich. Fl. Great Britain: 391 (1879). Type: [United
Kingdom: Scotland,] ad ligna vetusta putrefacta apud
Blaire Athole, JMC [= J.M. Crombie] (H-NYL 4665,
holotype!). TLC: confriesiic acid. According to Leighton
(1879), the specimen was collected in 1872.
Ascomata with lateral growth of trunciseda type,
forming chains with next generation ascomata regenerating from the outer tips of empty excipular
shells; form broadly ellipsoid, 0.2–3.9 × 0.09–0.24
mm, L/W ratio 2.22±0.48; disc concave to lat,
light to dark brown, matte, with inconspicuous,
thin, brown margin, concolourous with the disc,
not lexuose; rarely prominent; exciple of laterally
interwoven hyphae, appearing paraplectenchymatous in vertical section, lush with the hymenium
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
72
T. Spribille et al.
Fig. 22. Xylographa trunciseda (Th. Fr.) Minks ex Redinger A, B, habit dry (A) and moistened (B); C, habit of ascomata, in water, showing spent “shells” of dead exciples; D, section of ascoma, showing regenerative ascoma beneath
“shell” of spent exciple, in LCB; E, goniocysts lined up inside xylem, in water; F, asci, in ILugols after pretreatment with
KOH. A, B, C: Tønsberg 40446 (BG, DNA voucher 1051); D, Muggia s.n. (TSB, DNA voucher 817); E, F: Canada,
British Columbia, Björk 12399 (UBC, DNA voucher 2387). Scale bars: A, B, 2 mm; C, 50 µm; D, 20 µm; E, F, 10 µm.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
surface in section or occasionally with “laps”,
20–45(–67) µm wide; excipular hyphae pigmented light brown externally, inner excipular hyphae
faintly birefringent and POL+; hypothecium 30–
50(–70) µm tall, hyaline; hymenium easily separating from exciple in gentle water squash, 60–85 µm
tall, hyaline or hazy yellow-brown, hemiamyloid
(ILugols+ blue-green à rust red) in all samples studied, consisting of asci 57–75(–90) × 12–15(–19)
µm embedded in a matrix of slender, sparsely
branched paraphyses 1.2–2.0 µm at midpoint, distally thickened to 3.5 µm in the apical cells, these
sprawling over the surface of the hymenium, with
pale brown wall pigments; ascospores 8/ascus, ellipsoid, (8.5–)10.1–11.3(–13) × (4.5–)5.2–6.1(–7)
µm (L/W ratio 2.22±0.48) (n = 41). Conidiomata
not seen. Sterile hyphae sprawling in surrounding
xylem cells, forming lichenized goniocysts around
single to multiple algal cells, the goniocysts with
paraplectenchymatous “cortex”, 10–40 µm diam,
mostly endosubstratal, the “thallus” thus appearing
similar to a bioilm. Associated algae chlorococcoid, 8–15 µm diam.
Chemistry: confriesiic acid constant and major in
all samples.
substrate affinity: on conifer logs, also infrequently on lignum of Betula, rare on snags.
maCroeCology: in old forests in the boreal and
oroboreal zones, circumboreal.
Xylographa trunciseda is a widespread, though
much misunderstood species that has been inadequately explained in the literature; nearly ¾ of
the material seen from northern Europe was iled
under another name. It is in fact easy to recognize
once the habit of the short, “American football”shaped ascomata (Fig. 22B, C) is understood, and
it possesses a characteristic chemistry, as explained
by Brodo (1992). In a few specimens (e.g. Brodo
18257, CANL, F) the exciple is strongly swollen
and nearly eclipses the disc when dry, however
these specimens are anatomically and chemically
concordant with X. trunciseda. We further obtained
73
DNA sequences for at least one such specimen
(Björk 12399, UBC) and veriied that they not differ from those of typical X. trunciseda.
Xylographa trunciseda was one of the few lichen
species in a recent study to be statistically signiicantly associated with older forests (Bunnell et
al. 2008), and its ecology as an oldgrowth forest
species has been borne out by years of ield observation. The overwhelming majority of material of
X. trunciseda seen from both northern and central
Europe was collected before 1950, and the species
should be considered highly threatened here due to
loss of substrate and habitat. The species is known
from Europe, Atlantic Maritime Canada, and western North America from Alaska to Colorado (Spribille & Björk 2008) and is reported here as new to
Asia, the Czech Republic, Germany and Greece.
exsiCCate: Finland: Norrlin & Nylander, Herb. Lich.
Fenn. 789 (BM!, G!, H!, as X. parallela f. pallens).
additional speCimens examined (only previously unpublished specimens, see also Spribille & Björk
2008): Austria: Salzburg, Pongau, Gasteiner-Tal, SE
von Böckstein, Anlauftal, zwischen der Ortschaft Anlauftal und dem Gasthof Marienbad, 1190 m, 28 Feb
1994, H. Wittmann s.n. (LI); Styria, Sölktal, slope
above Breitlahnhütte, 26 Sept 2011, T. Spribille & H.
Mayrhofer s.n. (GZU); Canada: Alberta, Jasper National Park, Miette Hot Springs, N slope at the campground
mountain, 4 Aug 1962, A. Henssen 14403i & R.F. Cain
(H, sub Ptychographa xylographoides); British Columbia, Zopkios Ridge, Coquihalla Highway, 22 May
1993, I.M. Brodo 28489 (CANL); Graham Island, ca.
4 miles W of Tow Hill, 13 Jul 1971, I.M. Brodo 18257
(CANL, F); Moresby Island, Sandspit, 19 Jun 1967, I.
M. Brodo 10069 (F); Newfoundland, Grand Falls Distr.,
Sandy Lake Dam, 17 Jul 1956, T. Ahti 7948 (H); Québec, Pontiac County, Parc de la Vérendrye, 47°14’N,
76°47’W, 5 Jul 1970, I.M. Brodo 16756 (CANL); China: Yunnan, Jian Chuan Co., San Jiang Bin Liu area,
trailhead to mt. Lao Juen Shan, 3800 m, 26°37’56.2”N,
99°43’30.8”E, 18 Oct 2002, C. Printzen 7275 p.p. (FR);
Czech Republic: [province not indicated,] Lichenes Bohemiae, na starém dříví v Krkonoších, 1931, V. Kut’ak
s.n. (GZU); Finland: Satakunta, Kankaanpää, 1937, M.
Laurila (H); Tavastia australis, Tammela, Kuusto, 1869,
A. Kullhem (H), Ylöjärvi, Pengonpohja, 5 Jun 1921, A.
A. Sola (H); Germany: [Bavaria,] Nationalpark Bayerischer Wald, Bayerisch-Böhmischer Wald, am Weg von
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
74
T. Spribille et al.
Fig. 23. Xylographa vermicularis T. Sprib. A, B, habit of type material, A dry, B moistened; C, D, habit of Alaskan
material, C dry, D moistened; E, ascomatal section, in water; F, asci, ascospores and paraphyses, in ILugols after pretreatment with KOH. A, B, F: holotype; C, D, E: U.S.A., Alaska, Spribille 27762 (GZU, DNA voucher 821). Scale bars: A,
B, 0.2 mm; C, D, 0.5 mm; E, 20 µm; F, 10 µm.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
der Schwarzbachklause zum Kirchlinger Stand, 19 Aug
1984, J. Poelt s.n. (GZU); Greece: Epirus, along Aoos
River, 39°57’08”N, 21°03’10”E, on Pinus nigra wood,
965 m, 06 Jul 2005, T. Spribille 16060 (GZU); Russia: Khabarovskiy Krai De Kastri-Komsomolsk route,
30 km (air line) WSW of De Kastri, near watershed
divide between Chistiy and Khanda River watersheds,
51°23.260’N, 140°21.758’E, 135 m, 20 Jul 2009, T.
Spribille 31080 & L. Yakovchenko (GZU); foothills of
the Etkil’-Yankanskiy Mountains, Amgun’ River region,
9.7 km (air line) due N of Berozovyy, accessed via garbage landill road, 51°46.193’N, 135°41.045’E, elev. 550
m, 24 Jul 2009, T. Spribille 31282 & L. Yakovchenko
(GZU, LE); Sweden: Södermanland, Västermo, Malmberga, 1881, O.G. Blomberg p.p. (BM, F, G); ibid., 1882,
O.G. Blomberg s.n. (M); U.S.A.: California, Del Norte
Co., Siskiyou National Forest, Sanger Lake, 1760-1830
m, 11 June 1984, T. Ahti 42608 & D. Norris (H); Oregon, Hood River Co., along Hwy. 38, 8 km SE of Mt.
Hood, along highway, at snowmobile parking area (Teacup Snopark Parking), 1307 m, 20 Sep 2008, T. Spribille
29876 (GZU); Vermont, Underkill, 18 May 1880, C.
Pringle 519 (FH).
Xylographa vermicularis T. Sprib.,
sp. nov. (Fig. 23). Mycobank No.: MB
805262.
Similar to X. trunciseda (Th. Fr.) Minks ex
Redinger, but differing in the longer and broader
ascospores 12.2–14.1 × 6.8–8.4 µm, and the chemistry (confriesiic and stictic acids); also similar to
X. vitiligo (Ach.) J.R. Laundon, but differing in the
high density of ascomata, the larger ascospores and
the presence of confriesiic acid.
Type: Russia: Khabarovskiy Krai, Khomi Mountains, De
Kastri-Komsomolsk route, between Tsimmermannovka
and Chernyy Mys; Gorelaya Mountain, logging road S
into mountains, Khivanda Creek drainage, 51°08.565’N,
139°09.775’E, Abies nephrolepis-Picea jezoensis forest,
logged areas, lignicolous on logs, 460 m, 21 Jul 2009,
T. Spribille 31246, C. Printzen & L. Yakovchenko (H,
holotype; F, FR, GZU, LE, M, NY, TNS, UBC, isotypes)
Etymology: from Latin vermiculus, little worm, referring
to the habit of the ascomata when dry.
Ascomata with growth of trunciseda-type, proliferating laterally; form ellipsoid to long-ellipsoid,
lexuose-vermiform, acute at the tips, 0.18–0.48 ×
0.09–0.21 mm, L/W ratio 2.19±0.57; disc concave,
75
swelling to lat when wet, beige to pale brown,
matte, with thin, pale margin, inconspicuous to
prominent, sometimes forming “laps”; exciple of
laterally interwoven hyphae, appearing paraplectenchymatous in vertical section, lush with the
hymenium surface or overtopping it in section, 17–
50 µm wide; excipular hyphae pigmented brown
externally, partially or wholly birefringent in cell
walls (POL+); hypothecium 40–90 µm deep, hyaline; hymenium (40–)80–120 µm deep, hyaline,
hemiamyloid (ILugols+ blue-green à rust red) or
euamyloid (ILugols+ blue), with a striking salmon
hue when ILugols is cleared with KOH, consisting of
asci 72–100 × 15–19 µm embedded in a matrix of
long, slender, sparsely branched, gangly paraphyses 1–1.5 µm at midpoint, distally moniliform and
thickened to 2.5–3 µm in the apical cells, looping
onto top of hymenium, unpigmented or with pale
brown wall pigments; ascospores 8/ascus, broadly
ellipsoid, (11–)12.2–14.1(–17.5) × (5.5–)6.8–8.4(–
11) µm (L/W ratio 1.77±0.2) (n = 59). Conidiomata adjacent to ascomata but segregated, mostly immersed, globose, to 90 µm diam, with light brown
paraplectenchymatous wall; conidia short-iliform
or long-bacilliform, straight, 10–12 × ca. 0.7 µm.
Sterile hyphae at least sometimes amyloid, ILugols+
blue in patches below ascoma; contacting endosubstratal algal plugs to 250 × 100 µm, becoming
conluent, displacing wood ibres when wet and
swelling, and given the thallus an “unkempt” appearance; thallus (in combination with surface
wood grain) acquiring a whitish gray to metallic
gray hue when dry; goniocysts rare, present in delimited soralia in few specimens, unpigmented.
Associated algae chlorococcoid, 8–15 µm diam.
Chemistry: confriesiic acid (major), stictic acid
(submajor to trace), rarely confriesiic acid alone.
substrate affinity: on wood of logs and decorticated branches of conifers, once on Betula, in
the type specimen spreading secondarily as small
thalli onto Cladonia squamules; also once on Abies
nephrolepis bark.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
76
T. Spribille et al.
maCroeCology: in high latitude conifer forests
in the summer-wet, winter-dry (‘monsoonal’) climates of the Russian Far East, Japan and central
Alaska; at altitudes of sea level to 1200 m.
Xylographa vermicularis was irst seen by us in a
collection from the island of Sakhalin and has subsequently been discovered at several near-coastal
sites on the mainland of the Russian Far East, as
well as Japan and Alaska. Especially characteristic
for X. vermicularis is a metallic gray thallus that
develops below a thin layer of wood ibres and distends it when wet. The combination of confriesiic
and stictic acids is diagnostic. Xylographa vermicularis strongly resembles X. erratica and can be
macroscopically impossible to distinguish from it,
especially when dry. However, in section it is easily separated by its much deeper hymenium and the
size of its ascospores, which are among the largest
in the genus, and the two are easily separated by
TLC (see Table 3, p. 43 for further comparisons).
Xylographa vermicularis is closely related to X.
vitiligo and this relationship is strongly supported
in both the Bayesian and maximum likelihood
analyses. More work is needed in this group. The
species pair X. vermicularis-X. vitiligo is the only
one in which the respective species are not reciprocally monophyletic, which may be caused by the
inclusion of a Chilean sample of X. aff. vermicularis in the tree. This specimen is morphologically
close to X. vitiligo but possesses the chemistry of X.
vermicularis, and is genetically divergent enough
from both to be unresolved in our current topology. A similar sorediate specimen with stictic and
confriesiic acids has also been seen in historical
material from southern Siberia (Brenner 483d, H).
additional speCimens examined: Japan: Hokkaido,
Ishikari Prov., Kamikawagun, Kamikawacho, just S
Daisetsukogen hot spring hotel (Onsen), alt. 1200 m,
43°37.30’N, 142°56’E, humid, oldgrowth coniferous forest with Abies sachalinensis, Picea glehnii and
P. jezoensis, 1995, T. Tønsberg 23210-11 (BG); Russia: Sakhalinskaya Oblast’, [Sakhalin Island], Noglikskiy Rayon, 2 km S of Nogliki, 51°45’30.1”N,
143°05’48.5”E, 26 Jul 2004, C. Printzen 9388 (FR); Pri-
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
morskiy Krai, Oblachnaya Mountain, 20 km (air line) E
of Yasnoye, 43°40.617’N, 134°12.761’E , 21 Aug 2007,
T. Spribille 23687 & P. Krestov (GZU); Kamchatka,
southern slope of Tolbachik Volcano, 55°37’45.5”N,
160°12’40”E, 560 m, D.E. Himelbrant & I.S. Stepanchikova s.n. (H); eastern Kamchatka, Elizovsky District,
Kronotsky Nature Reserve, 55°08’10”N, 159°58’55”E,
330-340 m, 03 Aug 2009, D.E. Himelbrant & I.S. Stepanchikova s.n. (H); Khabarovskiy Krai, De Kastri-Lazarev route, Vidanovo wetland complex, swampy valley
of the River Psyu, ca. 1.7 km E of Vidanovo, 6.5 km W
of seashore, 51°59.759’N, 141°15.000’E, 3 m elev, 16
Jul 2009, T. Spribille 30863 (H); 33.7 km (air line) due
W of Lazarev, up small side road in Sredniy Khrebet
Mountains, between Studeniy and Zvuchnaya streams,
52°13.451‘N, 141°00.428‘E, corticolous on bark patches
of log, probably of Abies nephrolepis, 56 m elev., 16 Jul
2009, C. Printzen, L. Yakovchenko & T. Spribille 30992
(GZU, H); Bogorodskoe-De Kastri route, 30.5 km (air
line) N of De Kastri, along main road, 51°44.699’N,
140°49.350’E, 69 m elev, 19 Jul 2009, T. Spribille 31075
(LE); Bureinskiy Zapovednik, upper reach of the Pravaya Bureya River, Tsarskaya Dorogа, small unnamed
stream ca. 1200 m N of patrol cabin ‘Staraya Medvezhka’, 52°09.318’N, 134°19.035’E, 882 m, 4 Aug 2009,
T. Spribille 31902 & L. Yakovchenko (GZU); U.S.A.:
Alaska, Kenai Peninsula, Russian River, 9 Aug 2008, T.
Spribille 27320 (GZU); Denali Borough, Summit Lake,
Parks Highway, 63°07.411‘N, 149°27.447‘W, lignicolous, 587 m, 17 Aug 2008, T. Spribille 27762 (GZU);
Denali Borough, wetlands along Chulitna River below
Buckskin Glacier, 62°49.220’N, 150°07.173’W, 312 m,
20 Aug 2008, T. Spribille 28105 (NY); ibid., T. Spribille
28121 (ALA).
additional speCimens examined (X. aff. vermicularis):
Chile: Prov. Antártica Chilena, Comuna Cabo de Hornos, N shore of Isla Navarino, N slopes of Pico de la
Bandera from Río Robalo dam to 400 m marker, on Nothofagus log, 22 Jan 2013, W.R. Buck 60823 (NY); Russia: [Krasnoyarsk Krai,] Guv. Jenisejsk, Ust-Kureika,
66°20’n. Br., auf Holz, 18.9.1876, M. Brenner 483d (H).
Xylographa vitiligo (Ach.) J.R. Laundon (Fig. 24)
Lichenologist 2: 147 (1963). Spiloma vitiligo Ach.,
Methodus: 10, tab. 1, ig. 4 (1803). Type: [probably Sweden:] E. Acharius s.n. (BM-ACH, lectotype!). For lectotypiication see Holien &Tønsberg (2008).
= Agyrium spilomaticum Anzi, Comment. Soc. Crittog.
Ital. 2: 20 (1864); Xylographa spilomatica (Anzi) Th. Fr.,
Lichenogr. Scand.: 639 (1874). Type: [Italy: Lombardy,
Prov. Sondrio] Bormio, Anzi, Lich. Rar. Langob. Exs.
385 (UPS!, lectotype designated by Holien & Tønsberg
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
77
Fig. 24. Xylographa vitiligo (Ach.) J.R. Laundon A, habit; B, section of ascomatum showing exciple, asci and ascospores; C, whole soralium, showing concave habit, in SEM; D, detail of goniocysts, in SEM. All photos: Switzerland,
Graubünden, Poelt s.n. (M). Scale bars: A, 1 mm; B, 10 µm; C, 100 µm; D: 20 µm.
2008; also present in H-NYL p.m. 6769, but not studied
by TLC).
= Xylographa corrugans Norman, Bot. Not. 1872(2): 34
(1872). Type: Norway: Finnmark, in Alten ad Skaidi, sinus Rafsbotten, Norman (UPS, lectotype!). See Holien &
Tønsberg (2008) for lectotypiication.
Ascomata solitary or adjacent in groups to 3 mm
in diameter, rarely proliferating outwards at multiple points and forming “rings” (e.g. in P.A. Karsten
s.n., 1860, H), with lateral growth of truncisedatype, usually straight, occasionally slightly curved,
mostly ± rounded, ellipsoid or fusiform, rarely
substellate, 0.3–0.6 × 0.1–0.3 mm; margin often
relexed, dark brown to medium brown, becoming
light brown by age, often glossy, unpigmented towards the hymenium, to 0.06 mm wide; disc con-
cave to lat, rarely convex, grayish white to brown,
becoming pale brownish to rose in widely exposed
discs; exciple brown in outer part, the brown pigment K–, colourless towards the hymenium, 24–72
μm wide in uppermost part; hypothecium colourless, of thick-walled cells with narrow lumina,
48–72 μm deep, in lower part not well separated
from excipulum; POL+ birefringence present in
excipulum rim, at least in the inner, colourless part,
in epihymenium and sometimes also in upper part
of hymenium; hymenium brown above, otherwise
colourless, 72–108 μm deep, consisting of paraphyses 1–1.5 μm thick, widening to 2.5(–3.5) μm in
upper part, uppermost paraphysis cells brown; asci
narrowly clavate, 65–95 × 10–17 μm; ascospores
8/ascus, simple, mostly straight, sometimes slight-
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
78
T. Spribille et al.
ly curved, elongate with rounded ends to ellipsoid,
rarely obovoid or dacryoid, (8–)10.9–11.5(–15.5)
× (4–)4.9–5.5(–7)(L/W ratio 2.27±0.48) (n = 78).
Conidioma observed once (Tønsberg 23551) as a
rounded mass of conidia in ± squashed section of
an apothecium, conidia iliform, ± curved, (12–)
15–20 μm. Sterile hyphae lichenized, developing
in the wood, colourless, forming endosubstratal
areoles (tuberculae) which at irst are covered by
the uppermost layer of the wood, later bursting
open to form convex soralia producing goniocysts
(= soredia); soralia concave to slightly convex,
sometimes distinctly convex, at irst often brown
due to pigmentation of the external soredia, later,
when the external soredia have been shed, ±dirty
white, rounded, ellipsoid or fusiform, 0.2–0.6(–1.0)
× 0.2–0.3(–0.8) mm in diam, conluent soralia
forming elongate patches to several mm long; soredia colourless or, especially in the outwardly facing part of external soredia, brown, globose with
a more or less distinct paraplectenchymatous wall,
19–45 μm diam, becoming conglutinated; into colourless or brown, rounded to irregularly rounded
“consoredia”, these 22–50(–70) μm diam. Photobiont (endosubstratal and in episubstratal soredia/
consoredia) chlorococcoid, (6–)8–12(–15) μm.
Chemistry: stictic acid with satellites. Brown pigment in excipulum, epithecium and wall of soredia/consoredia: K–.
substrate affinity: on wood of logs, snags and
decorticated twigs, also on worked wood and
maritime driftwood; usually on conifers but also
recorded on Betula.
maCroeCology: in boreal and montane forests
from ca. 35°N in Arizona to the Arctic, from sea
level to treeline.
Xylographa vitiligo is a widespread species of logs
and snags in boreal and montane forests. It has
been widely reported in the past, though in some
regions old records may refer to X. septentrionalis, X. soralifera, or, in rare cases, X. schoieldii. X.
vitiligo is most easily distinguished from X. sepSymb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
tentrionalis by its often cavate soralia with apparently “soft” goniocysts. The goniocysts acquire the
“soft” or matte habit from the roughened surface
as seen in SEM (Fig. 24D). In X. septentrionalis,
by contrast, the goniocysts are smaller, brown,
and not roughened (Fig. 19F), and are not borne
in cavate soralia. X. vitiligo can be easily separated
from X. soralifera by chemistry (stictic as opposed
to fumarprotocetraric acid) and the greenish, convex soralia of X. soralifera. Both X. vitiligo and
X. soralifera commonly possess conglutinated and
conluent goniocysts (“consoredia”: Fig. 24E-F
and Fig. 24C-D); the goniocysts of X. septentrionalis and X. schoieldii, by contrast, remain largely
discrete (Figs. 18E-F, 19E-F).
We report Xylographa vitiligo here as new to China. Numerous specimens from the eastern Alps
were mapped by Heininger & Spribille (2009) and
are not repeated here.
exsiCCates: Austria: Arnold, Lich. Exs. 563 (H!, M!, as
X. minutula); Styria, Obermayer, Dupla Graec. Lich. 200
(M!); Styria, Obermayer, Dupla Graec. Lich. 680 (M!);
Styria, Obermayer, Lichenoth. Graec. 12–13: 260 (G!,
M!); Norway: Krypt. Exs. 2554 (BG!, F!, M!); Sweden:
Södermanland, Malme, Lich. Suecici Exs. 196 (M!);
Switzerland: Graubünden, Plantae Graecenses Lich.
347 (G!, M!); United Kingdom: [Scotland,] Vězda,
Lich. Sel. Exs. 1478 (M!); U.S.A.: Colorado, Weber,
Lich. Exs. 163 (BG!, for other replicates see X. rubescens and X. septentrionalis).
seleCted speCimens studied: Austria: [border area of
Tyrol and Salzburg,] Gerlosplatte, 3 km W of Krimml,
10 Sep 1973, I.M. Brodo 19978 (CANL); Canada:
Alberta, Bow River Forest Reserve, 10 Jun 1966, S.D.
MacDonald s.n. (CANL); British Columbia, Queen
Charlotte Islands, Huxley Island, 52°28’N, 131°21’W,
01 Jul 1971, I.M. Brodo 17517 (CANL, F); Wells Gray
Prov. Park, Phillip Lake Meadows, 52°20’N, 120°00’W,
14 Jun 1978, T. Goward 78-375 (UBC); Zopkios Ridge,
Coquihalla Highway, 49°36’N, 121°04’W, 22 May 1993,
I.M. Brodo 28489 (CANL); Manitoba, Lac Brochet area,
59°00’N, 101°28’W, Apr 1977, P.Y. Wong 975 (CANL);
Newfoundland, Gros Morne National Park, 3.2 km SW
of St. Paul’s, 24 Jun 1981, C.M. Wetmore 42781 (CANL,
mixed with X. trunciseda, see Spribille & Björk 2008);
Nunavut, East Pen Island area, 56°45’N, 88°45’W, Aug
1973, K.A. Kershaw s.n. (CANL-98581); Yukon, Wernecke Mtns., Carpenter Lake, 64°30’N, 135°06’W, 25
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
Jul 1972, G.W. Scotter 19361 (CANL, iled under Xylographa parallela); China: Yunnan, Jian Chuan Co.,
San Jiang Bin Liu area, trailhead to mt. Lao Juen Shan,
3800 m, 26°37’56.2”N, 99°43’30.8”E, 18 Oct 2002, C.
Printzen 7275 p.p. (FR); Norway: Sogn og Fjordane,
Gloppen, S of fjord Nordfjord, N of Mt Haugsvarden,
Grønlia, 61°50’N, 6°15’E, alt. 340 m, lignicolous on
Juniperus communis, 12 May 1998, T. Tønsberg 26070
(BG-L-66291); Nord-Trøndelag, Namsskogan, E of
Smalvatn, 65°04’N, 13°22’E, alt. 350–360 m, on Picea
abies, stump, 27 Sept 1981, T. Tønsberg 6279 (BG-L25425); Namsskogan, Børgefjell National Park, Namskroken, 65°05’N, 13°27’E, alt.: 400 m, on Picea abies,
wood of stump, 23 Aug 1995, T. Tønsberg 23549 (BGL-31466), 23550 (BG-L-1467), 23551 (BG-L-96392);
Nordland, Grane, Børgefjell National Park, Simskaret,
N of Simskarelva, 65°17.31’N, 13°38.02’E, alt. 420–440
m, lignicolous on hard wood of trunk of downed Pinus
sylvestris, 11 June 2011, T. Tønsberg 40977a (BG-L94187); Troms, Bardu, near Lappskardelva, 68°47.72’N,
18°34.34’E, alt. 220–240 m, lignicolous on wood of
79
?Betula, 15 July 2006, T. Tønsberg 36829 (BG-L83842); Bardu, SW of Innset, E side of river Dittielva,
near the rim of the canyon, 68°39.35’N, 18°47.11’E, alt.
340–360 m, lignicolous on trunk of Betula pubescens, 12
July 2010, T. Tønsberg 40181 (BG-L-89199); Finnmark,
Lebesby, Hopseidet, at the Gamvik/Lebesby municipality
border, 70°48.04’N, 27°43.80’E, alt. 1–20 m, lignicolous
on decayed wood on horizontal ground above the beach,
27 June 2010, T. Tønsberg 39978 (BG-L-94170); SørVaranger, Fredheim i Sydvaranger, [69°41’N, 30°8’E,
alt.: 15–70 m,] 3.VIII.1906, J.J. Havaas (BG-L-56163);
U.S.A.: Arizona, Greenlee County, Bear Wallow Wilderness, 33°36’00”N, 109°25’00”W, 07 Jun 1998, T.H.
Nash 41891a (ASU); Oregon, Lane Co., near mouth of
Gwynn Creek on Paciic Ocean, 44°17’N, 124°06’W, 23
Feb 1996, B. McCune 23438 (ASU); Washington, San
Juan Co., San Juan Island SE, American Camp, South
Beach, 48°27.4’N, 123°00.3’W, alt. 0–5 m, on wooden
fence at inner part of beach, 02 Oct 1998, T. Tønsberg
26778 (BG; duplicates will be distributed in Tønsberg,
Lich. Isid. Sor. Crust. Exs.).
Excluded taxa
Xylographa arctica Fuckel in Lindeman & Finsch,
Die zweite deutsche Nordpolarfahrt 2: 95 (1874).
Type: Greenland: Kaiser-Franz-Josefs-Fjord (G,
holotype!). The specimen at G bears the inscription
“Xylographa arctica n. sp. Salix? (arctica; Kaiser
Franz Joseph Fiord Nova Zemblia) Herbier Fuckel
1894”. The attribution of the specimen to Novaya
Zemlya must be taken as an error. Fuckel (1874)
indicated “ascos nondum inveni” (= asci not yet
found) and what he thought were coloured ascospores are large brown conidia similar to those in
Phaeoblastophora resinae (Fr. : Fr.) Partr. & Morgan-Jones; the specimen represents an unidentiied
hyphomycetous black fungus and does not belong
to Lecanoromycetes.
Xylographa orientalis Navrotska, Ukr. Bot. Zhurn.
33: 277 (1976). This species was described by
Navrotskaya (1976) from Tilia amurensis bark in
the Russian Far East, but original material could
not be found during a 2008 visit to KW nor in a
recent search of TU (A. Suija, pers. comm.).
Xylographa perangusta (Stirt.) Müll. Arg., Bull.
Herb. Boissier 2 (App. 1): 76 (1894); Arthonia perangusta Stirt., J. Linnean Soc. Bot. 14: 470 (1875).
Type: New Zealand: near Wellington, J. Buchanan (BM-001084674, isotype!; the holotype, in
GLAM, was seen by Galloway 2007). The “apothecia” are sporodochia, possibly aff. Tylophoron
(Arthoniomycetes).
Xylographa perminuta (Juss. ex Müll. Arg.) R.W.
Rogers, Muelleria 5: 33 (1982); Lecanora perminuta Juss. ex Müll. Arg., Bull. Herb. Boissier 1:
39 (1893, ‘1892’). Type: [Australia:] Victoria, Mt.
Macedon, F.R.M. Wilson (G, holotype!). May be a
species of Lecanora, as described.
Xylographa perparvula (Stirt.) Müll. Arg., Bull.
Herb. Boissier 2 (App. 1): 76 (1894); Arthonia
perparvula Stirt., Proc. Phil. Soc. Glasgow 10: 301
(1877). Type: New Zealand: not found, also not
found by Galloway (2007).
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
80
T. Spribille et al.
Xylographa scaphoidea Stirt., Grevillea 3: 35
(1874). Type: not found. Described by Stirton
(1874) from “ad alnum decorticatum prope Dalwhinnie et Grantown”, Scotland. The type could
not be found at GLAM or BM but may be in unsorted specimen backlogs at BM (H. Thüs, pers.
comm.).
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank the curators of the herbaria
ALA, BG, CANL, F, FH, FR, G, GZU, H, L, LD,
LI, M, MSC, NBM, NY, O, TO, TUR, UBC, UPS,
W and WU as well as Curtis Björk, Trevor Goward
and Bruce McCune for loans of specimens and the
kind people of BM, H, KW and VER, especially
Holger Thüs, Sergei Kondratyuk and Francesco
di Carlo, for their hospitality on visits to their herbaria. Andy Acton, Curtis Björk, Stephen Clayden,
Brian Coppins, Alan Fryday, Lucia Muggia, Göran
Thor and Tim Wheeler are thanked for kindly providing fresh material for molecular studies. Einar
Timdal provided us yet-unpublished sequences
of X. isidiosa, as well as a photo of the type of X.
hians, for which we are grateful. Robert Lücking
kindly took photographs of several specimens on
loan to F, Florian Ernemann assisted in the Pritzker
Lab and Edith Stabentheiner assisted us with scanning electron microscopy in Graz. Teresa Craighero assisted with thin layer chromatography at an
early stage of this project. Irwin Brodo and Einar
Timdal are thanked for their detailed reviews of an
earlier version of this manuscript and Inga Hedberg and Leif Tibell for copy-editing. This project
was made possible by a visiting scholar grant to TS
from the Field Museum (2008) and by a grant from
the Austrian Science Fund (FWF P25237).
Literature
Baloch, E., Lücking, R., Lumbsch, H.T., Wedin, M.
(2010). Major clades and phylogenetic relationships
between lichenized and non-lichenized lineages in
Ostropales (Ascomycota: Lecanoromycetes). Taxon
59:1483–1494.
Bendiksby, M., Timdal, E. (2013). Molecular phylogenetics and taxonomy of Hypocenomyce sensu
lato (Ascomycota, Lecanoromycetes) — extreme
polyphyly and morphological convergence. Taxon
62: 940–956.
Bao, J., Xia, H., Zhou, J., Liu, X., Wang, G. (2013).
Eficient implementation of Mr Bayes on multiGPU. Mol. Biol. Evol. 30:1471–1479 doi: 10.1093/
molbev/mst043
Brodo, I.M. (1992). Bryoria trichodes, Ochrolechia
oregonensis and Xylographa opegraphella new to
Europe. Graphis Scripta 4:61–65.
Baral, H.O. (1987). Lugols solution / IKI versus Melzers reagent: hemiamyloidity, a universal feature of
the ascus wall. Mycotaxon 29:399–450.
Bunnell, F.L., Spribille, T., Houde, I., Goward, T.,
Björk, C. (2008). Lichens on down wood in logged
and unlogged forest stands. Can. J. For. Res.
38:1033–1041.
Castresana, J. (2000). Selection of conserved blocks
from multiple alignments for their use in phylogenetic analysis. Mol. Biol. Evol. 17:540–552.
Barreno, E., Pérez-Ortega, S. (2003). Liquenes de la
Reserva Natural Integral de Muniellos, Asturias.
Consejeria de Medio Abiente, Ordenacion del Territorio e Infraestructuras del Principado de Asturias;
KRK Ediciones, Oviedo.
Clements, F.E., Shear, C.L. (1931). The genera of Fungi. H.W. Wilson Company, New York.
Behlen, S., Desberger, F.A. (1835). Naturgeschichte
und Beschreibung der Deutschen Forstcryptogamen. Erfurt and Gotha.
Coppins, B.J. (1983). A taxonomic study of the lichen
genus Micarea in Europe. Bull. Brit. Mus. (Nat.
Hist.), Bot. Ser. 11(2):1–214.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
Cubeta, M.A., Echandi, E., Abernethy, T., Vilgalys,
R. (1991). Characterization of anastomosis groups
of binucleate Rhizoctonia species using restriction analysis of an ampliied ribosomal RNA gene.
Phytopathology 81:1395–1400.
Culberson, C.F. (1972). Improved conditions and new
data for the identiication of lichen products by a
standardized thin-layer chromatographic method. J.
Chromatography 72:113–125.
Culberson, C.F., Johnson, A. (1982). Substitution of
methyl tert.-butyl ether for diethyl ether in standardizded thin-layer chromatographic method for lichen
products. J. Chromatography 238:483–487.
81
identiication of mycorrhizae and rusts. Mol. Ecol.
2:113–118.
Gargas, A., DePriest, P.T., Grube, M., Tehler, A.
(1995). Multiple origins of lichen symbioses in
fungi suggested by SSU rDNA phylogeny. Science
268:1492–1495.
Giavarini, V., Orange, A. (2009). Xylographa (Fr.) Fr.
(1836). In: The lichens of Great Britain and Ireland.
(Smith, C.W., Aptroot, A., Coppins, B.J., Fletcher,
A., Gilbert, O.L., James, P.W., Wolseley, P.A., eds.)
British Lichen Society, London, pp. 973-974.
Elix, J.A. (2005). New species of sterile crustose
lichens from Australasia. Mycotaxon 94:219–224.
Hall, T.A. (1999). BioEdit: a user-friendly biological
sequence alignment editor and analysis program for
Windows 95/98/NT. Nucleic Acids Symposium Ser.
41:95–98.
― (2011). Lichen phytochemistry III: further additions and amendments. Australasian Lichenology
68:22–26.
Harmand, J. (1900). Catalogue descriptif des lichens
observés dans la Lorraine. Bull. Soc. Sci. Nancy Sér.
2 16:46–124.
Elix, J.A.,Tønsberg, T., Wardlaw, J.H. (2004). The
structure of friesiic acid, a novel lichen substance
from Hypocenomyce friesii. Bibliotheca Lichenologica 88:103–109.
Hedlund, T. (1892). Kritische Bemerkungen über einige
Arten der Flechtengattungen Lecanora, Lecidea und
Micarea. Bih. K. Svenska Vet.-Akad. Handl.18(3):
1–104.
Ertz, D., Miadlikowska, J., Lutzoni, F., Dessein, S.,
Raspe, O., Vigneron, N., Hofstetter, V., Diederich,
P. (2009). Towards a new classiication of the Arthoniales (Ascomycota) based on a three-gene phylogeny focussing on the genus Opegrapha. Mycol. Res.
113:141–152. doi:10.1016/j.mycres.2008.09.002
Heininger, C., Spribille, T. (2009). The sorediate
species of Xylographa in Austria (Baeomycetales,
lichenized Ascomycetes). Herzogia 22:129–134.
Ertz, D., Tehler, A. (2011). The phylogeny of Arthoniales (Pezizomycotina) inferred from nucLSU
and RPB2 sequences. Fungal Divers. 49: 47–71.
doi:10.1007/s13225-010-0080-y
Fries, E.M. (1822 [“1823”]). Systema Mycologicum,
sistens fungorum ordines, genera et species, huc
usque cognitas, quas ad normam methodi naturalis
determinavit, disposuit atque descripsit. Volumen
II. Lundae
Fries, E. (1849). Summa Vegetabilium Scandinaviae.
Sectio posterior. pp. 259–572. A. Bonnier, Holmiae
et Lipsiae.
Fuckel, L. (1874). Endophytische Pilze. In: Die Zweite
Deutsche Nordpolarfahrt in den Jahren 1869 und
1870 unter Führung des Kapitän Karl Koldewey.
Zweiter Band. Wissenschaftliche Ergebnisse. (Verein für die deutsche Nordpolarfahrt in Bremen, eds.)
Brockhaus, Leipzig, pp. 90–96.
Galloway, D. (2007). Flora of New Zealand Lichens.
Revised Second Edition including Lichen-Forming
and Lichenicolous Fungi. – Manaaki Whenua Press,
Lincoln, New Zealand.
Hertel, H. (1984). Über saxicole, lecideoide Flechten
der Subantarktis. Nova Hedwigia Beih.79:399–499.
― (1987). Bemerkenswerte Funde südhemisphärischer,
saxicoler Arten der Sammelgattung Lecidea. Mitt.
Bot. Staatssammlung München 23:321–340.
Hertel, H., Rambold, G. (1990). Zur Kenntnis der
Familie Rimulariaceae (Lecanorales). Bibliotheca
Lichenologica 38:145–189.
Hodkinson, B.P., Lendemer, J.C. (2011). The orders
of Ostropomycetidae (Lecanoromycetes, Ascomycota): recognition of Sarrameanales and Trapeliales
with a request to retain Pertusariales over Agyriales.
Phytologia 93:407–412.
Holien, H., Tønsberg, T. (2008) Xylographa soralifera,
a new species in the X. vitiligo complex. Graphis
Scripta 20:58–63.
Huneck, S., Yoshimura, I. (1996). Identiication of
Lichen Substances. Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg
Körber, G.W. (1861). Parerga lichenologica. Breslau.
193–288 pp.
Leighton, W.A. (1879). The lichen-lora of Great Britain, Ireland and the Channel Islands. Third Edition.
Shrewsbury.
Gardes, M., Bruns, T.D. (1993). ITS primers with enhanced speciity for Basidiomycetes: application to
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
82
T. Spribille et al.
Lettau, G. (1911). Beiträge zur Lichenographie von
Thüringen. Hedwigia 51:176–220.
gal lineages are derived from lichen symbiotic
ancestors. Nature 411:937–940.
Liška, J. (2013). The signiicance of Körber’s ‘‘Typenherbar’’, with an explanation of the locality abbreviations on his labels. Lichenologist 45:25–33.
Mangold, A., Martin, M.P., Lücking, R., Lumbsch, H.T.
(2008). Molecular phylogeny suggests synonymy of
Thelotremataceae within Graphidaceae (Ascomycota: Ostropales). Taxon 57:476–486.
Lücking, R., Hawksworth, D.L. (2007). Names for
lichen-forming fungi introduced by Ciferri and
Tomaselli are illegitimate and not available for use,
except for three cases. Taxon 56:1274–1284.
Lumbsch, H.T. (1997). Systematic studies in the suborder Agyriineae (Lecanorales). J. Hattori Bot. Lab.
83:1–73.
Lumbsch, H.T., Huhndorf, S.M. (2010). Myconet Volume 14. Part One. Outline of Ascomycota –2009.
Part Two. Notes on Ascomycete Systematics. Nos.
4751-5113. Fieldiana Life and Earth Sciences
1:1–64.
Lumbsch, H.T., Schmitt, I., Döring, H.,Wedin, M.
(2001). ITS sequence data suggest variability of
ascus types and support ontogenetic characters as
phylogenetic discriminators in the Agyriales (Ascomycota). Mycol. Res. 105:265–274.
Lumbsch, H. T., Schmitt, I., Barker, D., Pagel, M.
(2006). Evolution of micromorphological and chemical characters in the lichen-forming fungal family
Pertusariaceae. Biol. J. Linnean Soc. 89: 615–626.
Lumbsch, H.T., Schmitt, I., Lücking, R., Wiklund, E.
(2007a). The phylogenetic placement of Ostropales
within Lecanoromycetes (Ascomycota) revisited.
Mycol. Res. 111:257–267.
Lumbsch, H.T., Schmitt, I., Mangold, A., Wedin, M.
(2007b). Ascus types are phylogenetically misleading in Trapeliaceae and Agyriaceae (Ostropomycetidae, Ascomycota). Mycol. Res. 111:1133–1141.
doi:10.1016/j.mycres.2007.06.016
Lutzoni, F., Kauff, F., Cox, C.J., McLaughlin, D.,
Celio, G., Dentinger, B., Padamsee, M., Hibbett, D.,
James, T.Y., Baloch, E., Grube, M., Reeb, V., Hofstetter, V., Schoch, C., Arnold, A.E., Miadłikowska,
J., Spatafora, J., Johnson, D., Hambleton, S.,
Crockett, M., Shoemaker, R., Sung, G.H., Lücking,
R., Lumbsch, H.T., O‘Donnell, K., Binder, M., Diederich, P., Ertz, D., Gueidan, C., Hansen, K., Harris,
R.C., Hosaka, K., Lim, Y.W., Matheny, B., Nishida,
H., Pister, D., Rogers, J., Rossman, A., Schmitt, I.,
Sipman, H., Stone, J., Sugiyama, J., Yahr, R., Vilgalys, R. (2004). Assembling the fungal tree of life:
progress, classiication, and evolution of subcellular
traits. Am. J. Bot. 91:1446-1480.
Lutzoni, F., Pagel, M., Reeb, V. (2001). Major fun-
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
Merrill, G.K. (1913). New or otherwise interesting
lichens from Vancouver Island and the Rocky
Mountains. The Ottawa Naturalist 27:117–121.
Miadłikowska, J., Kauff, F., Hofstetter, V., Fraker, E.,
Grube, M., Hafellner, J., Reeb, V., Hodkinson, B.P.,
Kukwa, M., Lücking, R., Hestmark, G., Otálora,
M.G., Rauhut, A., Büdel, B., Scheidegger, C.,
Timdal, E., Stenroos, S., Brodo, I.M., Perlmutter,
G.B., Ertz, D., Diederich, P., Lendemer, J.C., May,
P.F., Schoch, C., Arnold, A.E., Gueidan, C., Tripp,
E., Yahr, R., Robertson, C., Lutzoni, F. (2006). New
insights into classiication and evolution of the
Lecanoromycetes (Pezizomycotina, Ascomycota)
from phylogenetic analyses of three ribosomal
RNA- and two protein-coding genes. Mycologia
98:1088–1103.
Mugambi, G.K., Huhndorf, S.M. (2009). Parallel
evolution of hysterothecial ascomata in ascolocularous fungi (Ascomycota, Fungi). Syst. Biodivers.
7: 453–464.
Navrotska, I.L. (1976). On new species of the Xylographa genus. Ukr. J. Bot. 33:276–278. [In Ukrainian]
Nilsson, G. (1930) Lichenologiska bidrag. III. Botaniska Notiser 1930:344–359.
Nylander, W. (1857). Prodromus Lichenographiae
Galliae et Algeriae. Actes Soc. Linn. Bordeaux
21(1):249–468.
― (1858 [‘1857’]). Énumération générale des lichens
avec l’indication sommaire de leur distribution
géographique. Mém. Soc. Sci. Nat. Cherbourg
5:85–146.
Pérez-Ortega S., Spribille T. (2007). Bellemerella
ritae sp. nov. (Verrucariaceae), a new lichenicolous
ascomycete from northwest North America. Nova
Hedwigia 85:512–520.
Persoon, C.H. (1796). Observationes mycologicae,
s. descriptiones tam novorum tam notabiliorum
fungorum. Lipsiae.
Posada, D. (2008). jModelTest: phylogenetic model
averaging. Mol. Biol. Evol. 25:1253–1256.
Poulsen, R.S., Schmitt, I., Søchting, U., Lumbsch,
H.T. (2001). Molecular and morphological studies
on the subantarctic genus Orceolina (Agyriaceae).
Lichenologist 33:323–329.
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
Prieto, M., Wedin, M. (2013). Dating the diversiication
of the major lineages of Ascomycota. PLoS ONE
8(6):e65576
Räsänen, V. (1939). Die Flechtenlora der nördlichen
Küstengegend am Laatokka-See. Ann. Bot. Soc.
Zool.-Bot. Fenn. Vanamo 12(1):1–240.
Redinger, K. (1938). Familie Graphidaceae. Rabenhorsts Kryptogamenlora 9(2/1):181–404.
Rivas Plata, E., Lumbsch, H.T. (2011). Parallel evolution and phenotypic disparity in lichenized fungi:
a case study in the lichen-forming fungal family
Graphidaceae (Ascomycota: Lecanoromycetes:
Ostropales). Mol. Phyl. Evol. 61:45–63.
Rivas Plata, E., Parnmen, S., Staiger, B., Mangold,
A., Frisch, A., Weerakoon, G., Hernández M., J.E.,
Cáceres, M.E.S., Kalb, K., Sipman, H.J.M., Common, R.S., Nelsen, M.P., Lücking, R., Lumbsch,
H.T. (2013). A molecular phylogeny of Graphidaceae (Ascomycota, Lecanoromycetes, Ostropales)
including 428 species. MycoKeys 6:55–94.
Ryan, B.D. (2004a). Xylographa. In: Lichen lora of
the Greater Sonoran Desert Region. Volume 2.
(Nash III, T.H., Ryan, B.D., Diederich, P., Gries, C.,
Bungartz, F., eds.) Lichens Unlimited, Tempe, AZ.
USA, pp. 612–616.
― (2004b). Lignoscripta. In: Lichen lora of the Greater Sonoran Desert Region. Volume 2. (Nash III,
T.H., Ryan, B.D., Diederich, P., Gries, C., Bungartz,
F. eds.) Lichens Unlimited, Tempe, AZ. USA, pp.
350–351.
Ronquist, F., Huelsenbeck, J.P. (2003). MrBayes 3:
Bayesian phylogenetic inference under mixed models. Bioinformatics 19:1572–1574.
Santesson, R. (1993). The lichens and lichenicolous
fungi of Sweden and Norway. SBT-förlaget, Lund.
Santesson, R., Moberg, R., Nordin, A., Tønsberg,
T., Vitikainen, O. (2004). Lichen-forming and
lichenicolous fungi of Fennoscandia. Museum of
Evolution, Uppsala.
Schmitt, I., Lumbsch, H.T. (2004). Molecular phylogeny of the Pertusariaceae supports secondary
chemistry as an important systematic character set
in lichen-forming ascomycetes. Mol. Phyl. Evol.
33:43–55.
Schmitt, I., Lumbsch, H.T., Søchting, U. (2003a).
Phylogeny of the lichen genus Placopsis and its
allies based on Bayesian analyses of nuclear and
mitochondrial sequences. Mycologia 95:827–835.
Schmitt, I., Martin, M.P., Türk, R., Lumbsch, H.T.
(2003b). Phylogenetic position of the genera Melanaria, Varicellaria and Thamnochrolechia (Pertusariales). Bibliotheca Lichenologica 86:147–154.
83
Schmitt, I., Yamamoto, Y., Lumbsch, H.T. (2006). Phylogeny of Pertusariales (Ascomycotina): resurrection of Ochrolechiaceae and new circumscription of
Megasporaceae. J. Hattori Bot. Lab. 100:753–764.
Schoch, C.L., Kohlmeyer, J., Volkmann-Kohlmeyer, B.,
Tsui, C.K., Spatafora, J.W. (2006). The halotolerant fungus Glomerobolus gelineus is a member of
Ostropales. Mycol. Res. 110:257–263.
Schoch, C.L., Sung, G.H., Lopez-Giraldez, F.,
Townsend, J.P., Miadlikowska, J., Hofstetter, V.,
Robbertse, B., Matheny, P.B., Kauff, F., Wang, Z.,
Gueidan, C., Andrie, R.M., Trippe, K., Ciufetti,
L.M., Wynns, A., Fraker, E., Hodkinson, B.P., Bonito, G., Groenewald, J.Z., Arzanlou, M., de Hoog,
G.S., Crous, P.W., Hewitt, D., Pister, D.H., Peterson, K., Gryzenhout, M., Wingield, M.J., Aptroot,
A., Suh, S.O., Blackwell, M., Hillis, D.M., Grifith,
G.W., Castlebury, L.A., Rossman, A.Y., Lumbsch,
H.T., Lücking, R., Büdel, B., Rauhut, A., Diederich,
P., Ertz, D., Geiser, D.M., Hosaka, K., Inderbitzin, P., Kohlmeyer, J., Volkmann-Kohlmeyer, B.,
Mostert, L., ODonnell, K., Sipman, H., Rogers,
J.D., Shoemaker, R.A., Sugiyama, J., Summerbell,
R.C., Untereiner, W., Johnston, P.R., Stenroos, S.,
Zuccaro, A., Dyer, P.S., Crittenden, P.D., Cole,
M.S., Hansen, K., Trappe, J.M., Yahr, R., Lutzoni,
F., Spatafora, J.W. (2009). The Ascomycota Tree of
Life: a phylum-wide phylogeny clariies the origin
and evolution of fundamental reproductive and ecological traits. Syst. Biol. 58:224–239. doi:10.1093/
sysbio/syp020
Sherwood, M.A. (1977). The Ostropalean fungi. Mycotaxon 5:1–277.
Silvestro, D., Michalak, I. (2011). raxmlGUI: a graphical front-end for RAxML. Org. Divers. Evol.
12:335–337.
Spribille, T., Björk, C.R. (2008). New records and
range extensions in the North American lignicolous
lichen lora. Mycotaxon 105:455–468.
Spribille, T., Thor, G., Bunnell, F.L., Goward, T., Björk,
C.R. (2008). Lichens on dead wood: species-substrate relationships in the epiphytic lichen loras of
the Paciic Northwest and Fennoscandia. Ecography
31:741–750.
Stamatakis, A. (2006). RAxML-VI-HPC: maximum
likelihood-based phylogenetic analyses with
thousands of taxa and mixed models. Bioinformatics
22:2688–2690.
Stenroos, S., Laukka, T., Huhtinen, S., Döbbeler,
P., Myllys, L., Syrjanen, K., Hyvönen, J. (2010).
Multiple origins of symbioses between ascomycetes
and bryophytes suggested by a ive-gene phylogeny.
Cladistics 26:281–300.
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
84
T. Spribille et al.
Stirton, J. (1874). New British lichens. Grevillea
3:33–37.
Thompson, J.D., Higgins, D.G., Gibson, T.J. (1994).
Clustal W: improving the sensitivity of progressive multiple sequence alignment through sequence
weighting, position-speciic gap penalties and
weight matrix choice. Nucleic Acids Res. 22:4673–
4680.
Tønsberg, T. (1992). The sorediate and isidiate, corticolous, crustose lichens in Norway. Sommerfeltia 14:
1–331.
Tuckerman, E. (1888). A synopsis of North American
lichens. Part II., comprising the Lecideacei, and (in
part) the Graphidaceae. E. Anthony and Sons, New
Bedford.
Vainio, E.A. (1883). Adjumenta ad lichenographiam
Lapponiae fennicae atque Fenniae borealis. Meddeland. Soc. Fauna Fl. Fenn.10:1–230.
― (1909). Lichenes in viciniis stationis hibernae
expeditionis Vegae prope pagum Pitlekai in Sibiria
septentrionali a Dre. E. Almquist collecti. Praefationem scripsit F. Almquist. Ark. Bot. 8(4):11–175.
― (1921). Lichenes novi in Fennia a V. Räsänen collecti. Meddeland. Soc. Fauna Fl. Fenn. 47:50–51.
Vilgalys, R., Hester, M. (1990). Rapid genetic identiication and mapping of enzymatically ampliied
ribosomal DNA from several Cryptococcus species.
J. Bacteriol. 172:4238–4246.
Vobis, G. (1980). Bau und Entwicklung der FlechtenPycnidien und ihrer Conidien. Bibliotheca Lichenologica 14:1–141.
Wedin, M., Döring, H., Gilenstam, G. (2004). Saprotrophy and lichenization as options for the same fungal
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
species on different substrata: environmental plasticity and fungal lifestyles in the Stictis-Conotrema
complex. New Phytol. 164:459–465.
Wedin, M., Wiklund, E., Crewe, A., Döring, H.,
Ekman, S., Nyberg, A., Schmitt, I., Lumbsch, H.T.
(2005). Phylogenetic relationships of Lecanoromycetes (Ascomycota) as revealed by analyses of
mtSSU and nLSU rDNA sequence data. Mycol. Res.
109:159–172.
White, T.J., Bruns, T.D., Lee, S., Taylor, J. (1990).
Ampliication and direct sequencing of fungal
ribosomal RNA genes for phylogenetics. In: PCR
protocols, a guide to methods and applications.
(Innis, M.A., Gelfand, D.H., Sninsky, J.J., White,
T.J., eds). Academic Press, San Diego, CA, USA,
pp. 315–322.
Wirth, V., Hauck, M., Schultz, M. (2013). Die Flechten
Deutschlands. Band 2. Ulmer, Stuttgart.
Zahlbruckner, A. (1922–1924). Catalogus Lichenum
Universalis. Band II. Gebrüder Borntraeger, Leipzig.
― (1931-1932). Catalogus Lichenum Universalis.
Band VIII. Gebrüder Borntraeger, Leipzig.
Zhou, S., Stanosz, G.R. (2001). Primers for ampliication of mt SSU rDNA, and a phylogenetic study of
Botryosphaeria and associated anamorphic fungi.
Mycol. Res. 105:1033–1044.
Zoller, S., Scheidegger, C., Sperisen, C. (1999). PCR
primers for the ampliication of mitochondrial small
subunit ribosomal DNA of lichen-forming ascomycetes. Lichenologist 31:511–516.
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
85
Index to generic and infrageneric taxa
Abies 69, 75, 76
Eucalyptus 42
abies, Picea 79
lexella, Elixia 53
abietina, Xylographa 56, 61
friesii, Hypocenomyce 18
abietinum, Hysterium 56
friesii, Xylopsora 18
Acacia 42
fusca, Malus 62
Agyrium 8, 59, 76
garryana, Quercus 40, 42
Ainoa 10, 20
glebulosa, Trapelia 11
amurensis, Tilia 79
glehnii, Picea 76
arctica, Xylographa 47, 50, 79
gmelinii, Larix 37
Arthonia 79
granulosa, Trapeliopsis 11
atrata, Tremolecia 11
Graphis 24
Baeomyces 10, 20
heterophylla, Tsuga 62
baeomyces, Dibaeis 10
Bellemerella 69
hians, Xylographa 12, 13, 20, 21, 27, 29, 37, 39, 40-42,
43, 50, 66, 80
Betula 56, 73, 75, 78, 79
Hymenelia 10, 20
betuloides, Nothofagus 42
Hysterium 8, 56
bjoerkii, Xylographa 11, 21, 24, 26, 27, 28-30, 43
Icmadophila 10, 20
borealis, Xylographa 47
icmalea, Placynthiella 10, 11, 45
carneopallida, Xylographa 11, 21, 27, 30-31, 54, 66
imbricata, Phyllobaeis 10
carneopallida, Xylographa rubescens var. 30
incerta, Xylographa 56
Casuarina 42
incrustans, Xylographa arctica var. 47, 50
Cladonia 75
incrustans, Xylographa sibirica var. 47
colensoi, Trapeliopsis 18
insularis, Lambiella 10, 20, 24, 25
communis, Juniperus 79
insularis, Lecidea 25
constricta, Xylographa 12, 21, 24, 26, 31-32
insularis, Rimularia 25
corrugans, Xylographa 77
involuta, Trapelia 11
crassithallia, Xylographa 21, 33, 34, 35
isidiosa, Hypocenomyce 42
Cupressus 37
isidiosa, Xylographa 12, 13, 18, 19, 21, 26, 42-45, 80
degelii, Xylographa abietina var. 50
jezoensis, Picea 75, 76
degelii, Xylographa rubescens var. 50, 55
Juniperus 79
Dibaeis 10, 20
kerguelensis, Placopsis 10
difformis, Xylographa 12, 20, 21, 28, 33-35, 54, 66, 71
lacustris, Hymenelia 10
difformis, Xylographa parallela var. 33
lagoi, Xylographa 13, 21, 24, 27, 43, 45-46
disseminata, Xylographa 12, 21, 26, 27, 28, 31, 36-37,
43
Lambiella 10, 20, 21, 24, 25
Elixia 8, 53
Larix 37, 58, 59
elliptica, Xylographa parallela f. 59, 71
lasiocarpa, Abies 69
ericetorum, Icmadophila 10
Lecanora 79
erratica, Xylographa 12, 20, 21, 27, 37-40, 42, 43, 49,
50, 76
Lignoscripta 9
erythrella, Phyllobaeis 10
lineare, Xylogramma 56
laricicola, Xylographa 56, 59
limborina, Rimularia 11, 20, 24, 25
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
86
T. Spribille et al.
linearis, Stictis 56
Placopsis 8, 10, 20, 24
linearis, Xylographa 56
Placynthiella 10, 20, 24, 42
Lithographa 8, 9, 10, 20, 21, 24
ponderosa, Pinus 67
macrophthalma, Placopsis 10
pruinodisca, Xylographa 21, 33, 34, 35
Malus 62
psephota, Lambiella 10, 20, 24, 25
melanocarpa, Hymenelia 10
Pseudotsuga 2, 30, 42, 67
menziesii, Pseudotsuga 2, 67
Ptychographa 8, 9, 11, 20, 21, 24, 73
Micarea 19
pubescens, Betula 79
mertensiana, Tsuga 69
pullata, Lecidea 59
micrographa, Xylographa 40, 42
Quercus 40, 42, 45
minutula, Xylographa 14, 20, 21, 56, 58, 59, 78
resinae, Phaeoblastophora 79
mooreana, Ainoa 10
Rimularia 9, 11, 20, 24, 25
nephrolepis, Abies 75, 76
ritae, Bellemerella 69
nigra, Pinus 75
nilssonii, Xylographa parallela var. 55
rubescens, Xylographa 14, 20, 21, 28, 30, 33, 35, 50,
52, 54, 55, 59-62, 66, 69, 71, 78
Nothofagus 42, 76
rufum, Agyrium 59
Opegrapha 24, 47, 56
rufus, Baeomyces 10
opegraphella, Xylographa 13, 20, 21, 27, 30, 33, 39,
42, 43, 47-50
sachalinensis, Abies 76
orientalis, Xylographa 79
scaphoidea, Xylographa 80
pallens, Xylographa 13, 21, 28, 35, 50-56, 58, 61, 62,
66, 71
schoieldii, Xylographa 14, 21, 26, 62-64, 78
Salix 79
pallens, Xylographa parallela f. 55, 73
septentrionalis, Xylographa 14, 20, 21, 26, 35, 45, 54,
62, 64-66, 78
pallens, Xylographa parallela var. 50, 53
sessitana, Xylographa parallela var. 56, 59
parallela, Opegrapha 56, 58
sibirica, Xylographa 47
parallela, Stictis 55, 59
sibirica, Xylographa sibirica var. 47
parallela, Xylographa 13, 14, 19, 20, 21, 25, 26, 28, 30,
33, 35, 42, 50, 53, 54, 55, 56-59, 61, 62, 64, 66, 69,
71, 73, 79
soralifera, Xylographa 14, 15, 21, 26, 55, 66, 67-69, 78
parallelum, Hysterium 56
parallelum, Xylogramma 56
parallelus, Lichen 56
perangusta, Arthonia 79
perangusta, Xylographa 79
perminuta, Lecanora 79
perminuta, Xylographa 79
perparvula, Arthonia 79
perparvula, Xylographa 79
petraea, Quercus 45
Phaeoblastophora 79
Phyllobaeis 10, 20
Picea 75, 79
Pinus 58, 59, 64, 67, 75, 79
placodioides, Trapelia 11
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
Spiloma 25, 76
spilomatica, Xylographa 76
spilomaticum, Agyrium 76
stenospora, Xylographa 15, 20, 21, 25, 69-71, 76
stictica, Opegrapha 47
Stictis 8, 25, 56, 59
subhians, Xylographa arctica var. 47, 50
subhians, Xylographa sibirica var. 47
sylvestris, Pinus 79
tesserata, Lithographa 10
Thamnolia 11
Thuja 28, 37
Tilia 79
Trapelia 11, 20, 24, 26
Trapeliopsis 11, 18, 20, 24
Tremolecia 11, 20
Molecular Systematics of Xylographa
87
trunciseda, Lecidea 71
trunciseda, Xylographa 15, 19, 21, 27, 30, 39, 40, 43,
53, 69, 71-75
Trebouxia 26, 37, 49, 71
Tsuga 62, 69
Tylophoron 79
uliginosa, Placynthiella 11
vermicularis, Thamnolia 11
vermicularis, Xylographa 15, 16, 20, 21, 26, 27, 39, 43,
74-76
vitiligo, Spiloma 76
vitiligo, Xylographa 16, 19, 20, 21, 26, 62, 64, 66, 67,
69, 75, 76-79
xylographoides, Ptychographa 11, 73
Xylographomyces 25
Xylopsora 8, 18
Symb. Bot. Ups. 37:1
ACTA UNIVERSITATIS UPSALIENSIS
SYMBOLAE BOTANICAE UPSALIENSES
VOL. I
H. G. Bruun, Cytological Studies in Primula. Uppsala 1932.
Ragnhild Grundell. Zur Anatomie von Myrothamnus labellifolia Welv. Uppsala 1933.
J. A. Nannfeldt, Poa rigens Hartm, versus Poa arctica R. Br. Uppsala 1934.
Sven Junell, Zur Gynäceummorphologie und Systematik der Verbenaceen und Labiaten nebst
Bemerkungen über ihre Samenentwicklung. Uppsala 1934.
5. J. A. Nannfeldt, Taxonomical and Plant-geographical Studies in the Poa laxa Group. A Contribution to
the History of the North European Montain Floras. Uppsala 1935.
1.
2.
3.
4.
VOL. II
1. H. O. Juel, Joachim Burser’s Hortus siccus. Uppsala 1936.
2. Nils Svedelius, The Apomeikotic Tetrad Division in Lomentaria rosea in Comparison with the Normal
Development in Lomentaria clavellosa. Uppsala 1937.
3. G. B. E. Hasselberg, Zur Morphologie des vegetativen Sprosses der Loganiaceen. Uppsala 1937
4. George F. Papenfuss, The Structure and Reproduction of Claudea multiida, Vanvoorstia spectabilis,
and Vanvoorstia coccinea. Uppsala 1937.
VOL. III
1. Gunnar Lohammar, Wasserchemie und höhere Vegetation schwedischer Seen. Uppsala 1938.
2. Nils Fries, Über die Bedeutung von Wuchsstoffen für das Wachstum verschiedener Pilze. Uppsala 1939.
3. Daniel Lihnell, Untersuchungen über die Mykorrhizen und die Wurzelpilze von Juniperus communis.
Uppsala 1939.
VOL. IV
1. Nils Fries, Researchers into the Multipolar Sexuality of Cyathus striatus Pers. Uppsala 1940.
2. Ewert Åberg, The Taxonomy and Phylogeny of Hordeum L. sect. Cerealia Ands. with special reference
to Thibetan Barleys. Uppsala 1940.
3. George F. Papenfuss, A Revision of the South African Marine Algae in Herbarium Thunberg. Uppsala
1940.
4. J. A. Nannfeldt, On the Polymorphy of Poa arctica R. Br., with Special Reference to its Scandinavian
Forms. Uppsala 1940.
5. Börje Åberg, Växtodling i artiicellt ljus (konstljuskultur) med särskild hänsyn till tomat. (Planzenkultur bei künstlichem Licht (Kunstlichtkultur) mit besonderer Berücksichtigung der Tomate.) Uppsala
1941.
VOL. V
1. Oskar Modess, Zur Kenntnis der Mykorrhizabildner von Kiefer und Fichte. Uppsala 1941.
2. Daniel Lihnell, Cenococcum graniforme als Mykorrhizabildner von Waldbäumen. Uppsala 1942.
3. Börje Åberg und Wilhelm Rodhe, Über die Milieufaktoren in einigen südschwedischen Seen. Uppsala
1942.
4. Daniel Lihnell, Tetramyxa rhizophaga Lihnell n. sp., ein Parasit in den Wurzeln von Juniperus communis L. Uppsala 1942.
VOL. VI
1. Gunnar Israelson, The Freshwater Floridae of Sweden. Studies on their Taxonomy, Ecology, and
Distribution. Uppsala 1942.
2. Erik Björkman, Über die Bedingungen der Mykorrhizabildung bei Kiefer und Fichte. Uppsala 1942.
3. Daniel Lihnell, Keimungsversuche mit Pyrolasamen. Uppsala 1942.
4. Nils Fries, Untersuchungen über Sporenkeimung und Mycelentwicklung bodenbewohnender Hymenomyceten. Uppsala 1943.
VOL. VII
1. Nils Hylander, Die Grassameneinkömmlinge schwedischer Parke mit besonderer Berücksichtigung
der Hieracia silvaticiformia. Uppsala 1943.
2. Nils Fries, Die Einwirkung von Adermin, Aneuerin und Biotin auf das Wachstum einiger Ascomyceten.
Uppsala 1943.
VOL. VIII
1. Börje Åberg, Physiologische und ökologische Studien über die planzliche Photomorphose. Uppsala
1943.
2. Gösta Lindeberg, Über die Physiologie ligninabbaunder Bodenhymenomyzeten. Uppsala 1943.
3. Elias Melin, Der Einluss von Waldstreuextrakten auf das Wachstum von Bodenpilzen, mit besonderer
Berücksichtigung der Wurzelpilze von Bäumen. Uppsala 1946.
VOL. IX
1. Nils Svedelius and Axel Nygren, On the Structure and Reproduction of Dictyurus purpurascens. Uppsala
1946.
2. Gösta Fåhræus, Studies in the Cellulose Decomposition by Cytophaga. Uppsala 1947.
3. H. Skuja, Taxonomie des Phytoplanktons einiger Seen in Uppland, Schweden. Uppsala 1948.
VOL. X
1. Wilhelm Rodhe, Environmental Requirements of Fresh-water Plankton Algae. Experimental Studies in
the Ecology of Phytoplankton. Uppsala 1948.
2. Auseklis Vegis, Über den Einluss der Aufbewahrungstemperatur auf die Dauer der Ruheperiode und
die Streckungsbereitschaft der ruhenden Winterknospen von Stratiotes aloides. Uppsala 1948.
3. Sven Österlind, Growth Conditions of the Alga Scenedesmus quadricauda with Special Reference to
the Inorganic Carbon Sources. Uppsala 1949.
4. Axel Nygren, Cytological and Embryological Studies in Arctic Poae. Uppsala 1950.
5. John Eriksson, Peniphora Cke sect. Coloratae Bourd. & Galz. A Taxonomical Study with Speical
Reference to the Swedish Species. Uppsala 1950.
VOL. XI
1. Birgitta Norkrans, Studies in Growth and Cellulolytic Enzymes of Tricholoma. With speical reference
to mycorrhiza formation. Uppsala 1950.
2. Bengt Kihlman, The permeability of the Nuclear Envelope and the Mode of Action of Purine Derivatives
on Chromosomes. Uppsala 1951.
3. Visvaldis Slankis, Über den Einluss von B-Indolylessigsäure und anderen Wuchstoffen auf das Wachstum von Kiefernwurzeln. I. Uppsala 1951.
4. Bengt Kihlman, Induction of Chromosome Changes with Purine Derivatives. Uppsala 1952.
5. K. H. Rechinger, Planzen aus Kurdistan und Armenien gesammelt von Prof. John Frödin. Uppsala
1952.
6. Ivar Ekdahl, Studies on the Growth and the Osmotic Conditions of Root Hairs. Uppsala 1953.
VOL. XII
1. Rolf Santesson, Foliicolous Lichens I. A Revision of the Taxonomy of the Obligately Foliicolous,
Lichenized Fungi. Uppsala 1952.
VOL. XIII
1. Nils Fries, Chemical Factors Controlling the Growth of the Decotylised Pea Seedling. Uppsala 1954.
2. Gunnar Degelius, The Lichen Genus Collema in Europe. Morphology, Taxonomy, Ecology. Uppsala
1954.
VOL. XIV
1. Auseklis Vegis, Über den Einluss der Temperatur und der täglichen Licht-Dunkel-Periode auf die
Bildung der Ruheknospen. Zugleich ein Beitrag zur Entstehung des Ruhezustandes. Uppsala 1955.
2. Börje Lövkvist, The Cardamine pratensis Complex. Outlines of its Cytogenetics and Taxonomy.
Uppsala 1956.
3. Lennart Holm, Etudes taxonomiques sur les Pléosporacées. Uppsala 1957.
VOL. XV
1. Olov Hedberg, Afroalpine Vascular Plants. A Taxonomic Revision. Uppsala 1957.
VOL. XVI
1. John Eriksson, Studies in the Heterobasidiomycetes and Homobasidiomycetes-Aphyllophorales of
Muddus National Park in North Sweden. Uppsala 1958.
2. Brita Lindeberg, Ustilaginales of Sweden (exclusive of the Cintractias on Caricoideae). Uppsala
1959.
3. Aino Käärik, Growth and Sporulation of Ophistoma and some other Blueing Fungi on Synthetic Media.
Uppsala 1960.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
VOL. XVII
Sven O. Björkman, Studies in Agrostis and Related Genera. Uppsala 1960.
Martin Johansson, Studies in Alkaloid Production by Claviceps purpurea. Uppsala 1962.
Axel Nygren, Artiicial and Natural Hybridization in European Calamagrostis. Uppsala 1962.
Björn Lindahl, The Inhibition of the Photosynthesis of Aquatic Plants by Tetramethylthiuram
Disulphide. Uppsala 1963.
Arnold Nauwerck, Die Beziehungen zwischen Zooplankton und Phytoplankton im See Erken. Uppsala
1963.
VOL. XVIII
Aino Henssen, Eine Revision der Flechtenfamilien Lichinaceae und Ephebaceae. Uppsala 1963.
Sven Nilsson, Freshwater Hyphomycetes. Uppsala 1964.
Karl-Ragnar Sundström, Studies of the Physiology, Morphology and Serology of Exobasidium.
Uppsala 1964.
Curt Forsberg, Environmental Conditions of Swedish Charophytes. Uppsala 1965.
Inga Hedberg, Cytotaxonomic Studies on Anthoxanthum odoratum L. s. lat. II. Investigations of some
Swedish and of a few Swiss population samples. Uppsala 1967.
VOL. XIX
1. Lena Junell, Erysiphaceae of Sweden. Uppsala 1967.
2. Bengt Jonsell, Studies in the North-West European Species of Rorippa s. str. Uppsala 1968.
3. Sven-Olof Norberg, Studies in the Production of Auxin and Other Growth Stimulating Substances by
Exobasidium. Uppsala 1968.
4. Birgitta Eriksson, On Ascomycetes on Diapensiales and Ericales in Fennoscandia. 1. Discomycetes.
Uppsala 1970.
VOL. XX
1. Nils Lundqvist, Nordic Sordariaceae s. lat. Uppsala 1972.
2. Gunnar Degelius, The Lichen Genus Collema with Special Reference to the Extra-European Species.
Uppsala 1974.
VOL. XXI
1. Mats Thulin, The Genus Wahlenbergia s. lat. (Campanulaceae) in Tropical Africa and Madagascar.
Uppsala 1975.
2. Leif Tibell, The Caliciales of Boreal North America. Taxomomy, ecological and distributional comparisons with Europe, and ultrastructural investigations of spores in some species. Uppsala 1975.
3. Kerstin and Lennart Holm, Nordic junipericolous Ascomycetes. Uppsala 1977.
VOL. XXII
1. Roland Moberg, The Lichen Genus Physcia and Allied Genera in Fennoscandia. Uppsala 1977.
2. Kerstin Haraldson, Anatomy and taxonomy in Polygonaceae subfam. Polygonoideae Meisn. emend.
Jaretzky. Uppsala 1978.
3. J. A. Nannfeldt, Anthracoidea (Ustilaginales) on Nordic Cyperaceae-Caricoideae, a concluding synopsis. Uppsala 1979.
4. Inga Hedberg (ed.). Parasites as Plant Taxonomists. Uppsala 1979.
1.
2.
3.
4.
VOL. XXIII
Leif Tibell, The Lichen Genus Chaenotheca in the Northern Hemisphere. Uppsala 1980.
J. A. Nannfeldt, Exobasidium, a taxonomic reassessment applied to the European species. Uppsala 1981.
Maud Wallsten, Changes of Lakes in Uppland, Central Sweden, during 40 years. Uppsala 1981.
Lars Jonsson, A Monograph of the Genus Microcoelea (Orchidaceae). Uppsala 1981.
VOL. XXIV
1. Mesin Tadesse, The Genus Bidens (Compositae) in NE Tropical Africa. Uppsala 1984.
2. Kálmán Vánky, Carpathian Ustilaginales. Uppsala 1985.
VOL. XXV
1. J. A. Nannfeldt, Pirottaea (Discomycetes inoperculati), a critical review. Mats Thulin, Revision of
Taverniera (Leguminosae-Papilionoideae). Uppsala 1985.
2. Sebsebe Demissew, The genus Maytenus (Celastraceae) in NE Tropical Africa and Tropical Arabia.
Uppsala 1985.
3. Bengt Jonsell, A monograph of Farsetia (Cruciferae). Uppsala 1986.
4. Roger Svensson and Marita Wigren, A survey of the history, biology and preservation of some retreating
synanthropic plants. Uppsala 1986.
VOL. XXVI
1. Olof Ryding, The Genus Aeollanthus s. lat. (Labiatae). Uppsala 1986.
2. Inga Hedberg (ed.), Research on the Ethiopian Flora. Uppsala 1986.
VOL. XXVII
1. Leif Tibell, Australasian Caliciales. Uppsala 1987.
2. Bengt and Lena Jonsell (eds.), Biosystematics in the Nordic lora. Uppsala 1986.
VOL. XXVIII
1. Ulla-Maj Hultgård, Parnassia palustris L. in Scandinavia. Uppsala 1987.
2. Lennart and Kerstin Holm, Studies in the Lophiostomataceae with emphasis on the Swedish species.
Uppsala 1988.
3. Inga Hedberg (ed.), Systematic Botany—a key science for tropical research and documentation.
Uppsala 1988.
VOL. XXIX
1. Mikael Hedrén, Justicia sect. Harnieria (Acanthaceae) in tropical Africa. Uppsala 1989.
2. Ensermu Kelbessa, Justicia sect. Ansellia (Acanthaceae). Uppsala 1990.
3. Svein Terje Iversen, The Usambara Mountains, NE Tanzania: Phytogeography of the vascular plant
lora. Uppsala 1991.
VOL. XXX
1. William Mziray, Taxonomic studies in Toddalieae Hook. f. (Rutaceae) in Africa. Uppsala 1992.
2. Suk-Pyo Hong, Taxonomy of the genus Aconogonon (Polygonaceae) in Himalaya and adjacent regions.
Uppsala 1992.
3. Nils Lundqvist and Roland Moberg (eds.), Hymenomycetes in the perspective of 200 years. Proceedings
of a symposium held in Uppsala September 5–8, 1994 in commemoration of Elias Fries. Uppsala
1995.
VOL. 31
1. Mats Wedin, The lichen family Sphaerophoraceae (Caliciales, Ascomycotina) in temperate areas of the
Southern Hemisphere. Uppsala 1995.
2. Mariette Manktelow, Phaulopsis (Acanthaceae)—a monograph. Uppsala 1996.
3. Ulla-Maj Hultgård, Karin Martinsson and Roland Moberg (eds.), The Nordic Flora—towards the
twenty-irst century. Uppsala 1996.
VOL. 32
1. Leif Tibell and Inga Hedberg (eds.), Lichen Studies. Uppsala 1997.
2. Jan-Eric Mattsson, Mats Wedin and Inga Hedberg (eds.), Swedish Lichenology. Uppsala 1999.
3. Göran Thor, Robert Lücking and Tatsuo Matsumoto, The foliicolous lichens of Japan. Uppsala 2000.
VOL. 33
1. Anders Nordin, Taxonomy and phylogeny of Buellia species with pluriseptate spores (Lecanorales,
Ascomycotina). Uppsala 2000.
2. Kåre Bremer, Birgitta Bremer and Mats Thulin, Introduction to phylogeny and systematics of lowering
plants. Uppsala 2004.
3. Inga Hedberg (ed.), Species Plantarum 250 years. Uppsala 2004.
VOL. 34
1. Göran Thor, Anders Nordin and Inga Hedberg (eds), Contributions to Lichen Taxonomy and Biogeography. Dedicated to Leif Tibell. Uppsala 2004.
VOL. 35
1. Karin Martinsson and Svengunnnar Ryman, Hortus Rudbeckianus. An enumeration of plants cultivated
in the Botanical Garden of Uppsala University during the Rudbeckian period 1655–1702. Uppsala
2007.
2. Inga Hedberg and Eva Persson (eds.), The Ethiopian Flora Project 1980 – 2009. Exploration,
collaboration, inspiration. Dedicated to Olov Hedberg. Uppsala 2011.
VOL. 36
1. an a a i and Leif Tibell, Polyblastia in Northern Europe and the adjacent Arctic. Uppsala 2012.
2. Eriksson O.E., Checklist of the non-lichenized ascomycetes of Sweden. Uppsala 2014.
VOL. 37
1. Toby Spribille, Philipp Resl, Teuvo Ahti, Sergio Pérez-Ortega, Tor Tønsberg, Helmut Mayrhofer & H.
Thorsten Lumbsch, Molecular systematics of the wood-inhabiting, lichen-forming genus Xylographa
(Baeomycetales, Ostropomycetidae) with eight new species. Uppsala 2014.